Victory
Petitioning Minister of Finance, Union Government of India Arun Jaitley and 7 others

Security transaction tax(STT)-A bad deal for traders & a systemic risk for capital markets

7,710
Supporters

STT anomaly on exercised options - a systemic risk to the entire stock exchange

This is an incident that happened with me on the last options expiry. On 25th Jan 2017, the expiry for January contracts, I had bought 8600 Nifty calls at 3.25 pm for Rs. 0.05 as I was 100% sure that Nifty will close above 8600 based on my 25 min weighted average price calculations. True to my expectations, Nifty closed at 8602.75. I had bought 3000 lots of Nifty 8600 call options at 5 paise, paying a premium of Rs. 11250. By the numbers, you can see that I should have made a profit of Rs. 6,07,500 (2.7* 2.25 lakh) right? But what followed was beyond comprehension.

I did make a profit on this trade because I let the option expire with some value. But much to my surprise end of the day when I received the contract note, found out that the Security Transaction Tax (STT) in case of exercised options is 0.125% of the entire contract value as opposed to 0.05% of the premium value if I had sold them on the exchange. So even though I did make a gross profit on this trade, to my shock, I ended up with a huge loss of Rs. 18 lakh because I had to pay STT of over Rs. 24 lakh. If I had sold the options before the market closed, the STT I would have had to pay would have been a few thousand rupees, but holding it just for a few minutes extra cost me over Rs. 16 lakh in losses. Are SEBI and the Government of India aware of how traders like me can lose their hard-earned savings in this manner?


Here are the reasons why everyone reading this should sign the petition.

I am sure there are thousands of innocent traders who would have lost a lot of money in similar fashion. I cannot understand how STT can be over 10000 times higher just because I decided to hold onto the trade for a few minutes extra. Are SEBI and the government blind to the woes of the retail trading community in an already shallow market?
More importantly, isn't this a systemic risk for the capital markets? 
To buy 3000 lots of this option, I required only Rs. 11250. Assume my account had only Rs. 11250, I am guessing the broker I am trading with would have faced a loss of Rs. 24 lakh (since I made 24lk loss with just 11k in my account). The exchange would debit this money from the brokers account if the client didn't have funds. 
So, if a bunch of clients, like me, say had bought 3 lakh lots with around Rs. 10 lakh, the potential losses just because of STT would have been over Rs. 24 crores. What if the broker wasn't liquid enough to make up for this loss? This could easily be Rs. 24 or 240 or 2400 crores, wouldn't such losses be a widespread systemic risk to everyone in the capital markets.

This is a disaster waiting to happen. SEBI should take the onus of fixing this anomaly immediately. STT for exercised options should be either brought down to same levels that are applicable when trading on the markets, or else it can open a trading window after market hours on expiry day to close out all in the money options (similar to the post-market trading session for equity).

I don't know if anything can happen in my case, and I probably will live with this regret throughout my life. But the least I can do is to make an effort so that no other unwitting retail trader has to go through what I am going through. I request all readers to not only sign this, but also get all your trading friends, broking employees, and whomever possible to support the cause and make sure that the regulators hear this loud and clear.

This petition was delivered to:
  • Minister of Finance, Union Government of India
    Arun Jaitley
  • SEBI
    Chairman, SEBI
  • Minister of State, Finance
    Arjun Ram Meghwal
  • Minister of State, Finance
    Santosh Gangwar
  • NSE India
    Investor Grievance Cell
  • SEBI
    SEBI
  • Press, NSE India
    D. Lahiri
  • Press, NSE India
    NSE

This petition starter stood up and took action. Will you do the same?


Today: Chirag is counting on you

Chirag Gupta needs your help with “Security transaction tax (STT)-A trap for traders and a systemic risk for capital markets.”. Join Chirag and 7,709 supporters today.