

Support Phone-Free SVVSD Schools -- But Allow Smartwatches in "School Mode" for PK-8
The Issue
We support phone-free schools. We ask St. Vrain Valley Schools to let PK-8 students wear a parent-managed smartwatch in School Mode and use it only to check the time.
Updated: November 20, 2026
Many of us chose a watch so we could wait to give our children a phone. If a child misses the bus after dismissal, the watch on their wrist lets them call home. During class, that same child should be able to glance at the time, put their hand down and get back to work. Calls, messages, games, browsing and recording would stay off-limits from the first bell through dismissal, including lunch and recess.
St. Vrain’s August 12 regulation now requires PK-8 students to silence or power off personal devices and store them out of sight. It specifically says devices cannot be worn. That means a student must take off even a watch already set for school. Read the district regulation (PDF).
Our children wore restricted watches for four school years without a reported watch-related disruption or disciplinary issue. In March 2026, their school confirmed they could keep wearing them to tell time. Nearby Weld RE-4 already allows silent watches for timekeeping at every grade level. Read Weld RE-4’s rule.
What we are asking the Board to approve
Parents would set and maintain the restrictions and sign an agreement with their child. Teachers could act on an observed or reported violation and direct the student to put the watch away. A student who texts, records or leaves School Mode without authorization could lose the privilege, even if the class stays quiet. Teachers would have no daily settings checks, and families would continue to call the office during the school day.
Please amend district regulation JS*-R to allow restricted wear. If the district wants local evidence first, we ask for a voluntary pilot of 60 to 90 school days at one or more elementary schools. Track violations, interruptions and staff time, ask teachers and families what worked, and report the results. Staff could stop the pilot if it interferes with learning.
Where things stand on November 20, 2026
As of November 20th, 205 people have signed this petition. On October 30, Superintendent Dr. Jackie Kapushion confirmed that the district did not actually ask parents about smartwatches separately before adoption or separately evaluate parent-managed restricted wear. She cited possible misuse and staff workload and declined further assessment or a pilot.
On November 17, we asked for a place on the Board’s agenda by January 27 for a ten-minute parent presentation followed by Board questions. On November 18, Board President Jocelyn Gilligan replied, “The Board supports this decision and will not be discussing this topic any further.” She declined the agenda request and invited families to speak during public comment. The district lists the regular meeting for Wednesday, January 27, 2027, at 6:00 p.m. January 27 regular meeting.
We are now also seeking the records behind those decisions and have filed our 2nd CORA request. The district produced additional text messages in November under our September 3 public-records request. Six follow-up items remained open in our November 20 letter. That day we filed a second request about the district’s experience since the August 12 change, including what families and schools reported and how the pilot and agenda decisions were made. The FAQ below explains both requests.
Please sign and share this petition. If you write to the Board, tell them what the rule looks like in your family or classroom and what you would want a pilot to measure. You can reach the Board at boardofeducation@svvsd.org and the superintendent at kapushion_jackie@svvsd.org. Earlier policy correspondence (PDF) · Boulder Daily Camera coverage.
Frequently asked questions
Q1. May my child wear a watch in School Mode in St. Vrain today?
Under the current PK-8 rule, the watch must be silenced or powered off and stored out of sight through dismissal. The regulation provides for documented medical or educational needs in an IEP, Section 504 plan or health plan, and for emergencies with staff approval. Families should follow their child’s plan and the current rule. Read the district regulation (PDF).
Q2. What would qualify a watch? Could a student use it at lunch or recess?
A parent would schedule Schooltime or an equivalent restricted mode for the whole school day. The watch would stay silent, with ordinary notifications and app access disabled. Checking the time would be the only routine use, including at lunch and recess. A silent watch that still lets a student play games or read texts would not qualify. The same standard would apply to every brand.
Q3. Who checks the settings? What happens if a child bypasses them?
Parents would confirm the settings each year, maintain them and review available exit history if there is an incident. Staff could act on observed or reported misuse, require immediate storage and suspend the individual student’s wearing privilege. Leaving restricted mode without authorization would itself violate the agreement. Teachers would not need family passwords, daily inspections or proof that a lesson had already been interrupted.
Q4. Can a child exit Apple Schooltime?
Yes. A child can temporarily exit Schooltime. On a family-managed Apple Watch, the parent can see when that happened and for how long. Apple also allows certain emergency communications. This is why the proposal includes a conduct rule alongside the settings. Apple’s Schooltime guide · Apple’s family-watch FAQ.
Q5. Why keep the watch on if a wall clock, ordinary watch or backpack is available?
A clock tells time in class. The reason many families chose a connected watch is what happens on the way home. A child who misses a bus or finds no one at pickup can call without already owning a phone. A watch left in a cubby, clipped to a bag or packed in a locker can still be there when the child needs it. An AirTag can help locate a bag, but a child cannot use it to explain a changed plan. Apple’s AirTag description.
Q6. What about calls from parents, emergencies and lockdowns?
Families should call the school office during the day. In an emergency, students follow staff directions and district procedures. Our request is about everyday travel and dismissal. The watch would give families an option when school is over, while preserving the school’s communication and safety procedures during the day.
Q7. Could a teacher require removal for testing?
Yes. Students would power off and store watches whenever testing rules or staff directions require it, including during CMAS testing. The same applies when staff identify a specific educational or safety reason for storage. Colorado testing guidance (PDF).
Q8. Have St. Vrain schools allowed restricted watches before?
Yes. Before the August 2026 change, Black Rock Elementary asked families to put watches in school mode. Centennial Elementary allowed students to wear watches while prohibiting texting, calls and games. Earlier Frederick High guidance in the records also directed teachers to address a distracting watch individually. The August regulation now governs. Black Rock’s September 2025 newsletter · Centennial’s February 2026 newsletter.
Q9. How do other districts handle smartwatches?
Nearby Weld RE-4 allows students at all levels to wear a silent watch to tell time and treats other functions as a device violation. Other districts publish variations of that rule. Each example has its own grade limits and conditions. Weld RE-4 policy.
- Texas. Grapevine-Colleyville ISD permits a watch for checking the time and confiscates it if a student uses it to communicate. Grapevine-Colleyville guidance.
- Minnesota. School District 197 makes an elementary-school exception for smartwatches, prohibits calls and texts, and points parents to Apple Schooltime. District 197 elementary procedures.
- Idaho. Pocatello-Chubbuck allows watches powered off or in school mode in elementary and high schools. Middle schools prohibit them. Pocatello-Chubbuck guidance.
- Utah. West Weber Elementary tells families that students may wear a smartwatch but may not use its apps during restricted hours. West Weber Elementary guidance.
Q10. What does the new Harvard study tell us?
Harvard’s Center for Education Policy Research studied about 3.3 million students at 4,600 schools. It found modest gains in math and reading growth where schools used lockable phone pouches, roughly equivalent to one to two additional weeks of instruction per year. That supports the phone-free goal we share. It did not compare students wearing watches in restricted mode with students required to store them. Read the Harvard report.
Q11. What does the American Academy of Pediatrics say about watches?
The AAP recognizes that notifications and messages from parents can distract students. It recommends following school rules, routing urgent messages through the office, muting notifications and restricting games and media. It gives Apple Schooltime as an example and describes the limited research on smartwatch distraction in K-12 classrooms. Read the AAP guidance.
Q12. What input did the district get from parents?
SVVSD says families gave feedback about phones at community meetings, advisory councils and Leadership St. Vrain. The superintendent subsequently said parents were not asked separately about smartwatches before adoption. After adoption, she reported that four town halls and a Leadership St. Vrain meeting produced no smartwatch concerns, and that two parents wrote in support of the policy after newspaper coverage. In the records we reviewed, we found administrator input and staff accounts of parent views on phones, but no documented pre-adoption survey asking families about removing a restricted watch. District announcement · Earlier policy correspondence (PDF).
Q13. What is still outstanding under public-records Request #1?
Our September 3 Colorado Open Records Act (CORA) request asked what informed the August decision. The district supplied documents and, on November 2 and 6, text messages. The November 6 production centered on a high-school principals’ conversation. Our November 12 letter identified seven occasions when the district had described its response or production as complete.
Our November 8 and 12 letters had received no item-by-item reply when we followed up on November 20. Six items were outstanding. They cover which administrators searched their phones, whether the district searched those administrators’ Google Chats, the scope of the searches, who participated in the produced exchanges, readable and complete copies, and the identity of a recovered school document. We asked counsel to tell us by November 23 when to expect item-by-item answers and any remaining records. Records and correspondence folder (request access).
Q14. What does public-records Request #2 cover?
We filed it on November 20 for records from August 12 through November 20. We asked for feedback supporting or questioning the rule, schools’ experience with enforcement and staff workload, and the records behind decisions on a pilot and a Board discussion. The request covers email, district-business texts and chats, as well as existing aggregate or de-identified incident reports. We asked the district for a response by November 25.
Q15. Why pursue a pilot if the district says the policy works?
The district points to consistency, the ability to exit School Mode and the burden on staff. A volunteer pilot could test those concerns at one or more elementary schools. Agree on the rules and stopping criteria in advance, record misuse and staff time, and hear directly from teachers. We have not found local incident data in the records reviewed that isolate watches operating in restricted mode. The superintendent declined a pilot on October 30, and the Board president backed that decision on November 18.
Q16. Does Colorado law require students to take off every smartwatch?
Colorado’s HB25-1135 includes watches capable of communication and calls for local policies, with an exemption for districts that adopted and implemented a qualifying policy by August 31, 2025. The law does not prescribe a statewide wrist-removal rule. St. Vrain adopted its own storage requirement. Read Colorado HB25-1135 (PDF).
Q17. What about cost, privacy and independence?
Participation would be optional. A family could choose an ordinary watch, a qualifying connected watch or no watch. Students would have the same access to instruction in every case. Families would decide whether to use location sharing. Schools would not need access to a child’s location or private messages. Children should still learn their routes, backup plans and how to ask a trusted adult for help.
Q18. Does this change the rules for phones or school-issued iPads?
We support keeping personal phones put away from bell to bell. Teachers and the district decide how school-issued devices are used for instruction. This request concerns only wearing a qualifying personal watch and checking the time. Earlier community petition for phone-free schools.
Q19. What about radiofrequency exposure?
The CDC explains that most wearable devices use low-powered radio transmitters and that devices sold in the United States must meet federal exposure limits. Families can consider that information when choosing whether to use a watch. CDC guidance on wearable devices.
Q20. Can families still speak to the Board?
Yes. President Gilligan invited non-agenda public comment. The regular meeting is listed for Wednesday, January 27, 2027, at 6:00 p.m. in Longmont. Each speaker may have up to three minutes, with up to 30 minutes total for non-agenda comments. Advance sign-up is encouraged and speaking slots are limited. Families can also send the Board a short account of their own experience. January 27 regular meeting · Public-comment rules and sign-up · Board member directory.

205
The Issue
We support phone-free schools. We ask St. Vrain Valley Schools to let PK-8 students wear a parent-managed smartwatch in School Mode and use it only to check the time.
Updated: November 20, 2026
Many of us chose a watch so we could wait to give our children a phone. If a child misses the bus after dismissal, the watch on their wrist lets them call home. During class, that same child should be able to glance at the time, put their hand down and get back to work. Calls, messages, games, browsing and recording would stay off-limits from the first bell through dismissal, including lunch and recess.
St. Vrain’s August 12 regulation now requires PK-8 students to silence or power off personal devices and store them out of sight. It specifically says devices cannot be worn. That means a student must take off even a watch already set for school. Read the district regulation (PDF).
Our children wore restricted watches for four school years without a reported watch-related disruption or disciplinary issue. In March 2026, their school confirmed they could keep wearing them to tell time. Nearby Weld RE-4 already allows silent watches for timekeeping at every grade level. Read Weld RE-4’s rule.
What we are asking the Board to approve
Parents would set and maintain the restrictions and sign an agreement with their child. Teachers could act on an observed or reported violation and direct the student to put the watch away. A student who texts, records or leaves School Mode without authorization could lose the privilege, even if the class stays quiet. Teachers would have no daily settings checks, and families would continue to call the office during the school day.
Please amend district regulation JS*-R to allow restricted wear. If the district wants local evidence first, we ask for a voluntary pilot of 60 to 90 school days at one or more elementary schools. Track violations, interruptions and staff time, ask teachers and families what worked, and report the results. Staff could stop the pilot if it interferes with learning.
Where things stand on November 20, 2026
As of November 20th, 205 people have signed this petition. On October 30, Superintendent Dr. Jackie Kapushion confirmed that the district did not actually ask parents about smartwatches separately before adoption or separately evaluate parent-managed restricted wear. She cited possible misuse and staff workload and declined further assessment or a pilot.
On November 17, we asked for a place on the Board’s agenda by January 27 for a ten-minute parent presentation followed by Board questions. On November 18, Board President Jocelyn Gilligan replied, “The Board supports this decision and will not be discussing this topic any further.” She declined the agenda request and invited families to speak during public comment. The district lists the regular meeting for Wednesday, January 27, 2027, at 6:00 p.m. January 27 regular meeting.
We are now also seeking the records behind those decisions and have filed our 2nd CORA request. The district produced additional text messages in November under our September 3 public-records request. Six follow-up items remained open in our November 20 letter. That day we filed a second request about the district’s experience since the August 12 change, including what families and schools reported and how the pilot and agenda decisions were made. The FAQ below explains both requests.
Please sign and share this petition. If you write to the Board, tell them what the rule looks like in your family or classroom and what you would want a pilot to measure. You can reach the Board at boardofeducation@svvsd.org and the superintendent at kapushion_jackie@svvsd.org. Earlier policy correspondence (PDF) · Boulder Daily Camera coverage.
Frequently asked questions
Q1. May my child wear a watch in School Mode in St. Vrain today?
Under the current PK-8 rule, the watch must be silenced or powered off and stored out of sight through dismissal. The regulation provides for documented medical or educational needs in an IEP, Section 504 plan or health plan, and for emergencies with staff approval. Families should follow their child’s plan and the current rule. Read the district regulation (PDF).
Q2. What would qualify a watch? Could a student use it at lunch or recess?
A parent would schedule Schooltime or an equivalent restricted mode for the whole school day. The watch would stay silent, with ordinary notifications and app access disabled. Checking the time would be the only routine use, including at lunch and recess. A silent watch that still lets a student play games or read texts would not qualify. The same standard would apply to every brand.
Q3. Who checks the settings? What happens if a child bypasses them?
Parents would confirm the settings each year, maintain them and review available exit history if there is an incident. Staff could act on observed or reported misuse, require immediate storage and suspend the individual student’s wearing privilege. Leaving restricted mode without authorization would itself violate the agreement. Teachers would not need family passwords, daily inspections or proof that a lesson had already been interrupted.
Q4. Can a child exit Apple Schooltime?
Yes. A child can temporarily exit Schooltime. On a family-managed Apple Watch, the parent can see when that happened and for how long. Apple also allows certain emergency communications. This is why the proposal includes a conduct rule alongside the settings. Apple’s Schooltime guide · Apple’s family-watch FAQ.
Q5. Why keep the watch on if a wall clock, ordinary watch or backpack is available?
A clock tells time in class. The reason many families chose a connected watch is what happens on the way home. A child who misses a bus or finds no one at pickup can call without already owning a phone. A watch left in a cubby, clipped to a bag or packed in a locker can still be there when the child needs it. An AirTag can help locate a bag, but a child cannot use it to explain a changed plan. Apple’s AirTag description.
Q6. What about calls from parents, emergencies and lockdowns?
Families should call the school office during the day. In an emergency, students follow staff directions and district procedures. Our request is about everyday travel and dismissal. The watch would give families an option when school is over, while preserving the school’s communication and safety procedures during the day.
Q7. Could a teacher require removal for testing?
Yes. Students would power off and store watches whenever testing rules or staff directions require it, including during CMAS testing. The same applies when staff identify a specific educational or safety reason for storage. Colorado testing guidance (PDF).
Q8. Have St. Vrain schools allowed restricted watches before?
Yes. Before the August 2026 change, Black Rock Elementary asked families to put watches in school mode. Centennial Elementary allowed students to wear watches while prohibiting texting, calls and games. Earlier Frederick High guidance in the records also directed teachers to address a distracting watch individually. The August regulation now governs. Black Rock’s September 2025 newsletter · Centennial’s February 2026 newsletter.
Q9. How do other districts handle smartwatches?
Nearby Weld RE-4 allows students at all levels to wear a silent watch to tell time and treats other functions as a device violation. Other districts publish variations of that rule. Each example has its own grade limits and conditions. Weld RE-4 policy.
- Texas. Grapevine-Colleyville ISD permits a watch for checking the time and confiscates it if a student uses it to communicate. Grapevine-Colleyville guidance.
- Minnesota. School District 197 makes an elementary-school exception for smartwatches, prohibits calls and texts, and points parents to Apple Schooltime. District 197 elementary procedures.
- Idaho. Pocatello-Chubbuck allows watches powered off or in school mode in elementary and high schools. Middle schools prohibit them. Pocatello-Chubbuck guidance.
- Utah. West Weber Elementary tells families that students may wear a smartwatch but may not use its apps during restricted hours. West Weber Elementary guidance.
Q10. What does the new Harvard study tell us?
Harvard’s Center for Education Policy Research studied about 3.3 million students at 4,600 schools. It found modest gains in math and reading growth where schools used lockable phone pouches, roughly equivalent to one to two additional weeks of instruction per year. That supports the phone-free goal we share. It did not compare students wearing watches in restricted mode with students required to store them. Read the Harvard report.
Q11. What does the American Academy of Pediatrics say about watches?
The AAP recognizes that notifications and messages from parents can distract students. It recommends following school rules, routing urgent messages through the office, muting notifications and restricting games and media. It gives Apple Schooltime as an example and describes the limited research on smartwatch distraction in K-12 classrooms. Read the AAP guidance.
Q12. What input did the district get from parents?
SVVSD says families gave feedback about phones at community meetings, advisory councils and Leadership St. Vrain. The superintendent subsequently said parents were not asked separately about smartwatches before adoption. After adoption, she reported that four town halls and a Leadership St. Vrain meeting produced no smartwatch concerns, and that two parents wrote in support of the policy after newspaper coverage. In the records we reviewed, we found administrator input and staff accounts of parent views on phones, but no documented pre-adoption survey asking families about removing a restricted watch. District announcement · Earlier policy correspondence (PDF).
Q13. What is still outstanding under public-records Request #1?
Our September 3 Colorado Open Records Act (CORA) request asked what informed the August decision. The district supplied documents and, on November 2 and 6, text messages. The November 6 production centered on a high-school principals’ conversation. Our November 12 letter identified seven occasions when the district had described its response or production as complete.
Our November 8 and 12 letters had received no item-by-item reply when we followed up on November 20. Six items were outstanding. They cover which administrators searched their phones, whether the district searched those administrators’ Google Chats, the scope of the searches, who participated in the produced exchanges, readable and complete copies, and the identity of a recovered school document. We asked counsel to tell us by November 23 when to expect item-by-item answers and any remaining records. Records and correspondence folder (request access).
Q14. What does public-records Request #2 cover?
We filed it on November 20 for records from August 12 through November 20. We asked for feedback supporting or questioning the rule, schools’ experience with enforcement and staff workload, and the records behind decisions on a pilot and a Board discussion. The request covers email, district-business texts and chats, as well as existing aggregate or de-identified incident reports. We asked the district for a response by November 25.
Q15. Why pursue a pilot if the district says the policy works?
The district points to consistency, the ability to exit School Mode and the burden on staff. A volunteer pilot could test those concerns at one or more elementary schools. Agree on the rules and stopping criteria in advance, record misuse and staff time, and hear directly from teachers. We have not found local incident data in the records reviewed that isolate watches operating in restricted mode. The superintendent declined a pilot on October 30, and the Board president backed that decision on November 18.
Q16. Does Colorado law require students to take off every smartwatch?
Colorado’s HB25-1135 includes watches capable of communication and calls for local policies, with an exemption for districts that adopted and implemented a qualifying policy by August 31, 2025. The law does not prescribe a statewide wrist-removal rule. St. Vrain adopted its own storage requirement. Read Colorado HB25-1135 (PDF).
Q17. What about cost, privacy and independence?
Participation would be optional. A family could choose an ordinary watch, a qualifying connected watch or no watch. Students would have the same access to instruction in every case. Families would decide whether to use location sharing. Schools would not need access to a child’s location or private messages. Children should still learn their routes, backup plans and how to ask a trusted adult for help.
Q18. Does this change the rules for phones or school-issued iPads?
We support keeping personal phones put away from bell to bell. Teachers and the district decide how school-issued devices are used for instruction. This request concerns only wearing a qualifying personal watch and checking the time. Earlier community petition for phone-free schools.
Q19. What about radiofrequency exposure?
The CDC explains that most wearable devices use low-powered radio transmitters and that devices sold in the United States must meet federal exposure limits. Families can consider that information when choosing whether to use a watch. CDC guidance on wearable devices.
Q20. Can families still speak to the Board?
Yes. President Gilligan invited non-agenda public comment. The regular meeting is listed for Wednesday, January 27, 2027, at 6:00 p.m. in Longmont. Each speaker may have up to three minutes, with up to 30 minutes total for non-agenda comments. Advance sign-up is encouraged and speaking slots are limited. Families can also send the Board a short account of their own experience. January 27 regular meeting · Public-comment rules and sign-up · Board member directory.

The Decision Makers


Supporter Voices
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on September 10, 2026