Stop cuts to holistic mental health care

The issue

Stop cuts to comprehensive health care for those with mental illness.

The federal government has recently sent out letters to 341 General Practitioners requesting voluntary repayments for mental health consultations. The issue? Seeing a patient about a mental health issue and a physical issue at the same consultation. According to Medicare this should only occur if the physical issue is raised first. If the patient has come for a mental health consultation but raises concerns about a physical problem, work done towards the physical issue only attracts Medicare funding if “it is clinically indicated that a separate problem must be treated immediately” - immediately is undefined.


These letters come from the Medicare compliance department as part of a “nudge campaign”. Their intention is to induce fear and reduce Medicare costs, but the flow on effect will be to reduce the number of GPs who feel safe to look after people with complex mental and physical health conditions.


This specifically discourages the wholistic care of patients with mental health concerns.

According to Medicare, if you have physical health concerns AND mental health issues, you have to deal with them in that order. Not vice versa. It’s ridiculous to think that mental health issues present in isolation. In fact, we know that the burden of physical illness in this group is higher and yet - we are asked to deal with the mental and physical aspects of their health on separate days and are being specifically targeted if it is deemed we have provided comprehensive, joined-up, patient-centred care “too much”.


It takes a lot to open up to a GP. Now we are being told to say - sorry but I have to deal the rest of your issues on another day. This is a cut to already overburdened mental health care systems and the most vulnerable members of our society.


And worse yet it’s happening by stealth. This is your rebate, this is your Medicare. Say no. Sign this petition.

39,854

The issue

Stop cuts to comprehensive health care for those with mental illness.

The federal government has recently sent out letters to 341 General Practitioners requesting voluntary repayments for mental health consultations. The issue? Seeing a patient about a mental health issue and a physical issue at the same consultation. According to Medicare this should only occur if the physical issue is raised first. If the patient has come for a mental health consultation but raises concerns about a physical problem, work done towards the physical issue only attracts Medicare funding if “it is clinically indicated that a separate problem must be treated immediately” - immediately is undefined.


These letters come from the Medicare compliance department as part of a “nudge campaign”. Their intention is to induce fear and reduce Medicare costs, but the flow on effect will be to reduce the number of GPs who feel safe to look after people with complex mental and physical health conditions.


This specifically discourages the wholistic care of patients with mental health concerns.

According to Medicare, if you have physical health concerns AND mental health issues, you have to deal with them in that order. Not vice versa. It’s ridiculous to think that mental health issues present in isolation. In fact, we know that the burden of physical illness in this group is higher and yet - we are asked to deal with the mental and physical aspects of their health on separate days and are being specifically targeted if it is deemed we have provided comprehensive, joined-up, patient-centred care “too much”.


It takes a lot to open up to a GP. Now we are being told to say - sorry but I have to deal the rest of your issues on another day. This is a cut to already overburdened mental health care systems and the most vulnerable members of our society.


And worse yet it’s happening by stealth. This is your rebate, this is your Medicare. Say no. Sign this petition.

The Decision Makers

Chris Bowen
Minister for Climate Change and Energy of Australia
Responded
Thanks to everyone who has signed this petition. The Labor Party is taking this issue very seriously. Labor created Medicare, and we will always defend it. GPs who are helping people with mental health issues at the same time as a physical issue should not be penalised or reprimanded. I have written to Minister Greg Hunt outlining Labor’s position, which can be found below. Chris Bowen MP Shadow Minister for Health ******* Dear Minister, I write regarding your Department's recent letter to some GPs who co-claim MBS Professional Attendance items with GP Mental Health Treatment items. Labor created Medicare, and we have supported previous efforts to ensure that its integrity is not undermined by the very small number of providers who bill inappropriately. However, I am concerned that this intervention has confused many GPs, and risks undermining our shared vision of comprehensive GP care. While the letter was sent to a relatively small number of GPs, you would be aware that many more have been alarmed by its apparent implications. Indeed, the President of the Royal Australian College of General Practitioners has described the letter as "an intimidating and heavy-handed tactic designed to pick on a small group to affect the whole group”. I note that your Department has apologised for the “anxiety and distress” caused by similar letters in the past. | also note that these letters are under review by the Australian National Audit Office, with a report due in May. In response to the letter, GPs have highlighted a range of common situations where providing integrated physical and mental health care is entirely appropriate - and indeed, to be encouraged. I therefore urge you to clarify your Government's policy on this matter, and to assure the vast majority of GPs who bill appropriately that they will not be subject to similar interventions in the future. Yours sincerely, The Hon. Chris Bowen MP Shadow Minister for Health Federal Member for McMahon 17 February 2020
Greg Hunt
Minister for Health

Petition Updates

Share this petition

Petition created on 11 February 2020