Bring back peanut butter cookies at Subway

Recent signers:
delilah jones and 11 others have signed recently.

The Issue

Peanut butter cookies at Subway have always been more than just a sweet treat for many of us. For me, they are a cherished part of my childhood memories. Every bite of those delicious cookies takes me back to simpler times, offering comfort and warmth when I needed it the most. They have been there for me during countless moments in life, a familiar taste that never failed to lift my spirits.

However, I recently discovered that Subway has unfortunately discontinued this beloved cookie from their menu. This decision has saddened countless fans, leaving us without our go-to dessert. In an age where personalized and meaningful consumer experiences are valued, it is disheartening to see such a cherished item disappear.

Subway has always been a brand that listens to its customers, making continuous improvements and innovations to its menu based on customer demand. They have shown responsiveness to public feedback in the past, and we hope they will do so again.

By signing this petition, we are collectively urging Subway to bring back their peanut butter cookies. It’s more than just a cookie; it’s a piece of our lives that many of us are deeply passionate about. Let's unite and show Subway just how important these cookies are to us.

Please sign this petition to ask Subway to listen to its customers and bring back our much-loved peanut butter cookies. Together, we can revive a cherished sweet treat for future memories and enjoyment. Your signature can make a difference. Let's bring back those memories in the form of a delicious cookie!

16

Recent signers:
delilah jones and 11 others have signed recently.

The Issue

Peanut butter cookies at Subway have always been more than just a sweet treat for many of us. For me, they are a cherished part of my childhood memories. Every bite of those delicious cookies takes me back to simpler times, offering comfort and warmth when I needed it the most. They have been there for me during countless moments in life, a familiar taste that never failed to lift my spirits.

However, I recently discovered that Subway has unfortunately discontinued this beloved cookie from their menu. This decision has saddened countless fans, leaving us without our go-to dessert. In an age where personalized and meaningful consumer experiences are valued, it is disheartening to see such a cherished item disappear.

Subway has always been a brand that listens to its customers, making continuous improvements and innovations to its menu based on customer demand. They have shown responsiveness to public feedback in the past, and we hope they will do so again.

By signing this petition, we are collectively urging Subway to bring back their peanut butter cookies. It’s more than just a cookie; it’s a piece of our lives that many of us are deeply passionate about. Let's unite and show Subway just how important these cookies are to us.

Please sign this petition to ask Subway to listen to its customers and bring back our much-loved peanut butter cookies. Together, we can revive a cherished sweet treat for future memories and enjoyment. Your signature can make a difference. Let's bring back those memories in the form of a delicious cookie!

The Decision Makers

Subway Executive Team
Subway Executive Team
SUBWAY UK
SUBWAY UK

Supporter Voices

Petition Updates

Share this petition

Petition created on November 5, 2025