

Drop the DOJ Investigation into NYC's Poetica Coffee for Turning Away Congressman
The Issue
A small coffee shop in Brooklyn posted something controversial online. Now the federal government is investigating it.
Poetica Coffee, a local cafe in Williamsburg, made headlines after posting on Instagram that it would have turned away Rep. Dan Goldman — a pro-Israel congressman — had staff recognized him during his visit. The post was blunt and politically charged. Many people disagreed with it. The coffee shop later took it down.
But here's what happened next: the Justice Department opened a formal civil rights investigation into the shop. Assistant Attorney General Harmeet Dhillon announced on X that the Civil Rights Division would "bring an enforcement action if warranted."
A business expressing a political opinion — however sharp or uncomfortable — is not a federal civil rights emergency. The Civil Rights Act was designed to protect people from discrimination based on who they are: their race, religion, or national origin. It was not designed to be used as a weapon against small businesses for criticizing politicians.
Rep. Goldman is a sitting member of Congress. He is a public figure. Disagreeing with his politics — or even saying you wouldn't want to serve him because of them — is political speech. It is not the same as refusing to serve someone because of their religion or ethnicity. The government's own filing does not allege Goldman was turned away. He bought a coffee and left.
Using a federal investigation to punish a small business for an Instagram post sets a dangerous precedent. If the government can threaten enforcement action every time a business publicly criticizes a politician, no shop owner — on the left or the right — is safe.
We are calling on the Justice Department to drop this investigation. Protect civil rights law by saving it for cases that actually matter.
482
The Issue
A small coffee shop in Brooklyn posted something controversial online. Now the federal government is investigating it.
Poetica Coffee, a local cafe in Williamsburg, made headlines after posting on Instagram that it would have turned away Rep. Dan Goldman — a pro-Israel congressman — had staff recognized him during his visit. The post was blunt and politically charged. Many people disagreed with it. The coffee shop later took it down.
But here's what happened next: the Justice Department opened a formal civil rights investigation into the shop. Assistant Attorney General Harmeet Dhillon announced on X that the Civil Rights Division would "bring an enforcement action if warranted."
A business expressing a political opinion — however sharp or uncomfortable — is not a federal civil rights emergency. The Civil Rights Act was designed to protect people from discrimination based on who they are: their race, religion, or national origin. It was not designed to be used as a weapon against small businesses for criticizing politicians.
Rep. Goldman is a sitting member of Congress. He is a public figure. Disagreeing with his politics — or even saying you wouldn't want to serve him because of them — is political speech. It is not the same as refusing to serve someone because of their religion or ethnicity. The government's own filing does not allege Goldman was turned away. He bought a coffee and left.
Using a federal investigation to punish a small business for an Instagram post sets a dangerous precedent. If the government can threaten enforcement action every time a business publicly criticizes a politician, no shop owner — on the left or the right — is safe.
We are calling on the Justice Department to drop this investigation. Protect civil rights law by saving it for cases that actually matter.
The Decision Makers
Supporter Voices
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on June 23, 2026
