Petition Closed
Petitioning Japan Ministry of Justice

Extend Author Ownership Rights to Video Game Content Creators

369
Supporters

* * * If you are fluent in Japanese, we could use your help! Please see the Petition Updates for more information! * * *

=====Some Background=====

Keiji Inafune: Co-designer of Mega-Man, Producer for the Oninumsha and Dead Rising series

Yoshinori Ono: Responsible for reviving the Street Fighter series

Hideki Kamiya: Creator of Okami, Viewtiful Joe, and Devil May Cry

Shinji Mikami: Creator of the Resident Evil series, Dino Crisis, and God Hand

All four of these men helped put Capcom on the map with their creations. Three of them have left in disgust due to the current state of their publisher, Capcom, and their stance on the rights of content creators and artists. The one who didn't leave, Ono, was overworked to the point of hospitalization, a disturbing echo of a female Capcom employee who was harassed by her employers to the point of attempted suicide back in December of last year. What's clear is that the working standards maintained by Capcom are far less than ideal for artists who create content that is loved by millions and yet who receive a disproportionately small amount of benefit when compared to publishing executives such as Kenzo Tsujimoto.

Maybe we should take the first step to changing that.

=====What We Want to Do=====

Inafune, Kamiya, and Mikami no longer hold the rights to the franchises they themselves created and put on the map. This may be standard practice for other electronic entertainment publishing giants, but an interesting wrinkle is Japan's traditional stance on intellectual property rights for manga artists. You need only refer to the aptly named Copyright Act of Japan.

=====The Copyright Act=====

Section 3: Contents of Rights

Subsection 1: General Provisions

Article 17 - Rights of author

An author shall enjoy the rights provided for in paragraph (1) of the next Article, Article 19, paragraph (1) and Article 20, paragraph (1)(hereinafter referred to as "moral rights of author") as well as the rights provided for in Articles 21 to 28 (hereinafter referred to as "copyright").

Subsection 3: Types of Rights Comprising a Copyright

Article 21 - Right of Reproduction

The author shall have the exclusive right to reproduce his work.

Article 28 - Right of the original author in the exploitation of a derivative work

In connection with the exploitation of a derivative work, the author of the original work shall have exclusive rights of the same types as those possessed by the author of the derivative work under the provisions of this Subsection.

Sources:

http://www.japaneselawtranslation.go.jp/law/detail/?id=1980&vm=04&re=02&new=1

http://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Copyright_Act_of_Japan

 

There are also said to be laws in Japan that specifically allow manga authors and artists to hold the rights on their creations even after leaving their publisher. Why a conceptually similar level of protection is not afforded to video game content creators is a mystery, especially in light of the specific words of the Copyright Act of Japan.

=====The Point=====

I would like to petition the Japanese Ministry of Justice to propose a law that would seek to extend intellectual property rights to video game creators in the way the Copyright Act of Japan had originally intended.

And I would like to ask all of you to join me.

If you truly care for the medium and not just the industry, if you value what is right over apathy and compromise, and if you value integrity and quality over a publishing machine that seeks to consume more than it creates, please spread the word.

Thank you.

--------------------

Read more:

Inafune Says We Need Heroes

http://www.gamasutra.com/view/feature/6521/we_need_heroes_inafune_speaks.php

The Rise and Collapse of Yoshinori Ono

http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/2012-06-11-the-rise-and-collapse-of-yoshinori-ono

Additional commentary

http://www.cinemablend.com/games/Capcom-Overworks-Ono-Says-Famous-Street-Fighter-Producer-43521.html

Kamiya Comments on the Missing Okami Credits

http://gamasutra.com/php-bin/news_index.php?story=18469

Shinji Mikami Symbolically Commits Digital Seppuku to Demonstrate His Break from Capcom

http://andriasang.com/comiwb/shinji_mikami_project_site/

And finally,

http://geek.pikimal.com/2011/07/30/editorial-japanese-game-designers-are-falling-behind-the-west/

"Over the years we’ve seen the destruction of the JRPG, the marginalization of Japanese game design and the mass exodus of developers from design companies. This all points to a very real problem, and one that is sadly not likely to change anytime soon. Some of our favorite franchises are stuck with inept leadership, and my beloved Japanese aesthetics are being misrepresented and poorly handled by the incompetent and disconnected. Eventually, some significant shift will have to occur, but possibly not before we witness the deaths of even more beloved characters. Mega Man was not the first franchise to die an untimely death, and it will not be the last."

To echo the words of Jody Sol, commenting on Inafune's call for heroes:

Are you a bad enough dude to save the video game industry?

Letter to
Japan Ministry of Justice
I just signed the following petition addressed to: Japan Ministry of Justice.

----------------
Extend Author Ownership Rights to Video Game Content Creators

Keiji Inafune: Co-designer of Mega-Man, Producer for the Oninumsha and Dead Rising series

Yoshinori Ono: Responsible for reviving the Street Fighter series

Hideki Kamiya: Creator of Okami, Viewtiful Joe, and Devil May Cry

Shinji Mikami: Creator of the Resident Evil series, Dino Crisis, and God Hand

All four of these men helped put Capcom on the map with their creations. Three of them have left in disgust due to the current state of their publisher, Capcom, and their stance on the rights of content creators and artists. The one who didn't leave, Ono, was overworked to the point of hospitalization, a disturbing echo a female Capcom employee who was harassed by her employers to the point of attempted suicide back in December of last year. What's clear is that the working standards maintained by Capcom are far less than ideal for individuals who create content that is loved by millions and yet who receive a disproportionately small amount of benefit when compared to their publishing executives such as Kenzo Tsujimoto.

http://www.forbes.com/sites/erikkain/2012/05/19/dragons-dogma-developer-attempts-suicide-over-harassment-files-lawsuit-against-capcom/

Maybe we should take the first step to changing that.

Inafune, Kamiya, and Mikami no longer hold the rights to the franchises they themselves created and put on the map. This may be standard practice for other electronic entertainment publishing giants, but an interesting wrinkle is Japan's traditional stance on intellectual property rights for manga artists. You need only refer to the aptly named Copyright Act of Japan.



Section 3: Contents of Rights

Subsection 1: General Provisions

Article 17 - Rights of author

An author shall enjoy the rights provided for in paragraph (1) of the next Article, Article 19, paragraph (1) and Article 20, paragraph (1)(hereinafter referred to as "moral rights of author") as well as the rights provided for in Articles 21 to 28 (hereinafter referred to as "copyright").

Subsection 3: Types of Rights Comprising a Copyright

Article 21 - Right of Reproduction

The author shall have the exclusive right to reproduce his work.

Article 28 - Right of the original author in the exploitation of a derivative work

In connection with the exploitation of a derivative work, the author of the original work shall have exclusive rights of the same types as those possessed by the author of the derivative work under the provisions of this Subsection.

Sources:

http://www.japaneselawtranslation.go.jp/law/detail/?id=1980&vm=04&re=02&new=1

http://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Copyright_Act_of_Japan#Subsection_2_Moral_rights_of_author

There are also said to be laws in Japan that specifically allow manga authors and artists to hold the rights on their creations even after leaving their publisher. Why a conceptually similar level of protection is not afforded to video game content creators is a mystery, especially in light of the specific words of the Copyright Act of Japan.

I would like to petition the Japanese Ministry of Justice to propose a law that would seek to extend intellectual property rights to video game creators in the way the Copyright Act of Japan had originally intended.

And I would like to ask all of you to join me.

If you truly care for the medium and not just the industry, if you value what is right over apathy and compromise, and if you value integrity and quality over a publishing machine that seeks to consume more than it creates, please spread the word.

Thank you.


Read more:

Inafune Says We Need Heroes:

http://www.gamasutra.com/view/feature/6521/we_need_heroes_inafune_speaks.php

The Rise and Collapse of Yoshinori Ono

http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/2012-06-11-the-rise-and-collapse-of-yoshinori-ono

Additional commentary:

http://www.cinemablend.com/games/Capcom-Overworks-Ono-Says-Famous-Street-Fighter-Producer-43521.html

Kamiya Comments on the Missing Okami Credits

http://gamasutra.com/php-bin/news_index.php?story=18469

Shinji Mikami Symbolically Commits Digital Seppuku to Demonstrate His Break from Capcom:

http://andriasang.com/comiwb/shinji_mikami_project_site/

And finally:

http://geek.pikimal.com/2011/07/30/editorial-japanese-game-designers-are-falling-behind-the-west/

"Over the years we’ve seen the destruction of the JRPG, the marginalization of Japanese game design and the mass exodus of developers from design companies. This all points to a very real problem, and one that is sadly not likely to change anytime soon. Some of our favorite franchises are stuck with inept leadership, and my beloved Japanese aesthetics are being misrepresented and poorly handled by the incompetent and disconnected. Eventually, some significant shift will have to occur, but possibly not before we witness the deaths of even more beloved characters. Mega Man was not the first franchise to die an untimely death, and it will not be the last."

Food for thought
----------------

Sincerely,