Exclude Golden Temple/Harmandar Sahib (India) from Tentative World Heritage Site List

The Issue

To Exclude Harmandar Sahib (India) from Tentative World Heritage Site List          UNESCO - WHS  ( Reference No-1858 , Date-05.01.2004 )

Commitee for World Heritage List of UNESCO has to decide in near future.

The “Harmandar Sahib” or “Harimandir” or “Darbar Sahib” is Sikh Gurdwara (main religious place of worship) at Amritsar, India.  At Present the body of Sikhs that is responsible for upkeeping and management of Harmandar Sahib is SGPC ( Shiromani Gurdwara Prabandhak Commitee),  In the present dossier, there is already a provision for a body consisting of two representatives of Central government, two from State (Punjab) government and four experts chosen by the government and only ONE SGPC members, to supervise management and protection of the site for heritage purpose.
               The representatives from central and state government do not have to be Sikhs, they can even be anyone the government nominates.
               Any future development in the complex will need the permission of this body.
               Any decisions taken by SGPC or Sikhs that could reflect on the heritage status or have direct or indirect effect on the buildings, can be vetoed by this body. For instance if the Sikhs decide to hold a month long event to celebrate the anniversary of Sri Akal Takht Sahib (Religious Seat), the body can over-rule this.

        The above shows the extent of interference of the Indian government in the religious affair of Sikhs.

                To understand the present day situation it is important to understand the alliances of Political parties in Punjab State, in Punjab state at present Shiromani Akali Dal(SAD) and Bhartiya Janta Party (BJP) have a coalition government. SGPC member selection is  done under the influence of SAD and BJP in the background. BJP is pure Hindu party (Non-Sikh) with a backing of Hindu radical groups RSS, Bajrang Dal, Shiv Sena etc. At the Central Government level BJP is already in absolute majority, BJP has a necessarily a Hinduist agenda which is reflected by resending the proposal of Harmandar Sahib to UNESCO in 2014 with total Media black out, the news did not appear in any News Paper or TV channel, thats the reason it reflects that government wants to proceed secretly about this issue, the issue is burning issue, may be not even 1%  Sikhs are aware of this, that shows the bad intentions of the BJP ruled Central government. It is to remind that burning of five churches in Delhi and two in Jabalpur in 2015 were not reported on TV at all. The sensorship is to that extent (e.g).

The tragic series of events culminating in 1984 in Operation Bluestar by Indian Army on Harmandar Sahib killing about 3000 Sikhs – which caused serious damage to the complex and to the Akal Takht Sahib in particular – illustrate the state’s lack of respect for the complex’s sanctity. The Sikh Reference Library was purposely set on fire, the library contained rare books and manuscripts on Sikh religion, history, and culture. It also contained handwritten manuscripts of the Guru Granth Sahib (Holy Book of Sikhs) and Hukmnamas (orders of Guru) containing signatures of Sikh Gurus The library also held documents related to the Indian Independence Movement.. About fate of Sikh Reference Library, A former inspector for the Central Bureau of Investigation, (CBI) turned whistleblower in 2003, revealed he was part of a five member team CBI packed the documents into 165 numbered gunny sacks and bundled the material into waiting army vehicles and taken to known location, the case is with Jury. Toshakhana (Store for valueables) was partially destroyed and rest confiscated by Indian Government. Today school history books contain wrong history of Sikhs. No representations are looked into. Destroying the history means Government is trying to do ethnic cleansing.

                Sikhs are already not given separate Identity in the Indian Constitution nor we have Sikh Personal Law in the Indian Constitution. Article 25 considers  Sikhs as Hindus which is not less than an abuse for Sikhs.

                SGPC is a single body of Sikhs out of hundred others and does not represent all Sikhs of the world and not even Sikhs in India. It appears it had moved this proposal (Harmandar Sahib’s nomination for WHS) to the Central Government under influence of SAD and BJP.

                For any such move to get Harmandar Sahib nominated for WHS, the UNESCO should get referendum done by the Sikh community world-wide and Indian Government  should not interfere at all.

                The building of Harmandar Sahib was demolished 3 times in 18th Century by Mughal Rulers, The building was reconstructed FULLY, how such a building can be considered for WHS by UNESCO, it is a big question?

                The entire periphery of Harmandar Sahib is property of Sikhs and not of Indian Government. Majority of land on which it is constructed was bought by Sikh Gurus before 1574 and committee for WHS must ask this to Indian Government.

Whenever Sikh community experts are called for opinion please make sure person must declare himself as Sikh. There should be equal participation from representatives from various countries as this is concerned to the Sikhs of whole world. This case should not be compared with Vatican city. 

                Therefore considering the grievances of the Sikh community, The name of “Harmandar Sahib” please be termed as “Not appropriate to be considered for WHS” and may therefore be permanently excluded from the tentative list. 

References :    sikh24.com      scroll.in

http://www.sikhnugget.com/2010/06/sgpc-displays-rare-historic-treasures.html

http://www.gurmatbibek.com/contents.php?id=414

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sikh_Reference_Library

avatar of the starter
Baljeet SinghPetition StarterI am in bad habit of setting wrong into right. I can't syncronise with Indian society so I have hardly any friends.
This petition had 82 supporters

The Issue

To Exclude Harmandar Sahib (India) from Tentative World Heritage Site List          UNESCO - WHS  ( Reference No-1858 , Date-05.01.2004 )

Commitee for World Heritage List of UNESCO has to decide in near future.

The “Harmandar Sahib” or “Harimandir” or “Darbar Sahib” is Sikh Gurdwara (main religious place of worship) at Amritsar, India.  At Present the body of Sikhs that is responsible for upkeeping and management of Harmandar Sahib is SGPC ( Shiromani Gurdwara Prabandhak Commitee),  In the present dossier, there is already a provision for a body consisting of two representatives of Central government, two from State (Punjab) government and four experts chosen by the government and only ONE SGPC members, to supervise management and protection of the site for heritage purpose.
               The representatives from central and state government do not have to be Sikhs, they can even be anyone the government nominates.
               Any future development in the complex will need the permission of this body.
               Any decisions taken by SGPC or Sikhs that could reflect on the heritage status or have direct or indirect effect on the buildings, can be vetoed by this body. For instance if the Sikhs decide to hold a month long event to celebrate the anniversary of Sri Akal Takht Sahib (Religious Seat), the body can over-rule this.

        The above shows the extent of interference of the Indian government in the religious affair of Sikhs.

                To understand the present day situation it is important to understand the alliances of Political parties in Punjab State, in Punjab state at present Shiromani Akali Dal(SAD) and Bhartiya Janta Party (BJP) have a coalition government. SGPC member selection is  done under the influence of SAD and BJP in the background. BJP is pure Hindu party (Non-Sikh) with a backing of Hindu radical groups RSS, Bajrang Dal, Shiv Sena etc. At the Central Government level BJP is already in absolute majority, BJP has a necessarily a Hinduist agenda which is reflected by resending the proposal of Harmandar Sahib to UNESCO in 2014 with total Media black out, the news did not appear in any News Paper or TV channel, thats the reason it reflects that government wants to proceed secretly about this issue, the issue is burning issue, may be not even 1%  Sikhs are aware of this, that shows the bad intentions of the BJP ruled Central government. It is to remind that burning of five churches in Delhi and two in Jabalpur in 2015 were not reported on TV at all. The sensorship is to that extent (e.g).

The tragic series of events culminating in 1984 in Operation Bluestar by Indian Army on Harmandar Sahib killing about 3000 Sikhs – which caused serious damage to the complex and to the Akal Takht Sahib in particular – illustrate the state’s lack of respect for the complex’s sanctity. The Sikh Reference Library was purposely set on fire, the library contained rare books and manuscripts on Sikh religion, history, and culture. It also contained handwritten manuscripts of the Guru Granth Sahib (Holy Book of Sikhs) and Hukmnamas (orders of Guru) containing signatures of Sikh Gurus The library also held documents related to the Indian Independence Movement.. About fate of Sikh Reference Library, A former inspector for the Central Bureau of Investigation, (CBI) turned whistleblower in 2003, revealed he was part of a five member team CBI packed the documents into 165 numbered gunny sacks and bundled the material into waiting army vehicles and taken to known location, the case is with Jury. Toshakhana (Store for valueables) was partially destroyed and rest confiscated by Indian Government. Today school history books contain wrong history of Sikhs. No representations are looked into. Destroying the history means Government is trying to do ethnic cleansing.

                Sikhs are already not given separate Identity in the Indian Constitution nor we have Sikh Personal Law in the Indian Constitution. Article 25 considers  Sikhs as Hindus which is not less than an abuse for Sikhs.

                SGPC is a single body of Sikhs out of hundred others and does not represent all Sikhs of the world and not even Sikhs in India. It appears it had moved this proposal (Harmandar Sahib’s nomination for WHS) to the Central Government under influence of SAD and BJP.

                For any such move to get Harmandar Sahib nominated for WHS, the UNESCO should get referendum done by the Sikh community world-wide and Indian Government  should not interfere at all.

                The building of Harmandar Sahib was demolished 3 times in 18th Century by Mughal Rulers, The building was reconstructed FULLY, how such a building can be considered for WHS by UNESCO, it is a big question?

                The entire periphery of Harmandar Sahib is property of Sikhs and not of Indian Government. Majority of land on which it is constructed was bought by Sikh Gurus before 1574 and committee for WHS must ask this to Indian Government.

Whenever Sikh community experts are called for opinion please make sure person must declare himself as Sikh. There should be equal participation from representatives from various countries as this is concerned to the Sikhs of whole world. This case should not be compared with Vatican city. 

                Therefore considering the grievances of the Sikh community, The name of “Harmandar Sahib” please be termed as “Not appropriate to be considered for WHS” and may therefore be permanently excluded from the tentative list. 

References :    sikh24.com      scroll.in

http://www.sikhnugget.com/2010/06/sgpc-displays-rare-historic-treasures.html

http://www.gurmatbibek.com/contents.php?id=414

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sikh_Reference_Library

avatar of the starter
Baljeet SinghPetition StarterI am in bad habit of setting wrong into right. I can't syncronise with Indian society so I have hardly any friends.

The Decision Makers

UNESCO WHS -Chairperson: Mr Jacek Purchla (Poland) Rapporteur: Mr Muhammad Juma (Tanzania)
UNESCO WHS -Chairperson: Mr Jacek Purchla (Poland) Rapporteur: Mr Muhammad Juma (Tanzania)
World Heritage Centre UNESCO 7, Place de Fontenoy 75352 Paris CEDEX 07 France Tel.: +33 (0)1 45 68 4
Petition updates