We the citizens of the United States request that the corruption and wrong doings in the courtroom of Justice Gene R. Heintz be investigated and for him to be impeached.

The Issue

A Judge does not have the legal authority to decide who can and cannot present evidence in a case. He does not have the authority to make his own rules and run a courtroom any way he sees fit. This is not 1940's Nazi Germany and the Judge's last name is Heintz not Hitler. In the United States if America we have legal guidelines and specific laws and rules to make sure everyone gets a fair day in court.  On August 12, 2014 Judge Heintz violated those rules.

During the hearing regarding the dog "Lady"on Tuesday August 12, 2014, Judge Heintz would not allow Attorney Matthew Albert,  to put on a defense case. The judge would not consider the Facial Insufficiency motion and deemed Lady a dangerous dog without allowing any defense witnesses. 

Attorney Matthew Albert  asked the Judge Gene Heintz what authority he had to refuse him the right to present a defense and Judge Gene Heintz refused to answer. 

Never in the history of the practice of law has something like this happened. This is a complete miscarriage of Justice.

    

http://www.examiner.com/article/dog-seized-after-being-shot-by-erie-county-deputy-is-coming-home ;

avatar of the starter
Shea ClarkePetition StarterI am a happily married wife and mom. I am a very passionate animals rights advocate. My passion is dogs, and I am trying to start a canine rescue shelter. I am also an advocate against Domestic Violence, Child abuse and sexual assault and abuse.
This petition had 149 supporters

The Issue

A Judge does not have the legal authority to decide who can and cannot present evidence in a case. He does not have the authority to make his own rules and run a courtroom any way he sees fit. This is not 1940's Nazi Germany and the Judge's last name is Heintz not Hitler. In the United States if America we have legal guidelines and specific laws and rules to make sure everyone gets a fair day in court.  On August 12, 2014 Judge Heintz violated those rules.

During the hearing regarding the dog "Lady"on Tuesday August 12, 2014, Judge Heintz would not allow Attorney Matthew Albert,  to put on a defense case. The judge would not consider the Facial Insufficiency motion and deemed Lady a dangerous dog without allowing any defense witnesses. 

Attorney Matthew Albert  asked the Judge Gene Heintz what authority he had to refuse him the right to present a defense and Judge Gene Heintz refused to answer. 

Never in the history of the practice of law has something like this happened. This is a complete miscarriage of Justice.

    

http://www.examiner.com/article/dog-seized-after-being-shot-by-erie-county-deputy-is-coming-home ;

avatar of the starter
Shea ClarkePetition StarterI am a happily married wife and mom. I am a very passionate animals rights advocate. My passion is dogs, and I am trying to start a canine rescue shelter. I am also an advocate against Domestic Violence, Child abuse and sexual assault and abuse.

Petition Closed

This petition had 149 supporters

Share this petition

The Decision Makers

New York State Commission on Judicial Conduct
New York State Commission on Judicial Conduct
Responded
Ms. Clarke, We have received your submissions. Please be advised that a signed complaint is required by law. Please feel free to contact our office, 585-784-4141, and ask for Stephanie Fix. You can advise her as the specific details of your complaint. John J. Postel Deputy Administrator
Andrew M. Cuomo
Former Governor - New York
Petition updates