NYC Department of Education: Reject proposed changes to sibling admissions policy

The Issue

The NYC Department of Education is pushing through an amendment to the Chancellor's Regulations making it almost impossible for siblings to stay together in Gifted & Talented programs, even if they are equally qualified.  The hearing is on December 20th.  We need to act fast to fight it!

We believe that the proposed changes would hurt families because:

1. The proposed change would push middle class, low-income, and minority families out of G&T programs by creating expensive logistical problems.

2. This change is unfair because it only applies to G&T programs; sibling policy is maintained elsewhere.

3. This change imposes inequity on middle class and minority families instead of addressing the real problem: not enough citywide G&T programs to educate all qualified kids at the level they are eligible for.

4. The change would purport to rank all NYC 4 year olds in numerical order, according to ability, using a test that testing experts say cannot be used in that way.

*Please include your NYC public school affiliation, if any, when signing this letter.  

Thank You!

This petition had 651 supporters

The Issue

The NYC Department of Education is pushing through an amendment to the Chancellor's Regulations making it almost impossible for siblings to stay together in Gifted & Talented programs, even if they are equally qualified.  The hearing is on December 20th.  We need to act fast to fight it!

We believe that the proposed changes would hurt families because:

1. The proposed change would push middle class, low-income, and minority families out of G&T programs by creating expensive logistical problems.

2. This change is unfair because it only applies to G&T programs; sibling policy is maintained elsewhere.

3. This change imposes inequity on middle class and minority families instead of addressing the real problem: not enough citywide G&T programs to educate all qualified kids at the level they are eligible for.

4. The change would purport to rank all NYC 4 year olds in numerical order, according to ability, using a test that testing experts say cannot be used in that way.

*Please include your NYC public school affiliation, if any, when signing this letter.  

Thank You!

The Decision Makers

Marty Markowitz
Marty Markowitz
Brooklyn Borough President
Responded
from the DOE: Over the past few weeks, we have discussed with many of you the change to sibling priority for placement within the Gifted and Talented program, which are captured under the Amended Chancellor’s Regulation A-101 you all will be voting on tomorrow evening. In light of the enormous amount of public comment we have received, the Department has decided not to implement its proposed change to sibling priority for G&T placement this year. Although we are reverting back to our original policy, we do not need to revise the language in A-101 as the current regulation allows us to articulate our G&T placement process in the G&T handbook. Thus, this reversion will be articulated in the handbook, as well. Our Office of Student Enrollment will be communicating with affected schools and families later today via email to inform them that we are revising the language in the handbook, and effectively reverting back to the previous sibling policy. ld you like to say?
Former State Senate
4 Members
Velmanette Montgomery
Former State Senate - New York-25
John Flanagan
Former State Senate - New York-2
Daniel Squadron
Former State Senate - New York-26
Former State House of Representatives
6 Members
Sheldon Silver
Former State House of Representatives - New York-65
Catherine Nolan
Former State House of Representatives - New York-37
Rhoda Jacobs
Former State House of Representatives - New York-42
Linda Rosenthal
New York State Assembly - District 67
New York State Senate
2 Members
José Serrano
New York State Senate - District 29
Michael Gianaris
New York State Senate - District 12

Petition Updates