Bonagee Link Bridge Petition

“United for Change – Bridging Our Future”

Q1 – Why did you decide to setup a petition?

First and foremost, I want to thank you for the opportunity to discuss the critical issue of the Bonagee Link Bridge for our local community. I want to emphasize that my intention in initiating this petition is not to diminish the efforts and progress made by others thus far. Instead, I view myself as a forward-looking individual, recognising the need for swift action. It's clear that in my hometown of Letterkenny, with a population of 22,549 people, the current situation is far from ideal. Daily commutes have become a nightmare. I took some photos recently of primary routes into the town and uploaded them to social media, receiving an instance response. I received numerous communications highlighting a number of issues, concerns, and frustrations which I felt I could not ignore. The issue of congestion and a bridge over the Swilly which has come to be known as the ‘Bonagee Link Bridge’ has been a topic of discussion as far back as the 80’s-based on the feedback I have received to date. Due to same, I decided to proactively contribute to the needs of my local community and in that the petition was born. We find ourselves wasting precious hours stuck in traffic. The primary route in and out of Letterkenny and the recent works which involved quite a substantial investment have been of little benefit to relieving the congestion with many feeling that things have got worse. One signatory commented “We started off with 4 lanes, spent millions and ended up with 4 lanes and traffic lights!”. 

I have identified three pressing areas of concern.

Area 1 - Emergency Response & Safety
Traffic congestion on the primary route in and out of Letterkenny poses a significant threat to emergency response times and overall public safety in the region. Several factors necessitated the creation of a petition to highlight this issue.

Response Time Delays
The existing congestion can lead to delays for emergency services, including ambulances, fire services, and the Gardai, as they struggle to navigate through traffic. This has become an even greater issue in recent months with the latest upgrade works on the N56 due to the limited and in the most part no available space for traffic to manoeuvre and allow emergency service through. These delays can have life-threatening consequences during critical situations. In a research paper titled ‘Saving Lives through faster Emergency Unit Response Times: Role of Accessibility and Environmental Factors’ The provision of medical care in cases of road crashes is among the most defining elements in trauma handling, with the care provided within the first hour (a period frequently termed as the golden hour) significantly decreasing mortality. As a result, the reduction in response times often represents one of the top priorities (Dimitriou, Loukas & Efthymiou, Dimitris & Antoniou, Constantinos. (2018). Journal of Transportation Engineering. Pg 144).

Access to Medical Facilities
Letterkenny University Hospital serves a vast population with Census 2022 figure showing Letterkenny and Donegal populations on the increase at 22,549 and 167,082 respectively with Letterkenny projected to grow to 27,300 by 2040.

Delays in reaching the hospital due to traffic congestion on the Primary Route into Letterkenny can jeopardise the ability to provide timely medical care to patients, particularly during emergencies.

Safety Hazards
Congestion increases the risk of accidents and collisions on the road, further impacting public safety. As traffic congestion worsens, it may contribute to road safety hazards due to road rage due to lane hoping and may also contribute to higher levels of stress for commuters leading to rushing to recoup time spent in traffic jams therefore increasing the potentially for fatal accidents.

We need to be removing barriers from an already under pressure sector.

Area 2 - Economic Viability & Tourism
The economic well-being of the Letterkenny area and its appeal to tourists are significantly affected by the congestion issue and the absence of the Bonagee Link Bridge.

Business Disruption
Congestion leads to extended commuting times, which may disrupt business operations and hamper economic growth. It may discourage investment in the region and affect the livelihoods of local residents.

Tourist Experience
Letterkenny and its surroundings have immense tourism potential. However, traffic congestion may discourage tourists, impacting the local economy. Enhancing infrastructure with the Bonagee Link Bridge can potentially improve the tourism experience, attracting more visitors and supporting local businesses.

Future Economic Growth
The Bonagee Link Bridge project has the potential to stimulate economic growth by improving transportation connectivity. It has the potential to lead to increased investment, job creation, and the development of new economic opportunities in the region.

Area 3 - Environmental & Planning
The environment and urban planning are integral considerations when it comes to addressing the issue of congestion and the need for the Bonagee Link Bridge.

Environmental Impact
Congestion contributes to higher levels of air pollution and carbon emissions due to prolonged idling and slow-moving traffic. Addressing congestion with the Bonagee Link Bridge project could help Letterkenny become more energy efficient therefore we would be making a greater contribution in the reduction of the overall environmental footprint of transportation.

Sustainable Development
Proper urban planning, including the implementation of the Bonagee Link Bridge, would potentially contribute to more sustainable and efficient transportation solutions. This is essential for the long-term well-being of the community and the environment.

Land Use Efficiency
The congestion issue also raises questions about land use and urban planning. Addressing congestion can lead to more efficient land use, which in turn can promote sustainable, well-planned development and ensuring that Letterkenny can grow and evolve sustainably.

In conclusion, the decision to set up a petition addressing congestion in Letterkenny and the need for the Bonagee Link Bridge across the Swilly is motivated by concerns related to emergency response and safety, economic viability, and tourism, as well as environmental and planning considerations. Based on the feedback I have received to date the signatories and myself believe the successful implementation of this project will not only alleviate congestion but also have a positive impact on the well-being and development of the Letterkenny area.

Q2 - When did you setup the petition and how many signature do you have?

The petition was setup on 26th Oct 2023. Since its inception, the petition has garnered significant support, with a total of 1150 signatories as of 12th Nov 2023. This impressive response translates to an average of one signature for every 12 views of the petition.

Notably, this level of support stands out when compared to industry estimates. According to Change.org, most petitions typically receive approximately one signature for every 25 views. My petition's performance, surpassing this benchmark, underscores the strong resonance of our cause and the enthusiasm of the supporters.

Q3 – What do you hope comes out of this petition?

The Bonagee Link Bridge project, aimed at addressing the congestion issues on the primary route in and out of Letterkenny, holds the promise of resolving several pressing concerns which I previously detailed in my reasoning for setting up the petition. These concerns relate to emergency response and safety, economic viability, and tourism, as well as environmental and planning considerations. Keeping to the same theme I have highlighted again these three current categories of concern and the potential positive impact of this infrastructure development, demonstrating how it offers hope for mitigating the challenges that the Letterkenny faces.

Emergency Response & Safety
The current state of congestion on the roads leading to Letterkenny poses a grave threat to emergency response and overall public safety. With the introduction of the Bonagee Link Bridge, there will be a newfound hope for significant improvements in this regard.

Response Time Efficiency
The Bonagee Link Bridge will enable faster, unimpeded access for emergency services to reach their destinations. Reduced congestion can translate into more efficient response times, potentially saving lives in critical situations.

Enhanced Access to Medical Facilities
With reduced traffic congestion, the accessibility of Letterkenny University Hospital and other medical facilities will vastly improve. This is a beacon of hope for patients and healthcare providers alike, ensuring timely and critical care in emergency situations.

Improved Road Safety
The hope is that the Bonagee Link Bridge will not only ease congestion but also contribute to overall road safety. Reduced traffic density means fewer opportunities for accidents, enhancing public safety and reducing the risks posed by traffic-related incidents due to contributing factors such as road rage and higher levels of stress.

Economic Viability & Tourism
The economic prosperity of Letterkenny and its appeal as a tourist destination hinges on resolving the current traffic congestion issue. The Bonagee Link Bridge project offers hope for rejuvenating the local economy and tourism sector.

Economic Growth Potential
Addressing traffic congestion with the Bonagee Link Bridge project would potentially offer hope for local businesses. Reduced commuting times and improved transportation connectivity can stimulate economic growth, attract investment, and create employment opportunities in the region. 

Tourist Enhancement
Letterkenny and its surroundings are endowed with natural beauty and cultural attractions. The Bonagee Link Bridge kindles hope for the tourism industry, as it will enhance the visitor experience by eliminating traffic-related inconveniences, attracting more tourists, and supporting local businesses.

Prospects for Future Development
The Bonagee Link Bridge project represents a promising step toward long-term economic development. As the region becomes more accessible, it encourages sustainable urban planning and efficient land use, ultimately benefiting both the environment and the economy.

Environmental & Planning Considerations
Sustainability and responsible urban planning are at the forefront of the Bonagee Link Bridge project. The hope is that it will lead to several positive outcomes in these areas. 

Reduced Environmental impact
The Bonagee Link Bridge project aspires to alleviate congestion, subsequently reducing air pollution and carbon emissions associated with slow-moving traffic. This sustainable approach is a beacon of hope for mitigating the environmental footprint of transportation in Letterkenny. 

Sustainable Development
The project represents hope for fostering sustainable urban development. It can provide a template for efficient land use and urban planning, ensuring that future growth aligns with environmental and community interests.

Efficiency in Land Use
Addressing congestion creates opportunities for efficient land use, maximizing the use of available resources and spaces in a sustainable manner. This hope for efficient land use planning is essential for the long-term well-being of the community and its surroundings.

In conclusion, The Bonagee Link Bridge project shines as a beacon of hope for resolving critical issues related to emergency response and safety, economic viability and tourism, and environmental and planning considerations in the Letterkenny region. It is anticipated that this vital infrastructure development will not only alleviate traffic congestion but also usher in a brighter future for the community by fostering safety, economic growth, tourism, and sustainable development.

Q4 – Do you think the constant traffic puts people off coming to Letterkenny?

Traffic congestion can indeed discourage people from visiting or spending time in an area like Letterkenny. Constant traffic and congestion can have several negative effects that may deter both locals and visitors, such as

Inconvenience - Heavy traffic and congestion can lead to long commute times, making it inconvenient for residents and tourists to move around the town. This inconvenience can deter people from visiting or enjoying their time in Letterkenny.

Air Quality - Congestion often leads to increased air pollution, which can have health implications and negatively affect the overall environment. Poor air quality can be a turn-off for people, particularly those with health issues. 

Parking Challenges - Congestion can exacerbate parking problems, making it difficult for people to find parking spaces in busy areas. This can be a significant deterrent for those planning to visit shops, restaurants, or other attractions in Letterkenny.

Economic Impact - Businesses in the area may be adversely affected by traffic congestion as potential customers may choose to go elsewhere. This can result in economic losses for the local economy.

Tourism - Traffic congestion can be a significant turn-off for visitors. The inconvenience of navigating congested roads can lead tourists to choose other destinations with smoother traffic flow.

Quality of Life - Residents may experience a reduced quality of life due to constant traffic congestion, and this can, in turn, influence their perception of the town. We need to encourage stronger community connections and encourage people to interact, socialize, and participate in local events giving the public a better quality of life and making the town a more attractive place to live and work.

Efforts to address traffic congestion, such as the proposed Bonagee Link Bridge in Letterkenny, aim to alleviate these issues and make Letterkenny more appealing to both residents and visitors. Reducing congestion can contribute to a more pleasant and attractive environment, which is likely to encourage people to visit, enjoy their time here and spread the word which would encourage others to visit our wonderful town and County.

Q5 – What would be the benefits of a bridge?

The construction of a bridge, such as the Bonagee Link Bridge in Letterkenny, can offer a wide range of benefits to a community and its surrounding areas. Some of the key benefits could potentially be 

Emergency Response - One of the primary benefits of the Bonagee Link Bridge would potentially be significant improvements in emergency response times. First responders, such as ambulances, fire services, and the Gardai, can navigate more efficiently, leading to quicker response times during emergencies, potentially saving lives.

Traffic Relief - Alleviation of traffic congestion. The Bonagee Link Bridge would provide an additional route for vehicles effectively reducing congestion on existing roadways and improving the flow of traffic in and around Letterkenny.

Improved Connectivity – The Bonagee Link Bridge would improve connectivity between different parts of Letterkenny, making it easier for people to access various areas. This can lead to increased economic activity, job opportunities, and overall accessibility for residents.

Economic Growth - Improved transportation infrastructure, like the Bonagee Link Bridge, could potentially stimulate economic growth in Letterkenny. It may attract businesses, investments, and tourists, thereby creating jobs and boosting our local economy.

Tourism Promotion - The Bonagee Link Bridge could make an area more accessible to tourists, which can increase the number of visitors. Tourism-related businesses, such as hotels, restaurants, and shops, could potentially benefit from improved infrastructure in Letterkenny.

Environmental Benefits - The Bonagee Link Bridge would potentially help reduce the environmental impact of transportation. By reducing congestion, vehicles spend less time idling in traffic, leading to lower air pollution and decreased carbon emissions.

Land Use Efficiency - The Bonagee Link Bridge could potentially encourage more efficient land use and urban planning. It could promote sustainable development.

Safety - The Bonagee Link Bridge could be designed and constructed with built-in safety features that can help prevent accidents, such as a separate walking / cycle path, guardrails, and a well-designed road layout. This would contribute to overall road safety for drivers, pedestrians, and cyclists.

Enhanced Community Quality of Life - The Bonagee Link Bridge could improve the overall quality of life for residents by reducing stress associated with traffic congestion, reducing commuting times, and providing better access to essential services and amenities.

Infrastructure Resilience - The Bonagee Link Bridge should be designed in such a way that it could withstand various weather conditions, which would enhance Letterkenny’s resilience to climate-related events.

It is important to note that the specific benefits of the Bonagee Link Bridge would vary based on its design, start and end location, and the varying needs of the Letterkenny community. Nevertheless, the proposed Bonagee Link Bridge is a critical piece of infrastructure that can have a profound and positive impact on my hometown of Letterkenny and the wider Donegal region.

Q6 – Can you provide examples of what the signatories are saying in terms of their reason for signing your petition?

"Soil samples were taken for this project on the land down Bonagee lane away back as far as 1980/84 for this project..."

"It's a crucial priority."

...because it is essential, it is logical, it is what the people want, and it is long long overdue.

"It's about time that this BRIDGE was built. Talked about it for far too long. Elections next year, so we need a commitment from all going for election that this Bridge will be top of their agenda."

“So desperately needed”

"It's been talked about since the 70s and is long overdue."

“Letterkenny needs this link”

"There has been delays for decades now in regard to two major developments in road infrastructure for the area - one of which had businesses and land claimed to begin the work's, all frozen in time - while an already loaded to capacity town is under pressure with the volume of traffic entering and exiting.

"Why has this greatly needed relief bridge not started after so many years? There was favour to spending *millions* on the four lanes at the Port Road this past few years, with no reasonable improvement in traffic flow...as yet."

"I live on Ramelton Road, and the current traffic situation is untenable. The bridge should have been built 30 years ago."

“It's right”

“I have been caught in traffic jams coming into and out of Letterkenny, it frustrates me. This bridge is needed now, not in four years, it should have been built 3 years ago”

“It is absolutely necessary to allow management of traffic in Letterkenny”

"This link road was proposed and approved years ago, and a local business was shut down, and jobs were lost to facilitate this new road, and we're still waiting."

"Traffic in Letterkenny is currently atrocious."

“Letterkenny needs it”

"About time something meaningful was done to resolve this pitiful situation. Says so much about the government's lack of commitment to this area that this bridge has never been funded, considering also that we have no train infrastructure either."

“Build a bridge and we'll all get over it!”

“Traffic congestion is ruining our quality of life in the town. The Council have delighted in the growth of the town but have failed to provide infrastructure. The town bus is a failure and pedestrians are marooned on roundabouts, crossing dangerous roads”

“All traffic to Letterkenny and onto North and West Donegal has to pass through the Dry Arch and Polestar roundabouts. The existing road network does not have the capacity to deal with volumes. There’s only so much that can pass through a ‘small gap’. The proposed route from Dry Arch to Ballyraine is decades overdue and needs to be progressed separately from the bigger Ten-T project. Back roads like Bunagee Lane, Leck Road, Cullion Road and Old Town Bridge are providing a indirect by-pass from the traffic gridlock at the Polestar (even with the new lights operational) and these roads are unsuitable and unsafe for the traffic volumes. The current traffic situation (nightmare) is bad for business, tourism, road safety and the environment for Letterkenny and Donegal”

Q7 – How can the media, the local community in Letterkenny, the wider regions of County Donegal, and the business community help in promoting your petition for the Bonagee Link Bridge to end the congestion in Letterkenny?

The petition for the Bonagee Link Bridge to address congestion in Letterkenny in my view requires a collaborative effort with each of the aforementioned groups having a role to play in helping to promote the petition.

The Media

Social Media Sharing - Encourage the local Community and Tourist Information to share the petition on their social media profiles and in local community groups.
News Coverage - Encourage local newspapers such as yourselves as well as other media outlets across Donegal and perhaps further afield as we do welcome a lot of tourist to Letterkenny and the Donegal region, radio stations such as Highland Radio whom again I would like to thank presenter Donal Kavanagh, Caroline Orr and the team for the opportunity to bring this critical issue to the people of the North West in inviting me to an interview on Thur past 02/11. The full interview is now available on the ‘petition updates’ section of the petition website change.org at address https://www.change.org/BonageeLinkBridge as well as #BonageeLinkBridge on any social media platform.
Social Media Promotion - Leverage the reach of media organisations on social media platforms. Promote the sharing of the petition link and related content such as this interview to their followers.

The Community

Social Media Sharing - Encourage the local Community to share the petition on their social media profiles and in local community groups.
Face to Face - Encourage face to face interaction and promote communications to share information in relation to the petition and its impact on the local community.

The County of Donegal

Local Representatives - It is the responsibility of our elected representatives at Donegal County Council to represent its people which means providing updates on progress in relation to the Bonagee Link Bridge. In my own experience and any role of my professional career there has always been an expectation that I deliver at a minimum a Quarterly update on current projects where I highlighting primarily, the project status, key achievements, challenges and issues, upcoming milestones, risks and mitigation, budget and resources issues, timeline and schedule and next steps. This ensures an open, honest, and transparent process and a level of accountability. This is something we need to address within the County as we are missing same for sure between Donegal County Council and the Community.
Accountability Proposal - I recommend that Donegal County Council implements a centralised project database, encompassing ongoing initiatives like the Bonagee Link Bridge (presumably already established), each with assigned ownership. This step is crucial for accountability. The designated individual would be responsible for providing quarterly or semi-annual project status reports to the County Council. These reports should include comprehensive details regarding the project status, key achievements, challenges and issues, upcoming milestones, risks and mitigation, budget, funding and resource issues, timeline, schedule, and next steps. To ensure transparency, these reports should be accessible to the general public on the Donegal County Council website.

The Business Community

Chamber of Commerce – Collaboration with the local chamber of commerce to promote the petition to its members and highlight as outlined above the economic advantages of reduced congestion.
Sponsorship – Open to the idea of the business community supporting petition-related promotional efforts, such as printing flyers or advertising campaigns.
In-Store Promotion - Encourage businesses to display information about the petition in their stores, on their websites, and through social media.

Q8 – How can we access the petition and support the Bonagee Link Bridge Petition?

The success of the petition heavily depends on a coordinated and collaborative approach. I believe I have clearly communicated the critically important reasoning for the Bonagee Link Bridge but should anyone have anything that they wish to add or believe would help the cause please feel free to email BonageeLinkBridgePetition@gmail.com with your feedback / suggestions. The petition can also be accessed at https://www.change.org/BonageeLinkBridge and at #BonageeLinkBridge on any social media platform.

In conclusion and once again thank you for the opportunity to discuss this critical issue of the Bonagee Link Bridge for our local community and the County of Donegal and I want to emphasize again that my intention in initiating this petition is not to diminish the efforts and progress made by others thus far.

Thanks for your time.

--PS