Implement Dog Waste Management Solutions in Manhattan

The Issue

As a daily commuter from Wall Street station to Exchange Place, I am subjected, along with countless other pedestrians, to the intolerable smell of urine and the unsightly presence of dog feces on our shared city streets. This reality is not only annoying, but it has potential to pose health risks to children, pedestrians, and other household pets.

High-traffic areas such as Exchange Place have become disproportionately infested by this, depriving residents of their rights to clean, safe, and enjoyable sidewalks. It's about time we address this matter seriously.

The solution? A multi-pronged approach: (1) potential establishment of designated areas in the city for dogs to defecate and (2) implementation of an annual sanitation fee for dog owners in Manhattan. The latter would help fund the maintenance of the designated areas and ensure periodic clean-up of our city streets, making Manhattan a better place for everyone – dog owners, non-dog owners, and dogs themselves. 

In the US, more than 60 million homes have dogs. In New York City alone, 600,000 dogs are registered. If each of these dogs produces an average of half a pound of waste daily, that's hundreds of tons of dog waste generated every day (American Pet Products Association, 2020). This consumption to waste cycle continues unabated with serious implications for the environment and public health.

Therefore, we call upon the authorities of Manhattan to act swiftly and decisively for the establishment of a dog waste management system that includes designated defecation areas and an annual sanitation charge for dog owners. It's time to hold the people accountable who aren't currently being respectful of our shared space. I won't say I have all the answers, because I absolutely do not, but something needs to be done. Please share any and all ideas that you think could be beneficial to the end-goal here. Let's take back our city streets and restore cleanliness to our walks and the safety of our shared environment. Please sign the petition.

avatar of the starter
Olivia PCPetition Starter

73

The Issue

As a daily commuter from Wall Street station to Exchange Place, I am subjected, along with countless other pedestrians, to the intolerable smell of urine and the unsightly presence of dog feces on our shared city streets. This reality is not only annoying, but it has potential to pose health risks to children, pedestrians, and other household pets.

High-traffic areas such as Exchange Place have become disproportionately infested by this, depriving residents of their rights to clean, safe, and enjoyable sidewalks. It's about time we address this matter seriously.

The solution? A multi-pronged approach: (1) potential establishment of designated areas in the city for dogs to defecate and (2) implementation of an annual sanitation fee for dog owners in Manhattan. The latter would help fund the maintenance of the designated areas and ensure periodic clean-up of our city streets, making Manhattan a better place for everyone – dog owners, non-dog owners, and dogs themselves. 

In the US, more than 60 million homes have dogs. In New York City alone, 600,000 dogs are registered. If each of these dogs produces an average of half a pound of waste daily, that's hundreds of tons of dog waste generated every day (American Pet Products Association, 2020). This consumption to waste cycle continues unabated with serious implications for the environment and public health.

Therefore, we call upon the authorities of Manhattan to act swiftly and decisively for the establishment of a dog waste management system that includes designated defecation areas and an annual sanitation charge for dog owners. It's time to hold the people accountable who aren't currently being respectful of our shared space. I won't say I have all the answers, because I absolutely do not, but something needs to be done. Please share any and all ideas that you think could be beneficial to the end-goal here. Let's take back our city streets and restore cleanliness to our walks and the safety of our shared environment. Please sign the petition.

avatar of the starter
Olivia PCPetition Starter

The Decision Makers

NYC Department of Sanitation
NYC Department of Sanitation
Responded
Dog owners know they have a legal responsibility to pick up dog waste, regardless of the weather or conditions on the ground. It is irresponsible and just gross to leave this behind anywhere, whether it’s a sidewalk, a patch of grass or a snow pile. At the same time, all property owners are legally required to keep their sidewalks clean, as well as 18 inches into the roadway, and this would include removing dog waste from their sidewalks. All 311 complaints related to dog waste are investigated daily. And we do issue summonses to property owners for dirty sidewalks -- 5,929 this calendar year alone, although that was for any kind of dirty sidewalk, not just dog waste. • https://www.nyc.gov/site/dsny/what-we-do/cleaning/sidewalks-gutters.page Summonses for dog owners are much, much more difficult to issue, because our enforcement officer would have to catch the owner in the act of leaving a pile behind. We have done many special patrols in areas with high rates of 311 service requests for dog waste, and they have yielded almost zero summonses. In 2024, we did a 3-day stakeout in Mott Haven that yielded just one summons. Then, in 2025, we did special weeklong patrols in Washington Heights, Harlem, Morningside Heights and Flatbush – all in response to 311 service requests – and none of them yielded any summonses. The chances of someone not picking up after their dog while an enforcement officer is watching is very, very slim. So slim, that we issued just two summonses for failure to remove canine waste in 2025. It is clear that people only leave piles behind when they know no one is watching. We are not alone here: Some jurisdictions around the world require owners to submit DNA samples, which are then used to enforce rules requiring people to pick up dog waste. Bolzano, Italy requires this, as do some housing complexes in Des Moines, Iowa, and San Francisco considered it more than a decade ago. This is not something we are considering, but it shows you just how limited the options are. We are, however, exploring the use of mobile cameras to increase enforcement against these careless residents, as well as adding dog waste bag dispensers to some litter baskets. • https://www.theguardian.com/world/2024/jan/17/italian-province-orders-all-dogs-to-be-dna-tested-in-poo-crackdown • https://www.axios.com/local/des-moines/2022/03/01/pooprints-dog-poop-dna-technology-des-moines • https://www.vox.com/2014/2/21/11623728/san-francisco-losing-edge-in-disruptive-doggie-doo-technology Finally, we have also done – and continue to do – several ad campaigns and educational outreach on the issue of dog waste. But really, every dog owner knows what they are supposed to do. In consideration of their neighbors, they should do the right thing and pick up after their dogs. • https://www.cbsnews.com/newyork/news/new-york-city-launches-major-anti-littering-campaign-for-first-time-in-15-years/
New York City Council
3 Members
Tiffany Cabán
New York City Council - District 22
Shekar Krishnan
New York City Council - District 25
Julie Menin
New York City Council - District 5

Supporter Voices

Petition Updates