We’re closing in on 300 signatures, and the tide has officially turned.

On August 14, 2025, both Hugh and Alex filed petitions for Civil Protection Orders against each other in Whatcom County Superior Court. What happened next tells the whole story:

Hugh’s petition was denied the very next day — dismissed outright on August 15th, without even going to trial. That’s how little weight it carried. A desperate and pathetic attempt to spin the narrative, just like we've all seen before.

Alex’s petition was backed by multiple sworn declarations, including her attorney and witnesses. The court held a full hearing on September 25, 2025.

Result: Judge Nancy Ivarinen granted Alex a permanent protection order against Hugh. The case is now closed, with the order in place.

This is not rumor. This is not “Reddit drama.” This is a formal ruling by the Superior Court that Alex needed legal protection — and Hugh’s attempt to flip the narrative failed instantly. Hugh filed his against Alex (Case 25-2-01582-37) and Alex filed hers against Hugh (Case 25-2-01572-37). (See for yourself here https://odysseyportal.courts.wa.gov/odyportal) 

Why This Matters

📌 The courts have validated what staff, patrons, and community members have been saying all along: the danger was real.

📌 Hugh tried to weaponize the legal system, and it didn’t work. His case was tossed, Alex’s stood.

📌 This adds to the mountain of evidence: criminal charges, workplace testimonies, and now a civil protection order in Alex’s favor.

 
The End Goal Remains
This is a huge step toward accountability, but it doesn’t end here. A bar and game shop run by someone with a DV protection order against them is not safe for our community.

👉 We demand full transfer of ownership of 1-Up Lounge and Cardhaven.

If Hugh remains a benefactor, silent partner, or figure behind the curtain, nothing changes. If that isn’t possible, then closure is the only option.