How can a non-MBBS teach MBBS students!
This petition had 4,054 supporters
In medical colleges, high school students enter and they become Doctors. They are taught by Doctors, unfortunately, but not always. Medical Council of India (statuary body that maintains the standard of education) have given permission to colleges that they can Appoint maximum 30% Non-Medical teachers like MSc and PhD in concerning pre & Para-clinical Departments and upto 50% in Bio-chemistry who teach students of 1st year and 2nd-year MBBS. However, they don't have clinical knowledge but they can support medical teacher. Unfortunately, we had very fewer doctors who are willing to teach in colleges in past because they had to do clinical practice. So due to this reason, MCI had to take this decision. But now in India more than enough specialist doctors are available but still they are screened with Non-medical teachers and on the basis of that single exam/ interview merit list they are posted in colleges. For example, RPSC says in advertisement that "नियमानुसार मेडिको/नॉन मेडिको का अनुपात 70:30 है।" it is misinterpreted Regulation)
Sometimes they may be more sound in theory of syllabus but this does not make them more qualified. Sometimes we see a final year student who passed the exam for the post where that qualification needed but he is not marked as eligible because he does not have qualifying degree. so the first criteria is the qualification degree. a non-medical person always has less qualifying degree. they were given chance just because of lack of doctors in past.
but now somewhere they are more than 30% by promotion or due to Medical Teacher left the job. but still, new non-medical teachers are taken so they are becoming more than 30%. Even to become a 1st grade school teacher in senior secondary education department there is additional BEis needed but to become a assistant professor in medical college just MSc is enough.
At the time of Interview it is compulsary that MD/MS degree must be recognized by MCI, but for MSc Ph.D. recognisation by MCI is not required/applicable. Even a permitted but not recognised MD/MS does not get relaxation but a non medico is relaxed in term of recognisation. why?????
now please think.. perfection of future doctor taught by non medical teacher, who can just teach them theory but could not teach them application of theory in Field.. there are parts in non clinical subjects which must be correlate with clinical subjects like medicine and surgery. For example in 1st year subject there is a practical in syllabus known as "clinical physiology". in this stethoscope is used and they can not explain that what they would listen in a patient.
as well as MCI itself compare 2 these qualification medical and non medical in medical subject which is elaborated at end of this petition.
standard of medical education is falling. persons who can not crack medical entrance test to become doctor are now teaching medical students.this is just like 10th class student is taught by grduate. yes he can teach but not as perfectly as a post graduate teacher . And why , if post graduate teacher is available!!
so we are writing to govt of rajasthan, and MCI and we want your support. if you want that our society/country must get well studied competent doctors please support us by signing this petition.
here is comparison of permitted qualifying degrees of medical and non-medical persons. it is illustrated by MCI in Para 18 of counter affidavit of MCI which is taken as consideration in judgment of D.B. Special Appeal (writ) No. 1878/2014 in THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICIATURE FOR RAJASTHAN AT JAIPUR BENCH, JAIPUR (official judgment file can be downloaded from website of Rajasthan high court http://hcraj.nic.in/courtnic.htm
1. Qualification comparison for the post of tutor/ demonstrator/resident/ registrar
MBBS : 4yr 6 months structured course in medical college, Recognized by Medical council of india (MCI) (course standard controlled by MCI).Course curriculum, syllabus, examination pattern training requirements etc are approved by the medical council of India (MCI), 1 year internship/ practical training - in patient care applicatory studies and hospital management, Clinical / practical exposure to applied anatomy, applied physiology, clinical physiology, applied biochemistry(these are the part of syllabus of UG students):Trained in clinical diagnostic techniques practically in relation to patients
Non medical person
M.Sc : 2 or 3 yrs structured course in medical or non medical college, Not recognized by MCI (course standard not controlled by any statuary body). Course curriculum, syllabus, examination pattern training requirements etc are not approved by the medical council of India (MCI), NO internship/ practical training , No any exposure and training in clinical diagnostic technique
2. Qualification comparison for the post of assistant professor :
MBBS with MD/MS : 3 years structured course with theory paper, written and practical exams recognized by MCI Additional to MBBS as described above, MD/MS included research work (thesis)
M.Sc : This is the same qualification which is required for the post of tutor / demonstrator/resident/ registrar, research work may or may not be included
(please note : till last year here PhD were also required but it is deleted)
3. Qualification comparison for the post of associate professor :
MBBS with MD/MS : This is same qualification which is required for the post of assistant professor, Theory paper, written, practical exam and research work (thesis)
M.Sc with PhD : M.Sc is the same qualification which is required for the post of tutor / demonstrator/resident/ registrar,
Ph.D 2 to 4 yr durtation non structured course, Only research work on a single topic No theory, no practical and no written exam
4. other differences
Medical Teacher :
Mandatory registration required under theprovisions of Indian Medical Council Act,1956.
Amenable to disciplinary action by Medical Council of India under the Indian Medical Council (Professional Conduct,Etiquette and Ethics) Regulations, 2002.
They are accountable for their conduct,etiquette and code of ethics for medical professionals
No such registration required.
Not covered under the provisions of these Regulations.
No such accountability.
Remove 30% relaxation given to medical colleges/insitutions to appoint non-medical teachers.
Today: Against is counting on you
Against Misinterperatation needs your help with “Medical Council of India: Why Non Medical teachers are being appointed in medical college if medical doctors are easily available”. Join Against and 4,053 supporters today.