Bring back Nutter Butter cereal!


Bring back Nutter Butter cereal!
The Issue
Post’s Nutter Butter cereal is a beloved flavor that captured the hearts of many cereal and peanut butter enthusiasts. Known for its irresistible peanut butter flavor, this cereal wasn’t just a breakfast option, but a heavenly experience. Its unique texture and taste left an indelible mark on those fortunate enough to enjoy it.
The disappearance of Post’s Nutter Butter cereal from store shelves has left a void in the lives of countless breakfast lovers. The deliciously smooth peanut butter crunch that defined this cereal is sorely missed, and current alternatives simply do not measure up. People from all walks of life feel the absence of that familiar first bite keenly.
It's more than a cereal; It’s the absolute BEST peanut butter cereal I have ever had, and nothing else in existence holds a candle to it. The pieces were the perfect level of crunchiness and didn’t get soggy too fast, the coating was perfectly smooth and sweet and actually tasted like real peanut butter, it was just all around PERFECT! In a world where food brings us comfort and warmth, reintroducing Post’s Nutter Butter cereal can bring joy and smiles back to breakfast tables everywhere.
I, as well as many others like me, urge Post Consumer Brands to consider bringing back this special cereal that so many hold dear. By doing so, they would not only be responding to the demands of passionate Nutter Butter fans and peanut butter lovers in general, but also reviving a product that aligns with their legacy of producing iconic and beloved cereals.
Join us in petitioning for the return of Post’s Nutter Butter cereal and let’s make breakfast timeless once more. Please sign this petition to show your support for the comeback of a true masterpiece!

14
The Issue
Post’s Nutter Butter cereal is a beloved flavor that captured the hearts of many cereal and peanut butter enthusiasts. Known for its irresistible peanut butter flavor, this cereal wasn’t just a breakfast option, but a heavenly experience. Its unique texture and taste left an indelible mark on those fortunate enough to enjoy it.
The disappearance of Post’s Nutter Butter cereal from store shelves has left a void in the lives of countless breakfast lovers. The deliciously smooth peanut butter crunch that defined this cereal is sorely missed, and current alternatives simply do not measure up. People from all walks of life feel the absence of that familiar first bite keenly.
It's more than a cereal; It’s the absolute BEST peanut butter cereal I have ever had, and nothing else in existence holds a candle to it. The pieces were the perfect level of crunchiness and didn’t get soggy too fast, the coating was perfectly smooth and sweet and actually tasted like real peanut butter, it was just all around PERFECT! In a world where food brings us comfort and warmth, reintroducing Post’s Nutter Butter cereal can bring joy and smiles back to breakfast tables everywhere.
I, as well as many others like me, urge Post Consumer Brands to consider bringing back this special cereal that so many hold dear. By doing so, they would not only be responding to the demands of passionate Nutter Butter fans and peanut butter lovers in general, but also reviving a product that aligns with their legacy of producing iconic and beloved cereals.
Join us in petitioning for the return of Post’s Nutter Butter cereal and let’s make breakfast timeless once more. Please sign this petition to show your support for the comeback of a true masterpiece!

14
The Decision Makers
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on June 23, 2025