Confirmed victory
Petitioning Councilwoman Blondell Reynolds Brown Councilwoman Blondell Reynolds Brown and 21 others
1 response

Remove Illegal ATV and Dirt Bikes from Philadelphia


During fair weather days, for many years, the safety of Philadelphians of all ages out on the street is put in jeopardy by clusters of off-road vehicles. The Philadelphia Police Department currently maintains a no-chase policy against these motorists, making them virtually immune from prosecution because the law cannot reach them. Recent deaths have highlighted how the careless drivers who operate these vehicles in the City of Philadelphia are to the public, and to themselves.

Letter to
Councilwoman Blondell Reynolds Brown Councilwoman Blondell Reynolds Brown
Philadelphia Mayor's Office Philadelphia Mayor
Councilwoman Maria Quiñones-Sánchez Councilwoman Maria Quiñones-Sánchez
and 19 others
Councilman Curtis Jones Jr Councilman Curtis Jones Jr
Councilman Wilson Goode Jr Councilman Wilson Goode Jr
Councilman David Oh Councilman David Oh
Councilman Dennis O'Brien Councilman Dennis O'Brien
Philadelphia Police Civil Affairs Philadelphia Police Civil Affairs
Philadelphia Police Advisory Commission Philadelphia Police Advisory Commission
Philadelphia District Attorney Seth Williams Philadelphia District Attorney Seth Williams
Councilwoman Cindy Bass Councilwoman Cindy Bass
Councilman Bobby Henon Councilman Bobby Henon
Councilman Darrell Clarke Councilman Darrell Clarke
Councilman Mark Squilla Councilman Mark Squilla
Councilman Brian O'Neil Councilman Brian O'Neill
Councilman William Greenlee Councilman William Greenlee
Councilman Bill Green Councilman Bill Green
Councilman James Kenney Councilman James Kenney
Councilwoman Jannie Blackwell Councilwoman Jannie Blackwell
Councilman Kenyatta Johnson Councilman Kenyatta Johnson
Pennsylvania State House
Pennsylvania State Senate
I just signed the following petition addressed to: Philadelphia City Council, Mayor & PA Legislature.

----------------
Remove Illegal Off-Road Vehicles From Philadelphia's Streets

During fair weather days, for many years, the safety of Philadelphians of all ages out on the street is put in jeopardy by clusters of off-road vehicles. The Philadelphia Police Department currently maintains a no-chase policy against these motorists, making them virtually immune from prosecution because the law cannot reach them. Recent deaths within Philadelphia have highlighted how dangerous the careless drivers who operate these vehicles in the City of Philadelphia are to the public, and to themselves. These operators by and large have expressed zero concern for the public's safety or their own.

[Commonwealth of Pennsylvania's] own published documents submit that ATV's are inherently impossible to be used virtually everywhere in Philadelphia: http://www.dcnr.state.pa.us/forestry/atv/ATVBrochure.pdf
http://www.dcnr.state.pa.us/forestry/atv/ATVGuide.pdf

Further, the Commonwealth submits where Law Enforcement Officers have jurisdiction:

[editor: Corrected for document ownership]

Quote:
------
ENFORCEMENT All law enforcement officers in the state, including local and state police, are authorized to enforce the Snowmobile/ATV Law. In general:
• State forest and state park lands – DCNR Rangers and other state forest officers
• State game lands – Wildlife Conservation Officers and Deputy WCOs
• Municipal and state roadways – municipal and state police
• Private property – municipal and state police
-------

Current PPD policy is to not give chase. While understandable, it's obvious that policy will be excepted if, for instance:
A) The ATV operator is using the ATV to escape from a heinous crime (such as shooting a police officer)
B) The ATV operator is seen carrying a loaded firearm.

To not make an exception for that policy would mean ANYONE could commit any type of crime and escape law enforcement by mounting an ATV.

Further: Auctions are often hotspots where ATV enthusiasts in Philadelphia acquire these vehicles. It is more appropriate to dispose of confiscated vehicles in a fashion that makes it difficult to re-acquiring the vehicles. For instance, pouring chemicals into the fuel supply to seize the motor, then turning the vehicle over to salvage operators for vehicles unclaimed at auction. Operator fines should be set to a solitary amount for all violators: the maximum, and impounding should be cut to the shortest convenient time window allowable by Commonwealth law.

A Philadelphia replete with high speed off-road vehicles zipping around its streets is a Philadelphia that displays a semblance of lawlessness, and an ambivalence to do anything about it, even though the tools for enforcement exist. The ambivalence is so great that on some evenings, South Broad Street close to City Hall itself is an attraction point for ATV and dirt bike operators.

The times call for creativity in enforcement and encouraging operators to follow the law.

Citizens who raise this complaint are often met with "we can't chase" as the response. This is not an acceptable answer.

----------------

Sincerely,