Stop The New Clear Backpack Rule For The 23-24 School Year in Broward County

Victory

This petition made change with 116 supporters!

The Issue

As students of BCPS we understand that this is for safety. But we feel it is uncomfortable for us and we have some reasons why. 

1. The clear backpack rule is an invasion of privacy: Students have a right to privacy, and forcing them to carry clear backpacks violates that right. It's unfair to force students to give up their privacy just because of the actions of a few bad actors.

2. The clear backpack rule doesn't address the root of the problem: The clear backpack rule is a reactive measure that doesn't address the underlying issues that lead to school violence. Instead of focusing on superficial solutions, we should be working to address the root causes of school violence, such as mental health issues and easy access to firearms.

3. The clear backpack rule is ineffective: There is no evidence to suggest that clear backpacks actually prevent school violence. In fact, many students and parents feel that clear backpacks make schools feel more like prisons than places of learning.

4. The clear backpack rule is expensive: Clear backpacks can be expensive, and many families can't afford to buy them. This puts an undue burden on low-income families and can create a situation where some students are singled out and stigmatized for not having a clear backpack.

5. The clear backpack rule creates a false sense of security: The clear backpack rule may make some people feel safer, but it doesn't actually make schools safer. Instead, it creates a false sense of security that can actually make students and teachers more complacent and less aware of potential threats.

In conclusion, the clear backpack rule is a misguided and ineffective policy that violates students' privacy and doesn't address the root causes of school violence. Instead of focusing on superficial solutions, we should be working to address the underlying issues that lead to school violence and create safe and welcoming learning environments for all students.

The Decision Makers

Lori Alhadeff
Lori Alhadeff
Chair,District 4
BCPS school board
BCPS school board
Dr. Earlean Smiley
Dr. Earlean Smiley
Interim Su

Petition Updates