Petition updatePets Need Protection—Stop City RejectionPetition: A Case Study in Administrative Negligence

Carla Marie GallardoEl Paso, TX, United States

Mar 27, 2026
For six years, I maintained a close relationship with a resident in El Paso County, acting as the primary caregiver for her animals. Because the owner was often unable to manage the workload, I was the one consistently cleaning litter boxes, providing food and water, and monitoring the health of over 10 domestic animals. My understanding of this property was not based on a single report, but on half a decade of daily, firsthand observation.
The Fatal 48-Hour Decline
In April 2025, the situation reached a tragic breaking point. A puppy on the property, which I had seen in good health just two days prior, suffered a catastrophic physical decline.
• The Scene: After receiving a frantic call that the puppy was dying, I rushed to the home. I arrived to find the puppy in the owner’s lap, suffering from severe atrophy and violent, bloody diarrhea.
• The Passing: Within 10 minutes of my arrival, the puppy died right there in the owner's arms.
• The Hazard: The property contained an algae-filled pond that the puppy was known to drink from. Between the rapid 48-hour death and the environmental conditions, this was a clear red flag for a waterborne pathogen or zoonotic threat that required an immediate investigation.
The Evidence: Photographic Proof of High-Risk Exposure
The danger to the public was further confirmed when the owner reported that one of her felines brought a dead bat into the home. I have photographic proof of this incident. * The Law: Under Texas Health & Safety Code §826, bats are "High-Risk Vector Species." Any contact between a bat and domestic animals triggers a mandatory state legal requirement for vector testing and vaccination verification.
• The Failure: Despite this documented exposure and the sudden death of a puppy on the same property, El Paso County officials failed to follow the state-mandated rabies protocols for the 10+ surviving animals.
The 48-Hour "Clearance" and Abandonment
Following the puppy's death, the owner left the property for four days, locking the remaining 10+ animals inside the home during the El Paso summer heat with no food or water. I placed five to six documented calls to El Paso County reporting the bat exposure, the suspicious death, and the immediate abandonment.
The County cleared the case within 48 hours. They officially determined the animals had "adequate shelter," effectively closing a case involving a confirmed high-risk vector and animal cruelty without a functional investigation.
The Official Record: "Enforcement is Harassment"
The most damning evidence of this failure is a recorded call with an Animal Welfare Control Officer. When confronted with the fact that these 10+ animals were unvaccinated and that the dog on-site frequently ran at large to kill wildlife, the officer stated:
"CONTINUOUSLY GOING OUT THERE AND DEMANDING HER TO GET A RABIES VACCINE FALLS MORE UNDER "HARASSMENT" THAN IT DOES LEGAL OBLIGATION ADJUDICATION FOR IT!"
Accountability Over Infrastructure—-
When we are being asked to invest $32.7 million into a new animal shelter. Another animal shelter building cannot fix an administration that considers the enforcement of the Texas Rabies Control Act to be
"harassment." We are not asking for new favors; we are asking for the government to follow the laws-specifically regarding Rabies control and Running at Large-that are already on the books to keep El Paso safe.AlA
Support now
Sign this petition
Copy link
WhatsApp
Facebook
Nextdoor
Email
X