

Overturn Joseph Maldonado's Wrongful Conviction


Overturn Joseph Maldonado's Wrongful Conviction
The Issue
Joseph Maldonado, has been wrongfully convicted of first-degree murder and sentenced to life without the possibility of parole. This grave injustice was committed in January 2025, despite the absence of any evidence linking Joseph to the crime. No phone records, eyewitness reports, or physical descriptions connect him to the incident.
The only testimony against Joseph came from an accomplice, lacking the necessary corroboration as required by California Penal Code §1111. It states a conviction cannot be had upon the testimony of an accomplice, unless it is supported by other evidence that tends to connect the defendant to the crime, the star witness who is also the surviving victim was face-to-face with the shooter and testified that the shooter had a tattoo or a mole by his right eye, was right handed and touched her car door with no gloves . The star witness also testified that she could not recognize and did not identify Joseph as the shooter, nor pick him out of a photo lineup. She testified that she will never forget his face . now the record is clear Joseph does not have such markings on his face. He’s left-handed and 12 fingerprints were found on the victims door. None matching Joseph’s .This unreliable testimony should never have been enough to convict an innocent man. California law is clear about the need for corroboration, yet it was blatantly ignored in Joseph’s case.
Moreover, his first trial resulted in a hung jury, indicating a lack of consensus on his guilt. In the second trial, the district attorney committed gross misconduct by presenting a photograph of Joseph that was not relevance to the case nor was it disclosed to his defense attorney in advance. This is a direct violation of his rights to fair trial and justice.
Adding to these injustices, Joseph suffered from insufficient assistance of counsel – a constitutional right that was severely lacking.
This is a clear miscarriage of justice. Joseph deserves a fair and just trial, one that adheres to the laws and principles of the justice system. We call for an immediate overturning of his wrongful conviction and a thorough investigation into the mishandling of his case. Please sign this petition to help bring Joseph Maldonado home and restore faith in our justice system.

Poppi MattinglyPetition Starter
377
Let’s get to 500 signatures!
The Issue
Joseph Maldonado, has been wrongfully convicted of first-degree murder and sentenced to life without the possibility of parole. This grave injustice was committed in January 2025, despite the absence of any evidence linking Joseph to the crime. No phone records, eyewitness reports, or physical descriptions connect him to the incident.
The only testimony against Joseph came from an accomplice, lacking the necessary corroboration as required by California Penal Code §1111. It states a conviction cannot be had upon the testimony of an accomplice, unless it is supported by other evidence that tends to connect the defendant to the crime, the star witness who is also the surviving victim was face-to-face with the shooter and testified that the shooter had a tattoo or a mole by his right eye, was right handed and touched her car door with no gloves . The star witness also testified that she could not recognize and did not identify Joseph as the shooter, nor pick him out of a photo lineup. She testified that she will never forget his face . now the record is clear Joseph does not have such markings on his face. He’s left-handed and 12 fingerprints were found on the victims door. None matching Joseph’s .This unreliable testimony should never have been enough to convict an innocent man. California law is clear about the need for corroboration, yet it was blatantly ignored in Joseph’s case.
Moreover, his first trial resulted in a hung jury, indicating a lack of consensus on his guilt. In the second trial, the district attorney committed gross misconduct by presenting a photograph of Joseph that was not relevance to the case nor was it disclosed to his defense attorney in advance. This is a direct violation of his rights to fair trial and justice.
Adding to these injustices, Joseph suffered from insufficient assistance of counsel – a constitutional right that was severely lacking.
This is a clear miscarriage of justice. Joseph deserves a fair and just trial, one that adheres to the laws and principles of the justice system. We call for an immediate overturning of his wrongful conviction and a thorough investigation into the mishandling of his case. Please sign this petition to help bring Joseph Maldonado home and restore faith in our justice system.

Poppi MattinglyPetition Starter
Support now
377
Let’s get to 500 signatures!
The Decision Makers

U.S. Senate - California

President of the United States
Government of California
Supporter Voices
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on June 23, 2025