Take Action: Stop DOJ Overreach in the Luigi Mangione Case

Recent signers:
Damon Carlson and 19 others have signed recently.

The Issue

Justice should serve the people—not private interests or prosecutorial overreach.

The Department of Justice (DOJ) has filed federal charges against Luigi Mangione in connection with the death of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson. While the tragic nature of this case is clear, the federal charges raise serious concerns about fairness, misuse of federal laws, and undue corporate influence.

What’s Wrong?

  1. Federal Charges Are Redundant.  Luigi Mangione already faces prosecution in New York State for premeditated murder. The federal charges, including stalking under 18 U.S.C. § 2261A, are redundant and misapplied. Stalking laws were designed to address harassment and intimidation, not short-term surveillance linked to a single act of violence.
  2. Federal Jurisdiction is Weak. Federal intervention hinges on Mangione’s travel from Georgia to New York, but the alleged conduct occurred entirely within New York. This incidental travel does not justify federal prosecution.
  3. Corporate Influence in Prosecution. Reports suggest the insurance industry pressured the DOJ to pursue federal charges as a deterrent for future violence against executives. If true, this raises serious concerns about the DOJ serving private interests rather than justice.
  4. Overreach Undermines Justice. Dual prosecution—charging Mangione in both federal and state courts—appears to circumvent double jeopardy protections, giving prosecutors undue leverage to secure a conviction. 

Why This Matters

  1. Justice Must Be Fair. Allowing private industries to influence prosecutorial decisions undermines public trust in the justice system.
  2. Federal Resources Should Serve Public Interest. Misusing federal laws in state-level cases wastes resources and sets a dangerous precedent.
  3. Prevent Abuse of Power. Stretching federal stalking laws to cover premeditated murder dilutes their purpose and risks overreach in future cases.

What We Demand

To ensure justice is fair, independent, and aligned with the law, we call for the following actions:

  1. Drop the Federal Charges. The DOJ should allow this case to proceed solely under New York State jurisdiction, where the alleged conduct occurred and where the charges better reflect the facts.
  2. A Congressional Investigation.The House and Senate Judiciary Committees must investigate the DOJ’s decision to pursue federal charges, including:Reviewing whether undue influence from the insurance industry played a role.Evaluating the misuse of federal stalking statutes in this case.
  3. Transparency from the DOJ. The DOJ must explain its decision-making process and ensure its actions are free from external pressures or private interests.

Why Now Is the Time to Act
This case sets a dangerous precedent for federal overreach, misuse of laws, and corporate influence in the justice system. If we don't act now:

  • Federal prosecutors may continue stretching laws like the stalking statute, diluting their purpose.
  • Corporations could gain more power to influence prosecutions for private interests.
  • Dual prosecution tactics will erode defendants’ rights and trust in justice.
  • Immediate action can stop these abuses, ensure fair prosecution, and protect the integrity of our justice system. 


Sign the petition and demand accountability now—before it’s too late.
This case sets a dangerous precedent for federal overreach and corporate influence in criminal prosecutions. Sign this petition to demand fair justice in the Luigi Mangione case. Together, we can send a clear message: Justice must be impartial, independent, and free from abuse of power.

 
Call to Action
Share this petition: Help us spread the word by sharing this petition with your friends, family, and social networks. Together, we can demand accountability and protect the integrity of our justice system.

 
 

541

Recent signers:
Damon Carlson and 19 others have signed recently.

The Issue

Justice should serve the people—not private interests or prosecutorial overreach.

The Department of Justice (DOJ) has filed federal charges against Luigi Mangione in connection with the death of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson. While the tragic nature of this case is clear, the federal charges raise serious concerns about fairness, misuse of federal laws, and undue corporate influence.

What’s Wrong?

  1. Federal Charges Are Redundant.  Luigi Mangione already faces prosecution in New York State for premeditated murder. The federal charges, including stalking under 18 U.S.C. § 2261A, are redundant and misapplied. Stalking laws were designed to address harassment and intimidation, not short-term surveillance linked to a single act of violence.
  2. Federal Jurisdiction is Weak. Federal intervention hinges on Mangione’s travel from Georgia to New York, but the alleged conduct occurred entirely within New York. This incidental travel does not justify federal prosecution.
  3. Corporate Influence in Prosecution. Reports suggest the insurance industry pressured the DOJ to pursue federal charges as a deterrent for future violence against executives. If true, this raises serious concerns about the DOJ serving private interests rather than justice.
  4. Overreach Undermines Justice. Dual prosecution—charging Mangione in both federal and state courts—appears to circumvent double jeopardy protections, giving prosecutors undue leverage to secure a conviction. 

Why This Matters

  1. Justice Must Be Fair. Allowing private industries to influence prosecutorial decisions undermines public trust in the justice system.
  2. Federal Resources Should Serve Public Interest. Misusing federal laws in state-level cases wastes resources and sets a dangerous precedent.
  3. Prevent Abuse of Power. Stretching federal stalking laws to cover premeditated murder dilutes their purpose and risks overreach in future cases.

What We Demand

To ensure justice is fair, independent, and aligned with the law, we call for the following actions:

  1. Drop the Federal Charges. The DOJ should allow this case to proceed solely under New York State jurisdiction, where the alleged conduct occurred and where the charges better reflect the facts.
  2. A Congressional Investigation.The House and Senate Judiciary Committees must investigate the DOJ’s decision to pursue federal charges, including:Reviewing whether undue influence from the insurance industry played a role.Evaluating the misuse of federal stalking statutes in this case.
  3. Transparency from the DOJ. The DOJ must explain its decision-making process and ensure its actions are free from external pressures or private interests.

Why Now Is the Time to Act
This case sets a dangerous precedent for federal overreach, misuse of laws, and corporate influence in the justice system. If we don't act now:

  • Federal prosecutors may continue stretching laws like the stalking statute, diluting their purpose.
  • Corporations could gain more power to influence prosecutions for private interests.
  • Dual prosecution tactics will erode defendants’ rights and trust in justice.
  • Immediate action can stop these abuses, ensure fair prosecution, and protect the integrity of our justice system. 


Sign the petition and demand accountability now—before it’s too late.
This case sets a dangerous precedent for federal overreach and corporate influence in criminal prosecutions. Sign this petition to demand fair justice in the Luigi Mangione case. Together, we can send a clear message: Justice must be impartial, independent, and free from abuse of power.

 
Call to Action
Share this petition: Help us spread the word by sharing this petition with your friends, family, and social networks. Together, we can demand accountability and protect the integrity of our justice system.

 
 

Support now

541


The Decision Makers

Damian Williams
Damian Williams
U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of New York (SDNY)

Supporter Voices

Petition updates