Stop the August 11 Fogging in Menlo Park; Set up Public Forums to Discuss Mosquito Control

The Issue

The San Mateo County Vector Control District has scheduled a pesticide mosquito fogging for Monday night, August 11 (9pm to 5am) in West Menlo Park.  This was announced Friday mid-day.  The purpose is to eradicate mosquitos that have tested positive for West Nile Virus. The link below shows a map of the targeted fogging area, including a large residential area of West Menlo Park that encapsulates many public and private schools.

http://www.smcmad.org/data/press_releases/2014/Press_Release_fogging_WNV_Aug_11_2014.pdf

Pesticides used in fogging are pervasive and long-lasting in soils, plants, and water supplies with long-term human health implications.  We have established a petition to stop the scheduled fogging until public forums have been set up that engage Menlo Park residents on this matter, including healthier alternatives, and a robust cost-benefit analysis that accounts for the long-ranging health effects of pesticide fogging versus other forms of mosquito control.  Please sign now!

 

More details 

Numerous scientific studies, including one by the Harvard School of Public Health, have shown that mosquito fogging is dangerous to human health and ineffective at controlling targeted mosquito populations. (See links below for details.) Given that one of the groups most vulnerable to pesticide fogging is children, it is especially disconcerting that this area includes many young families, public parks, and numerous public and private schools such as Oak Knoll Elementary, Hillview, Sacred Heart, various preschools (and is also across the street from Menlo School).

 

Do safe approaches to control West Nile Virus exist?  Yes, they do, and Menlo Park residents (and parents of children who attend schools in this area) should have the right to fully vet those alternatives in public forums before our community is fogged.  Links below on safe alternatives.

 

The San Mateo Vector Control Agency and City of Menlo Park only notified the public on Friday, and we have about 24 hours to convince the Board of Supervisors, Vector Control Agency, and Menlo Park City Council and mayor that it is NOT OK to proceed with the scheduled fogging.  The fogging must be canceled until our residents can engage on this topic.  Public forums must be scheduled that engage Menlo Park residents, examine alternative approaches, and undertake a cost-benefit analysis that fully examines the long-ranging health effects of fogging versus other alternatives in a suburban area like Menlo Park.

 

To read more about safe alternatives, related scientific studies, and other local groups struggling with these issues, see:

 

Summary of Harvard study:

http://www.beyondpesticides.org/photostories/week_79_8_17_06/week79.php

UC Davis study linking chemical exposure from neighboring communities to birth defects: 

http://www.ucdmc.ucdavis.edu/publish/news/newsroom/8978

Open Letter By Concerned Physicians and Scientists:

http://www.stopwestnilesprayingnow.org/Concerned_Phys_Sci_WNV.pdf

 

Pesticide Dosing Myths:

http://www.stopwestnilesprayingnow.org/SafeDoseMyth.html

 

More Facts and Alternatives:

http://www.stopwestnilesprayingnow.org/?PesticideFacts.htm

 

 

Sincerely,

 

Menlo Park residents and parents of children attending schools in West Menlo Park

This petition had 398 supporters

The Issue

The San Mateo County Vector Control District has scheduled a pesticide mosquito fogging for Monday night, August 11 (9pm to 5am) in West Menlo Park.  This was announced Friday mid-day.  The purpose is to eradicate mosquitos that have tested positive for West Nile Virus. The link below shows a map of the targeted fogging area, including a large residential area of West Menlo Park that encapsulates many public and private schools.

http://www.smcmad.org/data/press_releases/2014/Press_Release_fogging_WNV_Aug_11_2014.pdf

Pesticides used in fogging are pervasive and long-lasting in soils, plants, and water supplies with long-term human health implications.  We have established a petition to stop the scheduled fogging until public forums have been set up that engage Menlo Park residents on this matter, including healthier alternatives, and a robust cost-benefit analysis that accounts for the long-ranging health effects of pesticide fogging versus other forms of mosquito control.  Please sign now!

 

More details 

Numerous scientific studies, including one by the Harvard School of Public Health, have shown that mosquito fogging is dangerous to human health and ineffective at controlling targeted mosquito populations. (See links below for details.) Given that one of the groups most vulnerable to pesticide fogging is children, it is especially disconcerting that this area includes many young families, public parks, and numerous public and private schools such as Oak Knoll Elementary, Hillview, Sacred Heart, various preschools (and is also across the street from Menlo School).

 

Do safe approaches to control West Nile Virus exist?  Yes, they do, and Menlo Park residents (and parents of children who attend schools in this area) should have the right to fully vet those alternatives in public forums before our community is fogged.  Links below on safe alternatives.

 

The San Mateo Vector Control Agency and City of Menlo Park only notified the public on Friday, and we have about 24 hours to convince the Board of Supervisors, Vector Control Agency, and Menlo Park City Council and mayor that it is NOT OK to proceed with the scheduled fogging.  The fogging must be canceled until our residents can engage on this topic.  Public forums must be scheduled that engage Menlo Park residents, examine alternative approaches, and undertake a cost-benefit analysis that fully examines the long-ranging health effects of fogging versus other alternatives in a suburban area like Menlo Park.

 

To read more about safe alternatives, related scientific studies, and other local groups struggling with these issues, see:

 

Summary of Harvard study:

http://www.beyondpesticides.org/photostories/week_79_8_17_06/week79.php

UC Davis study linking chemical exposure from neighboring communities to birth defects: 

http://www.ucdmc.ucdavis.edu/publish/news/newsroom/8978

Open Letter By Concerned Physicians and Scientists:

http://www.stopwestnilesprayingnow.org/Concerned_Phys_Sci_WNV.pdf

 

Pesticide Dosing Myths:

http://www.stopwestnilesprayingnow.org/SafeDoseMyth.html

 

More Facts and Alternatives:

http://www.stopwestnilesprayingnow.org/?PesticideFacts.htm

 

 

Sincerely,

 

Menlo Park residents and parents of children attending schools in West Menlo Park

The Decision Makers

Ray Mueller
Ray Mueller
Mayor, City of Menlo Park
Responded
Dear Neighbors, On August 11th, 2014, I spoke with President of the San Mateo County Board of Supervisors, Dave Pine. President Pine and I agreed that a request should be made to the San Mateo County Mosquito Abatement District and San Mateo County Health Officer, to delay the fogging for two days so a public hearing could be held, if the delay did not pose an unacceptable health risk. President Pine made that request on our behalf. The request was heard and denied, and the fogging proceeded that evening. Presently, the City of Menlo Park, the County of San Mateo, and the San Mateo County Mosquito Abatement District are scheduling a public meeting for public to be heard and to have questions and concerns addressed. I appreciate all of the time, energy, and feedback every has displayed in the last few days, and have enjoyed my interactions with Angela and Justin Davis, as they pursued this issue. They represented all of you well. In your service, Ray Mueller Mayor of Menlo Park
Rich Gordon
Former State House of Representatives - California-24
Don Horsley
Don Horsley
San Mateo County District 3 Supervisor
Catherine Carlton
Catherine Carlton
Mayor Pro Tem, City of Menlo Park
Richard Cline
Richard Cline
Council Member, City of Menlo Park

Petition Updates