We, Oldham Cats Rescue (charity no 1058621) are deeply concerned about the current ineffectual laws and regulations regarding cats in the United Kingdom. As individuals and as an organisation dedicated to the welfare of animals, particularly cats, we are appalled by the discrepancies in the legal treatment of cats compared to other animals.

Poppy’s story

In 2019, at Oldham Cats Rescue, we welcomed a beautiful tabby & white female cat aged 9 years young …..This was Poppy! Poppy, a sweet and gentle girl, became a resident at the Rescue, after attempting to find her the perfect forever home with no luck. We are a NO-KILL shelter, so in the event that we exhaust all avenues such as posting a particular cat on social media, videos, word of mouth and so forth, at that point we discuss residency at the Rescue. Our precious Poppy enjoyed her residency at the Rescue; she fitted into the family straight away. She would greet everyone on arrival, and everyone doted upon her, volunteers and family alike!

On Thursday 21st March 2024, Poppy was discovered deceased within very close proximity of our Rescue. Our precious girl was killed purposely, in a cold and cruel way. Poppy was decapitated and her head to this day is still missing. No animal should have to endure what our sweet Poppy was subjected to. We are heartbroken beyond belief - traumatised, angry and shocked by such a horrific act of animal cruelty. 

Police response

The police response was hesitant and inadequate. After reporting the incident, we received a message from the police to say that they would not be investigating. They declined to visit, look for evidence, talk to neighbours or review CCTV footage. After a complaint to the Chief Constable, local police contacted us after a week and said that they had been unaware of the crime (despite it being reported to the police and publicised in local media) until that day. They explained that the initial response had been made by a central team, without involving the local force.

We appreciate that police resources are limited and that, unfortunately, not all crimes can be solved. But this must be balanced against the importance of reassuring the local community that a serious effort will be made, within these constraints. This would not only provide solace to the public, but would also boost confidence in, and respect for, the police in the locality. As the founder of the modern police force, Sir Robert Peel, said - "The police are the public and the public are the police".

Response from the Community

We have been overwhelmed by the outpouring of support, sympathy and practical help from people and businesses in the local area, as a result of Poppy’s cruel murder. Donations, visits, offers of equipment – it has been an amazing display of kindness. This only serves to emphasise that there is a real demand from the general public for genuine, focussed and co-ordinated action to rectify this social evil.  The authorities need to match this public response with action.

These crimes are on the increase. An RSPCA survey in 2023 highlighted a 23% increase in cat cruelty cases, year on year. The South London Animal Investigation Network logged 1,039 such cases in the period since 2015. And local incidents in the Greater Manchester area are reported to be on the rise in a number of nearby towns – at least six recorded incidents in recent weeks.

It’s not even just an animal welfare issue. Allowing these incidents to continue, without effective intervention, misses the chance to identify perpetrators who obviously have serious psychological disorders and may progress to even worse crimes.

Our Mission and Our Call for Action

As a dedicated non-profit organization, founded in 1996, Oldham Cats Rescue’s mission is clear: to provide a safe haven, unwavering love, and vital care for abandoned, stray, and abused cats. All of us at Oldham Cats Rescue believe, every whisker counts. Our team of passionate volunteers and trustees work tirelessly to ensure that each cat receives the individualized attention and care they deserve. From medical treatment and rehabilitation to socialization and enrichment, we strive to address the unique needs of every feline, helping them to heal and thrive. We rehome an average of 270 cats a year.  But our work extends beyond the walls of our rescue. Through proactive community outreach and education initiatives, we aim to raise awareness about responsible pet ownership, the importance of spaying and neutering and microchipping, and the plight of homeless cats. By fostering a culture of compassion and empathy, we endeavour to create a brighter future for cats in our community. As a Rescue who deeply cares about the welfare of cats, we are appalled to learn that cats are treated differently under the law compared to other animals. This is a shocking revelation considering that they are protected animals. 

This is not only shocking but also undermines the intrinsic value and welfare of these beloved animals. Despite being recognized as protected animals, cats continue to be subjected to inadequate legal protection. The legal status of cats under the UK Animal Welfare Act 2006 is that of protected animals. UK law generally regards companion animals such as cats as personal property so that any damage or harm to a cat is legally the same as damage to any other piece of property (Criminal Damage Act 1971).

Despite being required by law from June to be microchipped, it seems that our feline friends still do not enjoy the same rights as other animals. For example, unlike dogs, there is no obligation to report cats involved in road traffic accidents. These discrepancies in treatment are unjust and require urgent attention and action. The Croydon Cat Killer case serves as a poignant reminder of society's disparate treatment of cats compared to other animals. The case of the Croydon cat killer was dropped without any significant resolution or justice for the victims involved. It’s disheartening and raises serious questions about how we value our pets' lives. Acknowledging the sentience of cats underscores the importance of treating them with compassion, respect, and understanding, recognizing that they, like us, are sentient beings deserving of consideration and care.

Despite existing laws aimed at protecting cats, it's evident that they are failing to adequately safeguard our cats. Loopholes and inconsistencies in legislation often result in lenient penalties for offenders, perpetuating a cycle of impunity. The lack of enforcement and resources allocated to enforce these laws further exacerbates the problem. Without robust and comprehensive measures in place, cats remain vulnerable and in danger.

 Therefore, we call for the following actions:        

­- Placing cats on the same legal footing as dogs in respect of road traffic accidents and intentional cruelty; 

- Making it a statutory responsibility for Police Commissioners to prioritise the investigation of crimes involving intentional killing and/or mutilation of domestic animals.

- Requiring local police to attend the site of all such incidents;

 - Chief Constables to publish an Annual Report, highlighting such cases and the action taken;

- Police Commissioners and Chief Constables to review annually the effectiveness of communication and "hand-offs" between central and local police teams;

- The Animal Welfare and Police Ministers to report annually to Parliament on the effectiveness of these new measures;

- This subject to be a standing item on the agenda for DEFRA’s Animal Welfare Committee

­

The Government has already intervened in this area with “Lucy’s Law” – to protect puppies and kittens. Now is the time to build on that precedent, and pass “Poppy’s Law”.

In conclusion, for our beautiful Poppy, the call for equal rights for cats is not just a matter of compassion, but one of justice and fairness. Cats, as sentient beings, deserve to be recognized and protected under the law, ensuring they are afforded the same basic rights and considerations as any other member of our society. By signing this petition, you're not only advocating for the well-being of our feline companions, but you're also taking a stand for equality and empathy and justice for Poppy. Let us work together to create a world where every cat is valued, respected, and treated with the dignity they rightfully deserve.