Stop public sharing of mugshots before proven guilty

Stop public sharing of mugshots before proven guilty

Recent signers:
Ashely Frederickson and 9 others have signed recently.

The Issue

A friend of my son, who is just about to graduate and has already received several Division 1 basketball offers, has been wrongfully accused and arrested. Now, his mugshot is plastered all over social media. This could ruin his future, stripping away opportunities he has worked tirelessly for. This alarming situation highlights the broader issue of releasing and publicizing mugshots before a person is found guilty in a court of law.

The presumption of innocence until proven guilty is a fundamental principle in our justice system, meant to protect individuals from prejudgment. Yet, the publication of mugshots before a verdict has become increasingly common, subjecting individuals to public condemnation and social stigma without adequate context or evidence. For young people especially, this can have dire consequences, tarnishing reputations and effectively sentencing them socially and professionally before they even set foot in a courtroom.

Consider the facts: According to recent statistics, a significant percentage of those arrested are not convicted of any crime. The Center for American Progress notes that over 70% of Americans with an arrest record have never been convicted of a crime. However, by the time their innocence is proven, the damage to their personal and professional lives is often irreversible. Employers, colleges, and athletic programs frequently scour social media and easily accessible online records, which may include mugshots, influencing decisions based on incomplete and misleading narratives.

This practice not only violates privacy rights but also perverts justice by imposing a form of penalty on individuals who have yet to be found guilty. Instead of treating mugshots as matters of public record, their dissemination should be restricted until a court delivers a verdict, ensuring that innocent individuals do not suffer unnecessary harm.

We propose legislative change to protect the rights of the accused by withholding mugshots from public access until cases reach a legal conclusion. This shift would uphold the true spirit of justice, guard against unnecessary social and economic hardships, and protect the futures of countless individuals like my son's friend.

Join us in urging lawmakers to enact these necessary changes. Sign this petition to stop the public sharing of mugshots before individuals are proven guilty. Your signature is a step towards fairness, justice, and the protection of innocent lives from unwarranted public scrutiny.

24

Recent signers:
Ashely Frederickson and 9 others have signed recently.

The Issue

A friend of my son, who is just about to graduate and has already received several Division 1 basketball offers, has been wrongfully accused and arrested. Now, his mugshot is plastered all over social media. This could ruin his future, stripping away opportunities he has worked tirelessly for. This alarming situation highlights the broader issue of releasing and publicizing mugshots before a person is found guilty in a court of law.

The presumption of innocence until proven guilty is a fundamental principle in our justice system, meant to protect individuals from prejudgment. Yet, the publication of mugshots before a verdict has become increasingly common, subjecting individuals to public condemnation and social stigma without adequate context or evidence. For young people especially, this can have dire consequences, tarnishing reputations and effectively sentencing them socially and professionally before they even set foot in a courtroom.

Consider the facts: According to recent statistics, a significant percentage of those arrested are not convicted of any crime. The Center for American Progress notes that over 70% of Americans with an arrest record have never been convicted of a crime. However, by the time their innocence is proven, the damage to their personal and professional lives is often irreversible. Employers, colleges, and athletic programs frequently scour social media and easily accessible online records, which may include mugshots, influencing decisions based on incomplete and misleading narratives.

This practice not only violates privacy rights but also perverts justice by imposing a form of penalty on individuals who have yet to be found guilty. Instead of treating mugshots as matters of public record, their dissemination should be restricted until a court delivers a verdict, ensuring that innocent individuals do not suffer unnecessary harm.

We propose legislative change to protect the rights of the accused by withholding mugshots from public access until cases reach a legal conclusion. This shift would uphold the true spirit of justice, guard against unnecessary social and economic hardships, and protect the futures of countless individuals like my son's friend.

Join us in urging lawmakers to enact these necessary changes. Sign this petition to stop the public sharing of mugshots before individuals are proven guilty. Your signature is a step towards fairness, justice, and the protection of innocent lives from unwarranted public scrutiny.

The Decision Makers

Donald Trump
President of the United States
James Vance
Vice President of the United States

Petition Updates