Save Eastern Kentucky From Water Contamination
The Issue
Kentucky Restoration Bill: A Call to Protect Our Water, Health, and Heritage
Presented by IanXIlyana, Transgender 2Spirit Human Rights Activist
Preamble
We, the undersigned, present this petition to the Kentucky State Legislature, urging immediate and comprehensive action to address the ongoing water contamination crisis in Eastern Kentucky. This crisis not only endangers the health and well-being of our fellow citizens but also threatens the rich cultural heritage and legacy of our state. We call upon our elected officials to prioritize the fundamental human right to clean water and to uphold the values of justice, autonomy, and dignity for all Kentuckians.
I. Immediate Actions Required
Veto Senate Bill 89: This bill redefines “waters of the Commonwealth,” effectively removing protections for headwater streams, wetlands, and groundwater. Its enactment would leave vast areas of our state’s water sources vulnerable to pollution, disproportionately affecting rural communities that rely on these waters for daily use.
Provision of Safe Drinking Water: Ensure the immediate distribution of clean, safe drinking water to all residents of Eastern Kentucky who may have been exposed to contaminated sources, including those from drinking fountains, household faucets, and meals prepared in local establishments.
Comprehensive Medical Screenings: Offer free, thorough medical examinations for residents to detect potential health issues arising from exposure to toxic substances, including heavy metals and carcinogens.
Water Safety Education: Implement educational programs in rural areas to inform residents about water safety, potential contaminants, and preventive measures to protect their health.
Restoration of Water Reservoirs: Initiate projects to clean and restore all affected water reservoirs to ensure long-term safety and sustainability of water sources.
Federal Investigation: Demand a full investigation into the actions and inactions of federal agencies that have led to the neglect and contamination of Eastern Kentucky’s water supplies, infringing upon the civil liberties of its residents.
II. Evidence of Necessity
Historical Contamination Events:
October 2000 – Martin County: A coal slurry impoundment failure released approximately 300 million gallons of toxic sludge into local waterways, contaminating drinking water for around 27,000 residents.
November 2019 – South Shore: Detection of PFAS chemicals in municipal drinking water, with levels nearing or exceeding EPA advisories.
2018–2019 – Martin County: Studies revealed chronic contamination issues, including elevated levels of disinfection byproducts and coliform bacteria in tap water.
Demographic Vulnerabilities:
Eastern Kentucky is predominantly rural, with many communities relying on private wells and small water systems.
The region has a median household income significantly below the state average, limiting access to healthcare and resources to address contamination issues.
Healthcare access is limited, with fewer primary care physicians and specialists compared to national averages.
III. Cultural and Human Impact
The people of Eastern Kentucky have deep-rooted connections to their land and water sources, often relying on them for generations. The contamination of these waters is not just an environmental issue but a profound violation of their heritage and way of life.
IV. Notable Kentuckians at Risk
The following individuals, born or raised in Kentucky, represent the rich cultural tapestry of our state. Their legacies are intertwined with the communities now facing environmental peril:
Chris Stapleton: Grammy-winning country musician from Staffordsville.
Tyler Childers: Acclaimed singer-songwriter from Lawrence County.
Loretta Lynn: Legendary country singer from Butcher Hollow.
Bill Monroe: Father of Bluegrass Music from Rosine.
Jennifer Lawrence: Academy Award-winning actress from Louisville.
George Clooney: Renowned actor and humanitarian from Lexington.
Muhammad Ali: Iconic boxer and activist from Louisville.
Ashley Judd: Actress and activist raised in Kentucky.
Patty Loveless: Country singer from Pikeville.
Johnny Depp: Celebrated actor from Owensboro.
These individuals, among many others, have brought pride to Kentucky. Their hometowns and the communities that nurtured them now face significant health risks due to water contamination.
V. Conclusion
This petition is more than a call for environmental justice; it is a plea to preserve the health, heritage, and dignity of Eastern Kentucky’s residents. The contamination of water sources is a direct assault on their rights and way of life. We urge the Kentucky State Legislature to act swiftly and decisively to address this crisis, ensuring that all Kentuckians can live with the basic human right of access to clean and safe water.
Stand with Eastern Kentucky. Protect our water. Preserve our heritage.
Eastern Kentucky Water Quality: Incidents, Demographics, and Legislative Context
Verified Water Contamination Incidents in Eastern Kentucky
Oct 2000 – Martin County (Inez area): A coal slurry impoundment (Massey Energy) failed, releasing ~300 million gallons of black coal-processing sludge into Wolf Creek and Coldwater Fork (Tug Fork tributaries). The sludge contained heavy metals (arsenic, mercury, lead, etc.), fouling ~100 miles of streams and contaminating the drinking water of ~27,000 people . (EPA/UK studies confirm high metals levels in the spill.)
Late Summer 2022 – Pike County: Independent testing by Appalachian Voices found high selenium – a coal-mining pollutant – in streams of the Big Sandy River watershed (including below the Hunts Branch mountaintop-removal mine). The group noted regulators only recently required coal companies to monitor these discharges, highlighting ongoing water-quality risks .
Nov 2019 – South Shore (Greenup County): State sampling detected PFAS “forever chemicals” in the town’s municipal drinking water. EPA-linked testing found PFOS/PFOA at 42.1 parts-per-trillion (ppt) and, including other PFAS, ~65.7 ppt total – levels just under or exceeding the EPA advisory of 70 ppt. (This was the highest PFAS contamination measured in Kentucky’s statewide tests.)
2018–2019 (Study period) – Martin County: A University of Kentucky pilot study of Martin County tap water found chronic contamination issues. Nearly half the household samples exceeded EPA limits for cancer-linked disinfection byproducts (trihalomethanes and haloacetic acids), and some showed coliform bacteria . Residents frequently report odor, discoloration, and boil-water notices – evidence of failing treatment and infiltration.
Feb 2025 – Eastern KY Flood Response: Historic flooding in February 2025 prompted the EPA to deploy a mobile lab to Pike, Martin and Perry Counties. The lab tested public supplies and private wells for fecal contamination (total coliform/E. coli) as a precaution against post-flood waterborne pathogens . (No specific contaminant was reported, but the action underscores flood-driven vulnerability of water supplies.)
Demographic Overview of Eastern Kentucky
Region: Eastern (Appalachian) Kentucky consists of 54 counties (northeast/southeast KY) covering ~18,200 sq mi (≈46% of KY land) . The population was about 1.16 million (2019) – up slightly from 2016 but below the 2010 peak . Most counties are very rural: only 5 of 54 Appalachian counties exceed the state’s average density (110 people/sq mi) , and many saw double-digit population decline in 2010–2019 (e.g. Harlan, Letcher, Pike) .
Income: Appalachian Kentucky is poorer than the state as a whole. Median household income is about $33,900 (2019), roughly 27% below the KY median of ~$46,500 . Several Eastern counties (e.g. McCreary at ~$19,300) are among the lowest in the nation . In fact, 38 of the 54 counties are designated “economically distressed” (another 13 are “at risk”) .
Rural/Health Vulnerability: Much of Eastern Kentucky relies on groundwater (private wells or small systems) for drinking water. Environmental groups note SB 89 would endanger “the groundwater of hundreds of thousands of Kentuckians who rely on rural public water utilities and private wells” . Many water/wastewater systems are outdated, leading to “poor service” and “unsafe water quality” in some areas . Health-care access is also limited: the region has ~26% fewer primary care doctors than the national average and ~60% fewer specialists than non-Appalachian Kentucky . Hospitals and clinics are scarce in mountain areas, heightening the impact of any water-borne health threat. (These factors – low income, sparse services, aging infrastructure – magnify Eastern Kentucky’s vulnerability to environmental health problems .)
Kentucky Senate Bill 89 (2025) – Summary and Analysis
Contents: Senate Bill 89 (sponsored by Sen. Scott Madon) rewrites Kentucky’s water-protection laws. The key change is to redefine “water” or “waters of the Commonwealth” very narrowly. SB 89 limits protected waters to navigable waters, sinkholes, certain springs, and wellhead protection areas, removing virtually all headwater streams, creeks, wetlands and most groundwater from state jurisdiction. (The official legislative summary confirms: SB 89 “changes the definition of water” in state law .) It also adds a new “long-term treatment” requirement for mine permits (affecting bonding/costs) .
Implications: By aligning with the federal “navigable waters” definition, SB 89 effectively strips state oversight of hundreds of miles of streams and groundwater. As one analysis notes, SB 89 “removes all protections” for groundwater, wetlands, and headwaters, leaving them unregulated . In practice, Kentucky would become the only state to cede so much of its water regulatory authority to the federal government . Environmental watchdogs warn this could allow increased pollution runoff, pipeline or mining discharges, and loss of wetland flood buffers (heightening flood risk).
Support and Opposition: SB 89 passed March 2025 over Gov. Beshear’s veto . Proponents (backed by the Kentucky Coal Association and others) argue it removes “bureaucratic barriers” to economic development (coal, construction, etc.) . Opponents counter that it rolls back decades of water protections. The Energy & Environment Secretary Rebecca Goodman and others publicly stated SB 89 would uniquely weaken Kentucky’s authority, risking “pollution, sickness and more dangerous flooding” . Environmental groups point out that with SB 89’s passage, Kentucky is now the sole state abandoning its own definition of protected waters . (Analysts warn the change will shift enforcement to EPA and make it harder for Eastern Kentucky communities to secure safe local water supplies.)
Sources: Official and news reports on contamination incidents ; U.S. EPA and academic studies of regional water quality; Kentucky demographic reports ; legislative text and analysis of SB 89 .
7
The Issue
Kentucky Restoration Bill: A Call to Protect Our Water, Health, and Heritage
Presented by IanXIlyana, Transgender 2Spirit Human Rights Activist
Preamble
We, the undersigned, present this petition to the Kentucky State Legislature, urging immediate and comprehensive action to address the ongoing water contamination crisis in Eastern Kentucky. This crisis not only endangers the health and well-being of our fellow citizens but also threatens the rich cultural heritage and legacy of our state. We call upon our elected officials to prioritize the fundamental human right to clean water and to uphold the values of justice, autonomy, and dignity for all Kentuckians.
I. Immediate Actions Required
Veto Senate Bill 89: This bill redefines “waters of the Commonwealth,” effectively removing protections for headwater streams, wetlands, and groundwater. Its enactment would leave vast areas of our state’s water sources vulnerable to pollution, disproportionately affecting rural communities that rely on these waters for daily use.
Provision of Safe Drinking Water: Ensure the immediate distribution of clean, safe drinking water to all residents of Eastern Kentucky who may have been exposed to contaminated sources, including those from drinking fountains, household faucets, and meals prepared in local establishments.
Comprehensive Medical Screenings: Offer free, thorough medical examinations for residents to detect potential health issues arising from exposure to toxic substances, including heavy metals and carcinogens.
Water Safety Education: Implement educational programs in rural areas to inform residents about water safety, potential contaminants, and preventive measures to protect their health.
Restoration of Water Reservoirs: Initiate projects to clean and restore all affected water reservoirs to ensure long-term safety and sustainability of water sources.
Federal Investigation: Demand a full investigation into the actions and inactions of federal agencies that have led to the neglect and contamination of Eastern Kentucky’s water supplies, infringing upon the civil liberties of its residents.
II. Evidence of Necessity
Historical Contamination Events:
October 2000 – Martin County: A coal slurry impoundment failure released approximately 300 million gallons of toxic sludge into local waterways, contaminating drinking water for around 27,000 residents.
November 2019 – South Shore: Detection of PFAS chemicals in municipal drinking water, with levels nearing or exceeding EPA advisories.
2018–2019 – Martin County: Studies revealed chronic contamination issues, including elevated levels of disinfection byproducts and coliform bacteria in tap water.
Demographic Vulnerabilities:
Eastern Kentucky is predominantly rural, with many communities relying on private wells and small water systems.
The region has a median household income significantly below the state average, limiting access to healthcare and resources to address contamination issues.
Healthcare access is limited, with fewer primary care physicians and specialists compared to national averages.
III. Cultural and Human Impact
The people of Eastern Kentucky have deep-rooted connections to their land and water sources, often relying on them for generations. The contamination of these waters is not just an environmental issue but a profound violation of their heritage and way of life.
IV. Notable Kentuckians at Risk
The following individuals, born or raised in Kentucky, represent the rich cultural tapestry of our state. Their legacies are intertwined with the communities now facing environmental peril:
Chris Stapleton: Grammy-winning country musician from Staffordsville.
Tyler Childers: Acclaimed singer-songwriter from Lawrence County.
Loretta Lynn: Legendary country singer from Butcher Hollow.
Bill Monroe: Father of Bluegrass Music from Rosine.
Jennifer Lawrence: Academy Award-winning actress from Louisville.
George Clooney: Renowned actor and humanitarian from Lexington.
Muhammad Ali: Iconic boxer and activist from Louisville.
Ashley Judd: Actress and activist raised in Kentucky.
Patty Loveless: Country singer from Pikeville.
Johnny Depp: Celebrated actor from Owensboro.
These individuals, among many others, have brought pride to Kentucky. Their hometowns and the communities that nurtured them now face significant health risks due to water contamination.
V. Conclusion
This petition is more than a call for environmental justice; it is a plea to preserve the health, heritage, and dignity of Eastern Kentucky’s residents. The contamination of water sources is a direct assault on their rights and way of life. We urge the Kentucky State Legislature to act swiftly and decisively to address this crisis, ensuring that all Kentuckians can live with the basic human right of access to clean and safe water.
Stand with Eastern Kentucky. Protect our water. Preserve our heritage.
Eastern Kentucky Water Quality: Incidents, Demographics, and Legislative Context
Verified Water Contamination Incidents in Eastern Kentucky
Oct 2000 – Martin County (Inez area): A coal slurry impoundment (Massey Energy) failed, releasing ~300 million gallons of black coal-processing sludge into Wolf Creek and Coldwater Fork (Tug Fork tributaries). The sludge contained heavy metals (arsenic, mercury, lead, etc.), fouling ~100 miles of streams and contaminating the drinking water of ~27,000 people . (EPA/UK studies confirm high metals levels in the spill.)
Late Summer 2022 – Pike County: Independent testing by Appalachian Voices found high selenium – a coal-mining pollutant – in streams of the Big Sandy River watershed (including below the Hunts Branch mountaintop-removal mine). The group noted regulators only recently required coal companies to monitor these discharges, highlighting ongoing water-quality risks .
Nov 2019 – South Shore (Greenup County): State sampling detected PFAS “forever chemicals” in the town’s municipal drinking water. EPA-linked testing found PFOS/PFOA at 42.1 parts-per-trillion (ppt) and, including other PFAS, ~65.7 ppt total – levels just under or exceeding the EPA advisory of 70 ppt. (This was the highest PFAS contamination measured in Kentucky’s statewide tests.)
2018–2019 (Study period) – Martin County: A University of Kentucky pilot study of Martin County tap water found chronic contamination issues. Nearly half the household samples exceeded EPA limits for cancer-linked disinfection byproducts (trihalomethanes and haloacetic acids), and some showed coliform bacteria . Residents frequently report odor, discoloration, and boil-water notices – evidence of failing treatment and infiltration.
Feb 2025 – Eastern KY Flood Response: Historic flooding in February 2025 prompted the EPA to deploy a mobile lab to Pike, Martin and Perry Counties. The lab tested public supplies and private wells for fecal contamination (total coliform/E. coli) as a precaution against post-flood waterborne pathogens . (No specific contaminant was reported, but the action underscores flood-driven vulnerability of water supplies.)
Demographic Overview of Eastern Kentucky
Region: Eastern (Appalachian) Kentucky consists of 54 counties (northeast/southeast KY) covering ~18,200 sq mi (≈46% of KY land) . The population was about 1.16 million (2019) – up slightly from 2016 but below the 2010 peak . Most counties are very rural: only 5 of 54 Appalachian counties exceed the state’s average density (110 people/sq mi) , and many saw double-digit population decline in 2010–2019 (e.g. Harlan, Letcher, Pike) .
Income: Appalachian Kentucky is poorer than the state as a whole. Median household income is about $33,900 (2019), roughly 27% below the KY median of ~$46,500 . Several Eastern counties (e.g. McCreary at ~$19,300) are among the lowest in the nation . In fact, 38 of the 54 counties are designated “economically distressed” (another 13 are “at risk”) .
Rural/Health Vulnerability: Much of Eastern Kentucky relies on groundwater (private wells or small systems) for drinking water. Environmental groups note SB 89 would endanger “the groundwater of hundreds of thousands of Kentuckians who rely on rural public water utilities and private wells” . Many water/wastewater systems are outdated, leading to “poor service” and “unsafe water quality” in some areas . Health-care access is also limited: the region has ~26% fewer primary care doctors than the national average and ~60% fewer specialists than non-Appalachian Kentucky . Hospitals and clinics are scarce in mountain areas, heightening the impact of any water-borne health threat. (These factors – low income, sparse services, aging infrastructure – magnify Eastern Kentucky’s vulnerability to environmental health problems .)
Kentucky Senate Bill 89 (2025) – Summary and Analysis
Contents: Senate Bill 89 (sponsored by Sen. Scott Madon) rewrites Kentucky’s water-protection laws. The key change is to redefine “water” or “waters of the Commonwealth” very narrowly. SB 89 limits protected waters to navigable waters, sinkholes, certain springs, and wellhead protection areas, removing virtually all headwater streams, creeks, wetlands and most groundwater from state jurisdiction. (The official legislative summary confirms: SB 89 “changes the definition of water” in state law .) It also adds a new “long-term treatment” requirement for mine permits (affecting bonding/costs) .
Implications: By aligning with the federal “navigable waters” definition, SB 89 effectively strips state oversight of hundreds of miles of streams and groundwater. As one analysis notes, SB 89 “removes all protections” for groundwater, wetlands, and headwaters, leaving them unregulated . In practice, Kentucky would become the only state to cede so much of its water regulatory authority to the federal government . Environmental watchdogs warn this could allow increased pollution runoff, pipeline or mining discharges, and loss of wetland flood buffers (heightening flood risk).
Support and Opposition: SB 89 passed March 2025 over Gov. Beshear’s veto . Proponents (backed by the Kentucky Coal Association and others) argue it removes “bureaucratic barriers” to economic development (coal, construction, etc.) . Opponents counter that it rolls back decades of water protections. The Energy & Environment Secretary Rebecca Goodman and others publicly stated SB 89 would uniquely weaken Kentucky’s authority, risking “pollution, sickness and more dangerous flooding” . Environmental groups point out that with SB 89’s passage, Kentucky is now the sole state abandoning its own definition of protected waters . (Analysts warn the change will shift enforcement to EPA and make it harder for Eastern Kentucky communities to secure safe local water supplies.)
Sources: Official and news reports on contamination incidents ; U.S. EPA and academic studies of regional water quality; Kentucky demographic reports ; legislative text and analysis of SB 89 .
The Decision Makers
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on May 4, 2025