Hockey Canada: Remove body checking from all levels of Pee Wee & Bantam hockey in Canada.

The Issue

Current medical evidence documents that injuries, specifically concussions, can be substantially reduced if body checking is removed from minor hockey.  Given the recent findings on the long term consequences of concussions, we are asking Hockey Canada to provide a safe playing environment for our Rep and Tiered hockey players: one which reduces the risk of concussions and injury by eliminating body checking.

Hockey Canada's current rules are failing players in the instance when they most need to be protected. We maintain that, if left unchanged, this situation is a serious breach of responsibility and accountability. This is NOT an issue of being for or against body checking- this is a broader issue concerning the health and welfare of Canadian children in sport.

 

Body Checking Fast Facts:

1.  Children and teenagers are more susceptible to concussions than adults.     Long-term consequences of concussions include reduced cognitive function, depression and dementia.

2.  There is an abundance of solid medical evidence which proves that body checking is the single most consistent risk factor for injury to minor hockey players.  Body checking is associated with between 46% and 86% of injuries in minor hockey. The top 3 injuries incurred are concussions, knee sprains, and shoulder dislocations.

3.  Renowned medical organizations such as the Mayo Clinic, the Canadian Paediatric Society, and the American Pediatric Association endorse the action of removing body checking from minor hockey.

4.  Boys play hockey for fun above ALL else. More than 99% of children who play Rep or Tiered hockey in Canada will not have professional hockey careers; after the age of 19 they will play in recreational, non-hitting leagues. 

5.  Hockey Canada continues to debate the issue.  They maintain that body checking is a required skill for players entering into professional hockey careers.  In fact, when body checking is removed from game play, the skill and development actually goes up. The "body checking is part of the game" retort is typically launched from the uninformed, or nostalgic.

6.  The volunteer system of hockey results in gaps in the ability to manage and mitigate potential injury situations, leaving the children at even further risk 

7.  Many boys leave hockey because they do not like the body checking game. As 30% of Canadian youth are overweight or obese, keeping children active should remain a key goal. We want our boys to be players, not spectators. 

Why do we have a minor hockey system designed for the uber-minority that may make it to the NHL instead of for the vast majority of children who want to play competitive hockey for the duration of their lifetime?

This is no longer an issue for Hockey Canada to ponder.  This is a public health crisis.  The time to make change is now. 

For more info visit Safer Hockey on Facebook

Confirmed victory
This petition made change with 1,440 supporters!

The Issue

Current medical evidence documents that injuries, specifically concussions, can be substantially reduced if body checking is removed from minor hockey.  Given the recent findings on the long term consequences of concussions, we are asking Hockey Canada to provide a safe playing environment for our Rep and Tiered hockey players: one which reduces the risk of concussions and injury by eliminating body checking.

Hockey Canada's current rules are failing players in the instance when they most need to be protected. We maintain that, if left unchanged, this situation is a serious breach of responsibility and accountability. This is NOT an issue of being for or against body checking- this is a broader issue concerning the health and welfare of Canadian children in sport.

 

Body Checking Fast Facts:

1.  Children and teenagers are more susceptible to concussions than adults.     Long-term consequences of concussions include reduced cognitive function, depression and dementia.

2.  There is an abundance of solid medical evidence which proves that body checking is the single most consistent risk factor for injury to minor hockey players.  Body checking is associated with between 46% and 86% of injuries in minor hockey. The top 3 injuries incurred are concussions, knee sprains, and shoulder dislocations.

3.  Renowned medical organizations such as the Mayo Clinic, the Canadian Paediatric Society, and the American Pediatric Association endorse the action of removing body checking from minor hockey.

4.  Boys play hockey for fun above ALL else. More than 99% of children who play Rep or Tiered hockey in Canada will not have professional hockey careers; after the age of 19 they will play in recreational, non-hitting leagues. 

5.  Hockey Canada continues to debate the issue.  They maintain that body checking is a required skill for players entering into professional hockey careers.  In fact, when body checking is removed from game play, the skill and development actually goes up. The "body checking is part of the game" retort is typically launched from the uninformed, or nostalgic.

6.  The volunteer system of hockey results in gaps in the ability to manage and mitigate potential injury situations, leaving the children at even further risk 

7.  Many boys leave hockey because they do not like the body checking game. As 30% of Canadian youth are overweight or obese, keeping children active should remain a key goal. We want our boys to be players, not spectators. 

Why do we have a minor hockey system designed for the uber-minority that may make it to the NHL instead of for the vast majority of children who want to play competitive hockey for the duration of their lifetime?

This is no longer an issue for Hockey Canada to ponder.  This is a public health crisis.  The time to make change is now. 

For more info visit Safer Hockey on Facebook

The Decision Makers

Paul Carson
Paul Carson
Vice President of Hockey Development
Responded
Thank you very much for your correspondence to Hockey Canada and those responsible for the administration of the game. Hockey Canada and its 13 regional branches review programs and regulations on a regular basis, including those that may impact player safety. This includes the age at which body checking may be introduced. Regardless of the level at which body checking is introduced; education continues to be the cornerstone in making the hockey environment safer for minor hockey players at all levels. There are many factors at play when managing the way the game is played and how children develop within the sport. Of utmost importance is how coaches are trained which leads to how players are taught in practice and how officials and sport administrators regulate the game. Body checking is a skill that is part of hockey around the world. Coaches are responsible to teach this skill; including preparing players for incidental body contact, which occurs at all levels and all ages of hockey including non-body checking environments. Hockey Canada and its regional branches offer non-body checking streams in many areas of the country. These streams will be offered in more areas in upcoming seasons, with the ultimate goal of providing most Canadian families and players with the option of selecting development streams without body checking in pee wee, bantam and midget hockey. In the 2010-11 season, Hockey Canada introduced an unprecedented ‘zero tolerance’ head contact rule at all levels of minor hockey. Hockey Canada is proud of the work of the member Branches and minor hockey associations in promoting and delivering this rule. In the Canadian Sport For Life position paper on Long Term Athlete Development, there are a number of short comings in the Canadian sport system and those who administer minor hockey should be mindful of these concerns. Simply changing a rule may achieve a temporary change, but it is still important to focus on other challenges that face amateur sport today. These concerns include but are not limited to: over-competing and under training, adult programs imposed on children, male training programs imposed on females, preparation geared to short-term outcomes, knowledgeable coaches at the elite levels, a competition system that interferes with athlete development and the demands for early specialization in sport. Please be assured that Hockey Canada evaluates the game on a regular basis with the goal of making minor hockey a safer environment for all participants, while managing risk that can be an inherent part of an active lifestyle. In closing, I commend you for taking the time to express your point of view and for reminding us that the rules that govern our sport and the way in which we manage the game are constantly under scrutiny. The priority of Hockey Canada is to insure that young people participating in hockey enjoy a safe and positive experience each time they step on the ice. Many, many people play a part in making this happen. Paul Carson Vice President, Hockey Development Hockey Canada
Mike Bruni
Mike Bruni
Chairman of the Board, Hockey Canada
Bob Nicholson
Bob Nicholson
President of Hockey Canada

Petition Updates