

Demand fair grading for poorly written exam
The Issue
Earlier today, June 28th 2026, students at NYU Meyers faced an unprecedented issue that has caused significant distress and frustration. An essential exam, known for its challenging nature, was not just difficult—it was poorly structured and confusing. As a result, nearly every student who took this exam received grades far below their usual performance standards.
The exam in question was riddled with ambiguities and poorly phrased questions, leaving students struggling to understand what was being asked. This is not only unfair but also undermines the integrity of the academic process at our esteemed institution. Exams should be a fair assessment of a student's knowledge and understanding of the subject, not a test of their ability to decipher incoherent questions.
For many students, exams are a crucial determinant of their academic future, affecting scholarships, job opportunities, and postgraduate offers. A single misstep in grading due to a flawed exam paper can have long-lasting repercussions on our futures.
We are calling upon the faculty and administrators to recognize the shortcomings of this particular exam and reconsider the grading. We propose a review of the exam questions and suggest conducting a reevaluation process that accurately reflects students' understanding of the subject matter. This could include adjustments to the grading scale, offering a re-examination with a revised paper, or providing an option for students to submit alternative assessments.
This is not only about fairness but also about maintaining the esteemed reputation of our institution. Students deserve to be evaluated in a manner that truly reflects their hard work and dedication. By signing this petition, we urge the NYU Meyers administration to take swift and just action to rectify this situation. Let's stand together for the integrity of our academic institution and ensure a fair and just resolution for all students affected. Please sign this petition to support our cause and demand the justice we deserve.

30
The Issue
Earlier today, June 28th 2026, students at NYU Meyers faced an unprecedented issue that has caused significant distress and frustration. An essential exam, known for its challenging nature, was not just difficult—it was poorly structured and confusing. As a result, nearly every student who took this exam received grades far below their usual performance standards.
The exam in question was riddled with ambiguities and poorly phrased questions, leaving students struggling to understand what was being asked. This is not only unfair but also undermines the integrity of the academic process at our esteemed institution. Exams should be a fair assessment of a student's knowledge and understanding of the subject, not a test of their ability to decipher incoherent questions.
For many students, exams are a crucial determinant of their academic future, affecting scholarships, job opportunities, and postgraduate offers. A single misstep in grading due to a flawed exam paper can have long-lasting repercussions on our futures.
We are calling upon the faculty and administrators to recognize the shortcomings of this particular exam and reconsider the grading. We propose a review of the exam questions and suggest conducting a reevaluation process that accurately reflects students' understanding of the subject matter. This could include adjustments to the grading scale, offering a re-examination with a revised paper, or providing an option for students to submit alternative assessments.
This is not only about fairness but also about maintaining the esteemed reputation of our institution. Students deserve to be evaluated in a manner that truly reflects their hard work and dedication. By signing this petition, we urge the NYU Meyers administration to take swift and just action to rectify this situation. Let's stand together for the integrity of our academic institution and ensure a fair and just resolution for all students affected. Please sign this petition to support our cause and demand the justice we deserve.

The Decision Makers
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on June 29, 2026