Stop the Co-Location at I.S. 2!!!

The Issue

What is the RUSH??? The PEP intends to vote on our schools co-location on October 15, 2013. 

SLOW DOWN and engage the parents, the school and the community in authentic dialogue to find solutions that work with our community school. 

I.S. 2, The George L. Egbert School,  is a middle school on Staten Island.  We are a Title 1 school located in Midland Beach, a flood zone.  Our school was flooded and damaged during Hurricane Sandy and needed to relocate.  The boiler was destroyed, the electrical system was destroyed, the basement was flooded and everything located in the basement was destroyed. We have no working boiler and are still recovering.   

We were alerted by the DoE to the proposed co-location a week before school ended. The DoE had not visited our school, nor were they aware we were impacted by the Hurricane prior to proposing co-location. 

We have not had a PTA meeting yet after learning about the co-location.  Our Community Education Council held a meeting in July to seek out parent input. ALL parents were opposed to co-location. 

Class size would remain large with the co-location at 30+ students. 

All common spaces would be shared creating logistical problems.  These include the cafeteria, gymnasium, auditorium and school yard. 

The DoE Impact Statement indicates that enrichment programs like art, music & chorus will likely be lost as a result of co-location.

The DoE Impact Statement indicates that sports programs will likely be lost as a result of reduced enrollment. 

We are a Title 1 school and have seen our budgets cut year after year having to work with less to help our students. 68% of whom are at the poverty level.

We want SOLUTIONS like smaller class size which is  proven to help academic outcomes. There is NO DATA that Co-locations improve academic outcomes. 

The DoE states the reason for this co-location is to improve performance and to give parents a choice. If that is true, engage the parents in meaningful conversation.  Parents have expressed they want SMALLER CLASS SIZES, not crowding two schools in one building and paying double the cost for two administrations with no money going to hire additional teachers to reduce class size.   Smaller class size WILL improve performance.  Help the STUDENTS and don't push your agenda on us with no data to show this works.  

avatar of the starter
PTA for George L.Egbert I.S. 2Petition Starter
Confirmed victory
This petition made change with 1,089 supporters!

The Issue

What is the RUSH??? The PEP intends to vote on our schools co-location on October 15, 2013. 

SLOW DOWN and engage the parents, the school and the community in authentic dialogue to find solutions that work with our community school. 

I.S. 2, The George L. Egbert School,  is a middle school on Staten Island.  We are a Title 1 school located in Midland Beach, a flood zone.  Our school was flooded and damaged during Hurricane Sandy and needed to relocate.  The boiler was destroyed, the electrical system was destroyed, the basement was flooded and everything located in the basement was destroyed. We have no working boiler and are still recovering.   

We were alerted by the DoE to the proposed co-location a week before school ended. The DoE had not visited our school, nor were they aware we were impacted by the Hurricane prior to proposing co-location. 

We have not had a PTA meeting yet after learning about the co-location.  Our Community Education Council held a meeting in July to seek out parent input. ALL parents were opposed to co-location. 

Class size would remain large with the co-location at 30+ students. 

All common spaces would be shared creating logistical problems.  These include the cafeteria, gymnasium, auditorium and school yard. 

The DoE Impact Statement indicates that enrichment programs like art, music & chorus will likely be lost as a result of co-location.

The DoE Impact Statement indicates that sports programs will likely be lost as a result of reduced enrollment. 

We are a Title 1 school and have seen our budgets cut year after year having to work with less to help our students. 68% of whom are at the poverty level.

We want SOLUTIONS like smaller class size which is  proven to help academic outcomes. There is NO DATA that Co-locations improve academic outcomes. 

The DoE states the reason for this co-location is to improve performance and to give parents a choice. If that is true, engage the parents in meaningful conversation.  Parents have expressed they want SMALLER CLASS SIZES, not crowding two schools in one building and paying double the cost for two administrations with no money going to hire additional teachers to reduce class size.   Smaller class size WILL improve performance.  Help the STUDENTS and don't push your agenda on us with no data to show this works.  

avatar of the starter
PTA for George L.Egbert I.S. 2Petition Starter

The Decision Makers

Former State House of Representatives
4 Members
1 Responded
Nicole Malliotakis
Former State House of Representatives - New York-64
Dear I.S. 2 PTA, I would appreciate if you could forward this response to the many parents and friends of I.S. 2 who signed this petition. As you may be aware, I am opposed to the NYC Department of Education's potential "co-location" plan for I.S. 2. I have supported legislation in Albany that would restrict similar co-location plans involving charter schools, and I see this situation as no different. It simply does not make sense to split I.S. 2 and bring in an additional administration. The children of our community would be better served if DOE would devote its resources to smaller class sizes, better equipment, and repairs to I.S. 2's physical plant. The families of I.S. 2 have suffered so much since Hurricane Sandy and are still fighting back to this day. It is entirely unreasonable to subject them to such a sudden and impactful change that the community simply does not want. I voiced my position on this measure at a meeting of the Community Education Council on September 16th. I have also joined my colleagues in calling on our mayoral candidates to denounce this misguided plan (http://www.silive.com/news/index.ssf/2013/09/staten_island_elected_official_7.html). I will be providing official testimony at the DOE Panel for Education hearing on October 3rd. Thank you for contacting me with regard to this very important issue. I will continue working with my colleagues in city government to prevent this plan from going through. Nicole Malliotakis
Joseph Borelli
Former State House of Representatives - New York-62
Matthew J. Titone
Former State House of Representatives - New York-61
Steve Matteo
Steve Matteo
Chief of Staff
Andrew Lanza
Former State Senate - New York-24
Mayor Bill de Blasio
Mayor of New York City
Robert Powell
Robert Powell
PEP Member

Petition Updates

Share this petition

Petition created on September 9, 2013