In September 2025, the people of Mobile were horrified by reports that two small dogs were allegedly thrown off the Dog River Bridge. Investigators say Mary Rivers, frustrated that the dogs had eaten her chickens, tossed them from the bridge’s crest. Miraculously, both dogs survived by swimming through the frigid waters to reach the marshland.

This act of cruelty shocked the community, prompting animal rights activists to rally outside the courthouse as Rivers faced a judge. “We want them to prosecute these crimes and stop giving them plea deals,” said one protester. Their fear is that, without a strong response, cases like this will continue to be brushed aside.

Eighteen-year-old Tavoris Gallery, a second defendant who was 17 at the time of the incident, also faces felony animal abuse charges. Yet a judge has already granted him youthful offender status, sealing his file and limiting his possible sentence to a maximum of three years. For many in Mobile, that decision feels like a message that animal cruelty is not treated with the seriousness it deserves.

Mobile County Sheriff Paul Burch himself attended the hearing, something he rarely does. His words echo what advocates have long argued: “Anyone who will abuse an animal, will abuse a person.” This case is about more than two small dogs. It’s about whether Alabama is willing to protect the vulnerable, hold abusers accountable, and take animal cruelty seriously as the felony crime it is.

We call on Mobile County District Attorney Keith Blackwood, Judge Ben Brooks, and Alabama lawmakers to ensure this case is prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law and that no plea deal undermines accountability. Strong sentencing in cases of animal cruelty is not just about justice for the animals — it is about protecting communities from those who may do harm again.

Alabama must send a clear message: animal cruelty will not be tolerated.