Petitioning Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen Kane

Abbie Bartels Has Died, After Indefensible Hershey School Decisions. It’s Time To Put Child Welfare Professionals In Charge, Before Any More Children Are Harmed.


Tell Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen Kane It’s Time To Protect Vulnerable Children At The $11 Billion Hershey Charity, Before Another Child Tragically Dies.

Abbie Bartels, a 14-year-old child, is dead. She committed suicide after facing indefensible policies at the Milton Hershey School, a charity with $11 billion in resources, including a controlling interest in the Hershey Company.

Abbie had spent ten years in residential care at Hershey, a school for disadvantaged children, having been enrolled at the age of four. 

Abbie was an honor role student, tenderhearted, and loved by all. She was also a member of an anti-bullying group and always put other children first.

But this spring, Abbie experienced severe depression and was doing her best to work through it. 

Receiving help, Abbie had begun repairing her self-esteem and was on her way to recovery. She was also excitedly anticipating her 8th grade graduation, together with her Hershey friends, whom she thought of as her family.

But ignoring the advice of professionals treating Abbie, Hershey administrators told her that she would not be permitted to return to the school.

They also informed Abbie’s family that she could not even attend her 8th grade graduation and student home picnic —and they threatened to call security if Abbie showed up, treating this tender and harmless child like a pariah. 

Even Hershey staff were mystified by the administration’s posture and struggled to understand why, with the school psychologist breaking down and crying on the phone over it.

But he was powerless to question Hershey leaders whose actions are shielded by Pennsylvania officials, no matter what decisions they make.

With nowhere to turn, Abbie’s fragile psyche could not withstand the added blows: a week later, she took her own life, after telling her brother that she had cried all night and wanted only to return to Hershey, the place she called home. 

Hershey administrators then allowed Abbie to return, to be buried in the Hershey Cemetery, paying for her funeral.

Abbie’s death is part of a long legacy of Hershey misconduct and poor decisions. 

This includes discrimination against kids with HIV, reckless housing experiments, gross misuse of funds, and self-enrichment by “charitable” board members who pay themselves millions, though they lack educational or child welfare qualifications. 

Hershey leadership hiring is also not driven by child welfare interests, but by fealty to the status quo.

It’s not that Hershey does not do vast good. On the contrary, with $11 billion in resources, it helps many needy children each year. But because of poor policy decisions and asset misuse, Hershey only scratches the surface of its enormous child-saving potential. 

Program flaws are revealed in massive attrition: more than one child is removed from Hershey on average every school day, despite $100,000 in per child annual spending. In the last ten years, 2,034 children were removed, while only 1,439 graduated. 

But rather than fixing systemic problems, Hershey’s leaders simply expel the children harmed by them. Abbie’s case is one example.

And sadly, those in charge are protected by their political allies in Pennsylvania government. 

These oversight officials — from both parties — refuse to intervene, no matter how many children are harmed. Even when children are put at risk of sexual abuse due to dangerous housing arrangements, the authorities fail to act against the politically and financially powerful Hershey trust. 

The latest example was the July selection as interim Hershey school president of a politically-connected insider with no educational or child welfare experience –but who happens to be the brother-in-law of Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen Kane’s chief of staff. 

Attorney General Kane has direct oversight responsibility for Hershey; and this questionable appointment demonstrated that disregard for the interests of needy children would continue.

Even worse, just before the appointment, Attorney General Kane gave the Hershey board a free pass when she closed an unprecedented Hershey investigation without any meaningful action. This was despite very serious allegations of board self-enrichment, poor policy, and misuse of charitable funds. Attorney General Kane even let the board completely off the hook for squandering $25 million of child welfare money on a scandalous luxury golf project, raising grave questions that have yet to be answered.

But Attorney General Kane packaged this oversight travesty as “dramatic reform,” relying on public inattentiveness to do so. This brought condemnation from respected charitable trust observers, who warned of the consequences for needy children.

Less than two months later, Abbie Bartels was dead; and the disturbing manner in which Abbie was treated underscores just how dysfunctional Hershey has become.

All of which is why we ask you here to join us in telling Attorney General Kane that she must act now — before another child is harmed on her watch — by placing qualified people in charge at Hershey, and ending the charity’s use as a patronage mill or insider job-mart.

For more information, including historical Hershey background and a video tribute to Abbie, please visit: www.protecthersheychildren.org.

Thank you for helping us to protect Hershey children, and for making sure that no other child ever again has to endure the treatment that Abbie faced.

On behalf of Abbie’s family,

Protect The Hersheys’ Children, Inc.

Please also visit our Facebook page: https://www.facebook.com/protecthersheychildren

For a Harvard Law School presentation on Hershey problems and how the school can save vastly more children, please watch “Making Bitter Chocolate Sweet: The Milton Hershey School's Past and Hoped for Future:” http://tinyurl.com/o3eu6te

Letter to
Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen Kane
Dear Attorney General Kane:

Our hearts are broken: Abbie Bartels, an innocent and tender 14-year-old child, is dead.

Abbie committed suicide after indefensible treatment at the hands of the Milton Hershey School, where she had lived since the age of four.

Your staff had been alerted about Hershey policies, including treating adolescent depression as grounds for expulsion.

You also were alerted about the Hershey school board’s lack of child welfare qualifications and the dangers that this visits on needy kids, including poor policy decisions and questionable leadership selection.

An example of the latter was the July appointment of your own chief of staff’s brother-in-law as the interim Hershey school president, demonstrating a pattern that your office should prevent.

But all warnings were ignored, and now a child has tragically died.

Many other children have also been hurt and scarce child welfare funds have been squandered.

But we want to believe you are willing to intervene and make matters right.

Accordingly, we call on you to:

1) Immediately place all Hershey school policy decisions, including child expulsions, in the hands of a completely reconstituted board, comprised primarily of bona fide child welfare professionals with no political ties.

2) Immediately replace the current Hershey interim school president with a credible, outside, interim leader, who has a proven record of turning around troubled educational facilities.

We stand today with Abbie’s family and with all needy families whose children can be helped by Hershey’s vast resources.

We ask you to act on our request right now, before any more children are harmed.