Investigate why a champion horse died during a race

Investigate why a champion horse died during a race

The Issue

DEAR NATIONAL THOROUGHBRED RACING ASSOCIATION,

As the presumed national body of Thoroughbred horse racing, we ask that you conduct a thorough audit of:

- the incentives and policies that led to the death of champion racehorse Monzante on the racetrack;

- the role and responsibility or lack thereof of his breeder, Juddmonte Farms; his owners during his championship years, Jay and Gretchen Manoogian and Scott Anastasi; his trainer during his championship years, Mike Mitchell; his owner-trainer at the time of his death, Jackie W. Thacker; and

- what incentives and policies the National Thoroughbred Racing Association intends to pursue to make sure another tragedy like this does not happen again.

Monzante began his racing career in Europe in 2006.

In fall 2007, he started his American racing career for award-winning trainer Mike Mitchell and owners Scott Anastasi and Jay and Gretchen Manoogian.

In 2008, he earned $391,550 his owners and trainer from seven races. In 2009, he was at the peak of his game and competed in the richest day of horse racing, the Breeders' Cup.

But from there it went downhill. Monzante ran a disappointing sixth at the Breeders' Cup. It was seventh in his next race. As they say in horse racing, he started dropping in "class," racing in less expensive and prestigious races against less talented horses.

Fast forward to today.

On July 20, 2013, Monzante -- now nine, old for a racehorse -- raced for the first time in more than seven months -- a notable layoff period -- for his owner/trainer Jackie W. Thacker.

The official racing chart says he "stopped." Then he was euthanized on the track.

Put another way: A horse who won more than $390,000 for his initial American owners and more than $580,000 in his lifetime was left to die on the racetrack.

National Thoroughbred Racing Association, what will YOU do about this?

Sincerely,

Horse racing fans everywhere

This petition had 3,046 supporters

The Issue

DEAR NATIONAL THOROUGHBRED RACING ASSOCIATION,

As the presumed national body of Thoroughbred horse racing, we ask that you conduct a thorough audit of:

- the incentives and policies that led to the death of champion racehorse Monzante on the racetrack;

- the role and responsibility or lack thereof of his breeder, Juddmonte Farms; his owners during his championship years, Jay and Gretchen Manoogian and Scott Anastasi; his trainer during his championship years, Mike Mitchell; his owner-trainer at the time of his death, Jackie W. Thacker; and

- what incentives and policies the National Thoroughbred Racing Association intends to pursue to make sure another tragedy like this does not happen again.

Monzante began his racing career in Europe in 2006.

In fall 2007, he started his American racing career for award-winning trainer Mike Mitchell and owners Scott Anastasi and Jay and Gretchen Manoogian.

In 2008, he earned $391,550 his owners and trainer from seven races. In 2009, he was at the peak of his game and competed in the richest day of horse racing, the Breeders' Cup.

But from there it went downhill. Monzante ran a disappointing sixth at the Breeders' Cup. It was seventh in his next race. As they say in horse racing, he started dropping in "class," racing in less expensive and prestigious races against less talented horses.

Fast forward to today.

On July 20, 2013, Monzante -- now nine, old for a racehorse -- raced for the first time in more than seven months -- a notable layoff period -- for his owner/trainer Jackie W. Thacker.

The official racing chart says he "stopped." Then he was euthanized on the track.

Put another way: A horse who won more than $390,000 for his initial American owners and more than $580,000 in his lifetime was left to die on the racetrack.

National Thoroughbred Racing Association, what will YOU do about this?

Sincerely,

Horse racing fans everywhere

The Decision Makers

Penelope Miller
Penelope Miller
National Thoroughbred Racing Association
Responded
Here is today’s statement from Alex Waldrop, President & CEO, National Thoroughbred Racing Association (NTRA): “We know very little about the specific events surrounding the recent death of the gelding, Monzante, but the death of any horse while racing is a cause for concern. The 25 racetracks accredited by the NTRA Safety and Integrity Alliance adhere to a rigorous set of standards and protocols to foster a safer racing environment, including pre-race veterinary examinations, post-race veterinary inspections, reporting of injuries and fatalities, post-mortem veterinarian examinations, the establishment of an injury review committee and retirement and retraining options for owners and trainers of older and infirmed horses. We urge all tracks and participants, including Evangeline Downs and its horsemen, to seek accreditation and take full advantage of the industry’s growing body of knowledge and best practices related to the safety of our human and equine athletes.”
Tom LaMarra
Tom LaMarra
BloodHorse
Responded
Why are these trainers not banned. Why do horses pay the price for gyp trainers to still be training. How sad to see the beautiful Monzante in the picture, winning a graded stakes then being dropped in a $4,000 claimer. Obviously, there were issues with this horse as it left the hands of M. Mitchell and shuttled further down the line to this gyp trainer. Disgusting. American horse racing does NOT police it's own well ! All horses go to heaven.
Rich Rosenbush
Rich Rosenbush
Daily Racing Form
Ray Paulick (Paulick Report)
Ray Paulick (Paulick Report)
Paulick Report

Petition Updates

Share this petition

Petition created on July 21, 2013