STOP the 30 meter Cell Tower proposal at McDougall United Church


STOP the 30 meter Cell Tower proposal at McDougall United Church
The Issue
Acadia neighbours, our community’s equity, aesthetics and health are at risk.
1) Equity Depreciation: Using the line of sight formula, and assuming an unobstructed view and flat topography, a person at ground level could see a 30m up to 24km away. Heritage to Southland is 4.5km. There are studies that state surrounding property values can drop between 2.5-20%. Assuming a conservative average home value of 700k, Acadia residents stand to lose 15-150k on average of equity each. All this for the Church to gain an estimated 15-25k/yr?
Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics 2018, all homes within 0.72km declines by 2.46% on average, and 9.78% for homes within the visible range
National Institute for Science, law, &P Public Polic7 (NISLAPP): 94% of homebuyers and renters are less interested in properties near cell towers, documenting price drops of up to 20%
Environmental Health Trust (EHT): homes can lose up to 20% of their value
2) Location/aesthetics: this location is unique in that it is proposed to be relatively inner community compared to other cell phone towers. I encourage you to look at the below link or google “cell phone tower map”(https://www.ertyu.org/steven_nikkel/cancellsites.html?lat=50.966281&lng=-114.043407&zoom=13&type=Roadmap&layers=t&pid=0&ds=0
- private landowners are pursed first, then the city. This is only the second private owner approached as they work their way down ideal locations
- With city land being a secondary option, the community may have more oversight, and revenues could potentially have a more transparent and direct community impact then the proposed beneficiary
- there is a school and park across the street. Generally, municipalties deam these types of locations are deemed not suitable for these cell tower proposals
3) Health risks: The proposal is compliant with the Federal Regulator under Section 6. However, a lot of community members have concerns about research that suggests otherwise.
315
The Issue
Acadia neighbours, our community’s equity, aesthetics and health are at risk.
1) Equity Depreciation: Using the line of sight formula, and assuming an unobstructed view and flat topography, a person at ground level could see a 30m up to 24km away. Heritage to Southland is 4.5km. There are studies that state surrounding property values can drop between 2.5-20%. Assuming a conservative average home value of 700k, Acadia residents stand to lose 15-150k on average of equity each. All this for the Church to gain an estimated 15-25k/yr?
Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics 2018, all homes within 0.72km declines by 2.46% on average, and 9.78% for homes within the visible range
National Institute for Science, law, &P Public Polic7 (NISLAPP): 94% of homebuyers and renters are less interested in properties near cell towers, documenting price drops of up to 20%
Environmental Health Trust (EHT): homes can lose up to 20% of their value
2) Location/aesthetics: this location is unique in that it is proposed to be relatively inner community compared to other cell phone towers. I encourage you to look at the below link or google “cell phone tower map”(https://www.ertyu.org/steven_nikkel/cancellsites.html?lat=50.966281&lng=-114.043407&zoom=13&type=Roadmap&layers=t&pid=0&ds=0
- private landowners are pursed first, then the city. This is only the second private owner approached as they work their way down ideal locations
- With city land being a secondary option, the community may have more oversight, and revenues could potentially have a more transparent and direct community impact then the proposed beneficiary
- there is a school and park across the street. Generally, municipalties deam these types of locations are deemed not suitable for these cell tower proposals
3) Health risks: The proposal is compliant with the Federal Regulator under Section 6. However, a lot of community members have concerns about research that suggests otherwise.
315
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on July 2, 2024