The Donald Trump administration arrested and tries to deport Mahmoud Khalil, a legal permanent resident, because it does not like what he has said.1
I do not know Mr. Khalil, but he and I would probably disagree on several points about Middle Eastern policy.
However, the government may not criminalize speech.
Federal agents arrested Mr. Khalil inside the Manhattan, NY residential building where he has his home. The plainly clothed agents took away Mr. Khalil in an unmarked vehicle, according to press reports.
The Department of Homeland Security moved him to a lockup in Louisiana, hampering his lawyers access to him. Furthermore, the Trump administration sought to evade the jurisdiction of federal courts in New York.2
Jailing and trying to deport Mr. Khalil is wrongful and horrifying. The government should immediately drop this persecution, releasing Mr. Khalil to return to his family in New York. (Mr. Khalil’s wife, a U.S. citizen, is eight months pregnant.)
The Trump administration argues the Immigration and Nationality Act of 1952 allows the government to deport any foreigner whose activities or presence the secretary of state has sensible basis to believe would potentially seriously harm the country’s foreign policy interests.
This statutory provision, a McCarthyism relic, has rarely or never been enforced. It violates freedom of speech and the right to due process, civil liberties enshrined in the Constitution’s First and Fifth amendments.
The Trump administration claims that one of its foreign policy goals is to counter antisemitism. President Trump’s record of antisemitism belies the claim.3
I support countering antisemitism. What Mr. Khalil’s heart holds, I do not know. The Trump administration frequently conflates Israeli government policy criticism and antisemitism.
Additionally, the government alleges Mr. Khalil’s First Amendment activities “align” him with a foreign terrorist group, conflating speech and crimes.
Let us be clear: The Trump administration does not like what Mr. Khalil has said, so the administration targeted him for political retribution, abusing his rights and trying to deport him.
The government may not silence and punish dissent. This should gravely concern us all.
President Trump stated Mr. Khalil’s case is “the first arrest of many to come.”
Persecution is evil and unacceptable.
References
1. Trump Administration Seeks to Expel a Green-Card Holder Over Student Protests. The New York Times. (2025, March 10).
www.nytimes.com/2025/03/10/us/trump-rubio-khalil-columbia-student-protests.html
2. There Was a Second Name on Rubio’s Target List. The Atlantic. (2025, March 13).
www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2025/03/trump-deportation-green-card-holder-mahmoud-khalil/682037
3. Trump’s long history of trafficking in antisemitic tropes. The Washington Post. (2022, Oct. 17).
www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2022/10/17/trump-history-antisemitic-tropes