Improve Examination Transparency by releasing both Raw and Rescaled marks on result days!

The Issue

I am sure you have all seen my recent petition. First up I want to thank you all for your support, whether it was signing or simply commenting your department was not involved! Yet it is not over just yet.
The point of this post and petition is to now present a possible solution to future examination issues and confusion. I ask you to have an open mind to consider:

After all of this I believe important issues have come to light, relating to a lack of transparency within exams, within this difficult time of the pandemic, and university exams in general.
I propose discussing with the university, and maybe others, about the releasing of two marks for student results. The first, the Raw mark (mark before rescaling) and second the Actual mark (mark after rescaling).

I see this as an opportunity to rebuild trust over this exam period, for students to see harsh marking/rescaling may not be reason for worse grades. Additionally, if this 10% was to occur again, we would know straight away and can act; alongside the fact that if university policy stands and rescaling only affects a couple of %, then there should be no issue in releasing both the mark types.

Would this idea be attractive to all of you? If so I ask you to make a subject access request via data protection for your raw scores. If enough of us do this - it may have an impact. The email to do this is dataprotection@york.ac.uk

Thank you all once again, and I hope this can appeal to some of you!

This petition had 813 supporters

The Issue

I am sure you have all seen my recent petition. First up I want to thank you all for your support, whether it was signing or simply commenting your department was not involved! Yet it is not over just yet.
The point of this post and petition is to now present a possible solution to future examination issues and confusion. I ask you to have an open mind to consider:

After all of this I believe important issues have come to light, relating to a lack of transparency within exams, within this difficult time of the pandemic, and university exams in general.
I propose discussing with the university, and maybe others, about the releasing of two marks for student results. The first, the Raw mark (mark before rescaling) and second the Actual mark (mark after rescaling).

I see this as an opportunity to rebuild trust over this exam period, for students to see harsh marking/rescaling may not be reason for worse grades. Additionally, if this 10% was to occur again, we would know straight away and can act; alongside the fact that if university policy stands and rescaling only affects a couple of %, then there should be no issue in releasing both the mark types.

Would this idea be attractive to all of you? If so I ask you to make a subject access request via data protection for your raw scores. If enough of us do this - it may have an impact. The email to do this is dataprotection@york.ac.uk

Thank you all once again, and I hope this can appeal to some of you!

The Decision Makers

Your YUSU sabbatical officer team
Your YUSU sabbatical officer team
YUSU president
Responded
Thank you for copying us into your petition! We are pleased that the down-scaling initially applied to this Economics module was reverted, and that 2nd year Economics students received clarifications last week via email. As such, we note that the wording of this petition has changed significantly since its creation. Our Academic Officer, Matt Johnstone, is aware of the issues you have highlighted and this is something which has been raised with academic departments and senior members of staff at the University. We are continuing to address the issues you highlight surrounding grading, and we would like to thank all students for their continued engagement, as well as our fantastic Academic Reps. Best wishes, Your YUSU sabbatical officer team
YUSU
YUSU
Charlie Jeffery
Charlie Jeffery
Vice Chancellor of York
Matt Johnstone
Matt Johnstone
YUSU academic officer
Carly precious
Carly precious
Well-being officer YUSU

Petition Updates