Save Our Young Learners - Reopen Our Schools

The Issue

Dr. Cascone and Board Members,

Thank you for the effort you have been putting into reopening West Orange schools safely after over nine long months during which many children have suffered emotionally and fallen behind academically in our district.

At this late stage and with so many setbacks, our request is that you stay the course in the face of opposition, and open to the greatest extent possible for all students—with in-person opportunities five days a week for elementary and special education students by the date of January 19, 2021 to allow for quarantine time after the holiday season. 

The science overwhelmingly suggests that young children are not driving transmission of COVID-19, and schools can be safe places for staff and students of all ages, even with spread in the greater community. This is particularly true with simple, low-tech precautions—for ex. masking, face shields, limiting close contact, cohorts, and opening windows for ventilation.

Many local public and private schools, following CDC and state guidelines, have been running for months without major issue. Notably, the YMCA and Boys & Girls Club are operating smoothly in some of our school buildings. Even when cases do occur, the testing, tracing and quarantining process used in other districts has been proven sufficient in limiting in-school spread. 

To ignore all of this evidence is to further children and families’ suffering with no rational justification.

Neither the CDC nor the State of New Jersey mandates the additional air filtration projects, but our district has gone truly above and beyond with preparing for this concern as well. We believe the existing guidelines, which we already exceed, are highly effective, as evidenced by the low number of outbreaks traced to thousands of schools across the state.

While we sympathize with fears of the unknown, we do not want to be driven by fear when making such important decisions. Many of us can no longer afford to delay this return to school any further and will be forced to make difficult choices for the coming year. We must do our best to make special accommodations for staff and continue to offer a virtual option, but we cannot ignore the many in our community who need in-person education now.

Please push forward, follow the science, and prioritize public education and a safe reopening. Thank you.

Articles and resources:

https://services.aap.org/en/pages/2019-novel-coronavirus-covid-19-infections/clinical-guidance/covid-19-planning-considerations-return-to-in-person-education-in-schools/

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.latimes.com/world-nation/story/2020-10-14/preschools-and-daycares-dont-appear-to-drive-coronavirus-infections-new-national-study-shows%3f_amp=true?fbclid=IwAR1g70WnMy-gbZ-j9DCeHHKcuG-DrIBQh8jslgc2sT2_ESX-DCG4y46vZhA

https://www.nytimes.com/2020/10/22/health/coronavirus-schools-children.html?fbclid=IwAR2vg4C_xBBBLq3COjq7hqdh7fu8rY9QStqNPAHgSm1NdVviYtQYAOGts_o

https://www.insider.com/emily-oster-school-infections-low-in-areas-with-rampant-coronavirus-2020-10

This petition had 349 supporters

The Issue

Dr. Cascone and Board Members,

Thank you for the effort you have been putting into reopening West Orange schools safely after over nine long months during which many children have suffered emotionally and fallen behind academically in our district.

At this late stage and with so many setbacks, our request is that you stay the course in the face of opposition, and open to the greatest extent possible for all students—with in-person opportunities five days a week for elementary and special education students by the date of January 19, 2021 to allow for quarantine time after the holiday season. 

The science overwhelmingly suggests that young children are not driving transmission of COVID-19, and schools can be safe places for staff and students of all ages, even with spread in the greater community. This is particularly true with simple, low-tech precautions—for ex. masking, face shields, limiting close contact, cohorts, and opening windows for ventilation.

Many local public and private schools, following CDC and state guidelines, have been running for months without major issue. Notably, the YMCA and Boys & Girls Club are operating smoothly in some of our school buildings. Even when cases do occur, the testing, tracing and quarantining process used in other districts has been proven sufficient in limiting in-school spread. 

To ignore all of this evidence is to further children and families’ suffering with no rational justification.

Neither the CDC nor the State of New Jersey mandates the additional air filtration projects, but our district has gone truly above and beyond with preparing for this concern as well. We believe the existing guidelines, which we already exceed, are highly effective, as evidenced by the low number of outbreaks traced to thousands of schools across the state.

While we sympathize with fears of the unknown, we do not want to be driven by fear when making such important decisions. Many of us can no longer afford to delay this return to school any further and will be forced to make difficult choices for the coming year. We must do our best to make special accommodations for staff and continue to offer a virtual option, but we cannot ignore the many in our community who need in-person education now.

Please push forward, follow the science, and prioritize public education and a safe reopening. Thank you.

Articles and resources:

https://services.aap.org/en/pages/2019-novel-coronavirus-covid-19-infections/clinical-guidance/covid-19-planning-considerations-return-to-in-person-education-in-schools/

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.latimes.com/world-nation/story/2020-10-14/preschools-and-daycares-dont-appear-to-drive-coronavirus-infections-new-national-study-shows%3f_amp=true?fbclid=IwAR1g70WnMy-gbZ-j9DCeHHKcuG-DrIBQh8jslgc2sT2_ESX-DCG4y46vZhA

https://www.nytimes.com/2020/10/22/health/coronavirus-schools-children.html?fbclid=IwAR2vg4C_xBBBLq3COjq7hqdh7fu8rY9QStqNPAHgSm1NdVviYtQYAOGts_o

https://www.insider.com/emily-oster-school-infections-low-in-areas-with-rampant-coronavirus-2020-10

The Decision Makers

Dr. Scott Cascone
Dr. Scott Cascone
Superintendent
Ken Alper
Ken Alper
Board of Education
Jenn Tunnicliffe
Jenn Tunnicliffe
Board of Education
Gary Rothstein
Gary Rothstein
Board of Education
Cheryl Merklinger
Cheryl Merklinger
Board of Education

Petition Updates

Share this petition

Petition created on December 9, 2020