Confirmed victory
Petitioning Fox 19 Bill Lanesey and 4 others
This petition was delivered to:
Fox 19
Bill Lanesey
President, CEO, Raycom Media
Paul McTear
Vice President, Human Resources, Raycom Media
Clyde Baucom
Executive Vice President, Chief Operating Officer, Raycom Media
Wayne Daugherty
News Anchor, Fox19
Tricia Mackie

Fox 19: Condemn Tricia Mackie's anti-gay comments

3,656
Supporters

GLAAD and Equality Ohio are calling on Fox 19 (Cincinnati, OH) to condemn comments made by news anchor Tricia Mackie, who called MSNBC host Rachel Maddow an "Angry Young Man" in a Facebook comment. According to incident reports received by Equality Ohio, after a viewer expressed offense to the comment, Mackie stood by her characterization of Maddow as male, responding "you are right. I'm sorry, I should've said 'antagonistic.'"

When another person responded that, in the news business, sexual orientation is irrelevant, Mackie responded, "I knew what I was saying." The exchange appears to have been deleted from Mackie's Facebook page, but screenshots are below.

Referring to Maddow as a "man" because she is a gay woman is completely unacceptable for someone in the business of journalism.

Cincinnati viewers rely on Mackie and Fox 19 to deliver unbiased and fair reporting about the lives of LGBT people in their community. But this is someone who attempted to insult a gay woman by challenging her gender, then stated very clearly that she did so with complete awareness of her actions.

Tricia Mackie undoubtedly tried to insult Maddow because of their political differences, rather than simply because Maddow is gay. But her comments went much further than insulting Maddow's political leanings, and took issue with Maddow's gender, revealing an anti-gay (or at least anti-gender-nonconforming) bias underlying her political beliefs.

Fox 19 and its owner Raycom Media must take swift action to condemn Mackie's remarks, and Mackie must make a full apology. These steps are necessary for both Mackie and the station to prove they can be trusted to report objectively on issues that impact Cincinnati's LGBT community.


Letter to
Fox 19 Bill Lanesey
President, CEO, Raycom Media Paul McTear
Vice President, Human Resources, Raycom Media Clyde Baucom
and 2 others
Executive Vice President, Chief Operating Officer, Raycom Media Wayne Daugherty
News Anchor, Fox19 Tricia Mackie
Dear Fox 19,

Last month, news anchor Tricia Mackie referred to MSNBC host Rachel Maddow, who is an openly gay woman, as an "angry young man." This comment went beyond disagreeing with Maddow's politics and attacked her gender, something Mackie would likely not have done if Maddow did not identify herself the way she does. This comment, though it now appears to have been removed, was never apologized for. In fact, Mackie defended it on her Facebook page, telling someone who was offended "I knew exactly what I was saying."

Your viewers need to know we can trust Fox 19 and Tricia Mackie to deliver unbiased, objective reporting about issues that affect Cincinnati's LGBT community. I am asking for the station to condemn these remarks, and for Mackie to issue an apology to all those who were offended.