Preserve Historical and Cultural Resources Within the Proposed Vineyard Vista Development

186

Let’s get to 200 signatures!
Petitions with 1,000+ supporters are 5x more likely to win!

The Issue

The hills and open spaces surrounding Vineyard Parkway represent more than vacant land. They are part of Murrieta's living history, containing landscapes associated with the historic Sykes Ranch, mature eucalyptus windbreaks, water infrastructure, wildlife habitat, and areas that may contain cultural or archaeological resources not yet fully documented. The documented discovery of a Native American artifact in the Vineyard Vista area, later acknowledged by Pechanga tribal representatives, highlights the importance of careful review and preservation of cultural resources that may still exist within this landscape. Such discoveries provide tangible connections to the Indigenous history of the region and remind us that important pieces of our shared heritage may remain beneath the surface. As development continues in our community, it is essential that significant historical, cultural, archaeological, tribal, and environmental resources are thoroughly identified, evaluated, and considered before grading and construction begin. This petition is not an opposition to responsible growth. Rather, it is a call for transparency, thorough investigation, public awareness, and thoughtful preservation of resources that cannot be replaced once they are lost. We respectfully ask the City of Murrieta, project applicants, and decision-makers to ensure that all relevant studies and reports are made readily available to the public, that tribal consultation is meaningful and respectful, and that any historically, culturally, archaeologically, or environmentally significant resources are preserved whenever possible. Murrieta's heritage belongs to future generations as much as it belongs to us today. Once these landscapes are altered, their historical and cultural value cannot be fully restored. We respectfully ask for careful review, responsible stewardship, and preservation of significant resources before development proceeds.

The Decision Makers

Justin Clifton
Justin Clifton
City Manager at City of Murrieta
Responded
The Vineyards Specific Plan was originally approved in 1987, when the property was within the County of Riverside, with Phase 1 (residential) being constructed in 2006. The certified Environmental Impact Report (EIR) evaluated the development of 1,587 single-family residential units, along with a range of commercial, recreational, institutional, and open space uses. The owner of the property has filed an application to amend the approved Specific Plan to request to reduce the minimum lot size, eliminate the commercial land use, and modify certain development standards within the Specific Plan. The existing certified EIR includes mitigation measures for subject areas, including biological and cultural resources. The property was evaluated and conditioned to comply with local, regional, state, and federal regulations, and these were implemented during the construction of Phase 1. Of note, the upper portions of the hills and the entire ridgeline are conserved and owned by a separate property owner, are not subject to development, and are located within the County of Riverside. Consideration of aesthetics is being carefully evaluated as part of the current review. As required by State law, city staff are consulting with tribal government(s) in a confidential manner and are also working with local, state, and federal agencies responsible for biological resources. The result of these discussions will lead to updating associated conditions and mitigation measures. These will be included in the updated environmental analysis, which will include technical studies and will be made available to the public prior to the public hearing. Staff will present a report to the City Council upon completion of the environmental, engineering, and planning reviews. The project will be advertised and noticed in accordance with State law requirements for the transparent public hearing process. The public will have the opportunity to attend and speak at the public hearing or send a letter if they are unable to attend. Thank you. Justin Clifton City Manager [Note: The Change.org Civic Engagement Team reaches out to decision makers to let them know about petitions in their community and to help facilitate engagement with supporters. The above was an email response we received regarding this petition.]
Murrieta City Council
5 Members
Lisa DeForest
Murrieta City Council - District 3
Jon Levell
Murrieta City Council - District 1
Ron Holliday
Murrieta City Council - District 2

Supporter Voices

Petition Updates