Petition Closed
Petitioning Mayor Roger Bergman and 3 others

Fawns To Be Orphaned As Mothers Methodically Executed 09/01/09


Our friends in Grand Haven, MI are fighting to prevent a deer cull from happening again. The council plans to kill deer beginning 9/1/09. Last year, after several garden owners complained about deer eating their plants (sounds familiar?), the city council voted in favor of killing the animals and pregnant doe and fawns were shot at their local cemetery in January.

Don't allow this to happen again! Council persons Mike Fritz and Geri McCaleb have told fellow council members Roger Bergman, John Naser and Ed Nieuwenhuis that they have no idea how many deer there are, how many they plan to kill - especially since a poacher has been killing them for over a year, and no safety measures in place. Geri McCaleb voted to cull and even she thinks it is not a good idea to rush into this.

Please urge them to implement safe non-lethal alternatives instead. Call the City Manager Pat McGinnis and Lt. Joe Boyle at Public Safety.

Please Call – and ask them to document your call:

City Manager Pat McGinnis at 616-847-4888

Lt. Joe Boyle, Public Safety at 616-842-3460

Help us be heard! The letter below will go to the Mayor and two key members of the city council. PLEASE ALSO COPY THE TEXT OF THIS LETTER AND SEND BY EMAIL TO THE OTHER COUNCIL MEMBERS:

E-mail GH City Council Members at:

Pat McGinnis -

Geri McCaleb –

Letters to the editor:

Grand Haven Tribune – (mention you vacation or visit here)

Grand Rapids Press – (200 word limit)



Letter to
Mayor Roger Bergman
Council Member Ed Nieuwenhuis
GHDPS Joe Boyle & Pat McGinnis & Dennis Edwards
and 1 other
Representative Pete Hoekstra
We urge you to reconsider your intent to begin killing deer and orphaning spotted fawn as soon as 9/1/09. You have done no study as to the effects of the last cull. You have no data as to how many deer there are. You did not keep the residents safe during the last cull nor did you alert them to the fact that a poacher was shooting for over a year into our cemetery.

You are turning Grand Haven into an unwelcome place for animals or anyone that loves them, all the while endangering citizens with your violent answers to the human/deer conflict.

It is well documented by MSU and others that there are solutions to the issue of deer browse and yet you refuse to give those peaceful, environmentally friendly methods a chance to work.

Shame on you for continuing your policy of "shooting until the phone stops ringing" and for ignoring the populace while you cater to the squeaky wheel demanding deer die for tulips.

Thank you.

Susan Rhem-Westhoff started this petition with a single signature, and now has 1,404 supporters. Start a petition today to change something you care about.