

Create stronger scrutiny for BBC content and commissioning
The Issue
The BBC, a treasured national institution, holds immense responsibility in shaping the narratives that inform, entertain, and engage the public. However, recent years have highlighted shortcomings in the commissioning processes and the accountability of those at the helm of content creation. Despite a celebrated history, the current systems in place fails to ensure that senior commissioners meet consistent standards or demonstrate recognised industry leadership.
Currently, no single BBC commissioner works to Key Performance Indicators (KPIs), leaving a gap in measurable accountability. The vast majority of the commissioning staff are not the best in class nor equipped with the cutting-edge expertise required to meet evolving audience needs. Many personnel are entrenched in outdated practices, with real experience deficits that do not reflect the vibrant and diverse world we live in today.
These issues contribute to a pattern of controversies, declining viewer numbers, and general underperformance. Notably, there is a visible absence of published frameworks assessing whether the decisions made by senior staff truly benefit the audience. Despite this, many commissioners have remained shielded from public scrutiny or formal accountability measures, with some even advancing in their roles.
To address these systemic issues, it is imperative that we establish a new level of governance that surpasses the current oversight functions provided by Ofcom and Pact. A dedicated, independent body should be formed to scrutinize, evaluate, and ensure that every decision made by commissioning personnel is in the best interest of the public. Such a body would not only uphold higher standards but also provide the transparency and accountability necessary for the BBC to maintain its integrity as a public service broadcaster.
This petition is vital to uphold the trust and calibre of the BBC, ensuring that it remains a beacon of quality and innovation for future generations. By adding your signature, you can help advocate for a BBC that is responsive, forward-thinking, and truly representative of its audience's needs. Sign the petition to join the call for a stronger, more informed level of scrutiny on all BBC content and commissioning personnel.
60
The Issue
The BBC, a treasured national institution, holds immense responsibility in shaping the narratives that inform, entertain, and engage the public. However, recent years have highlighted shortcomings in the commissioning processes and the accountability of those at the helm of content creation. Despite a celebrated history, the current systems in place fails to ensure that senior commissioners meet consistent standards or demonstrate recognised industry leadership.
Currently, no single BBC commissioner works to Key Performance Indicators (KPIs), leaving a gap in measurable accountability. The vast majority of the commissioning staff are not the best in class nor equipped with the cutting-edge expertise required to meet evolving audience needs. Many personnel are entrenched in outdated practices, with real experience deficits that do not reflect the vibrant and diverse world we live in today.
These issues contribute to a pattern of controversies, declining viewer numbers, and general underperformance. Notably, there is a visible absence of published frameworks assessing whether the decisions made by senior staff truly benefit the audience. Despite this, many commissioners have remained shielded from public scrutiny or formal accountability measures, with some even advancing in their roles.
To address these systemic issues, it is imperative that we establish a new level of governance that surpasses the current oversight functions provided by Ofcom and Pact. A dedicated, independent body should be formed to scrutinize, evaluate, and ensure that every decision made by commissioning personnel is in the best interest of the public. Such a body would not only uphold higher standards but also provide the transparency and accountability necessary for the BBC to maintain its integrity as a public service broadcaster.
This petition is vital to uphold the trust and calibre of the BBC, ensuring that it remains a beacon of quality and innovation for future generations. By adding your signature, you can help advocate for a BBC that is responsive, forward-thinking, and truly representative of its audience's needs. Sign the petition to join the call for a stronger, more informed level of scrutiny on all BBC content and commissioning personnel.
Supporter Voices
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on 1 August 2026