Stop the demolition of River Road shopping center in New Milford, NJ

Recent signers:
Yvette Rolon and 19 others have signed recently.

The Issue

In the bustling heart of New Milford, NJ, there's a vibrant shopping center on River Road that has become an integral part of our community. It's more than just a collection of stores; it's a place where relationships are built, where convenience meets necessity, and where the pulse of our town can be felt. As a student at a local school, I've seen firsthand how this center supports families, including my friend whose family restaurant operates here (save Michael and Rebecca!). The thought of this vital hub being demolished to make way for yet another apartment complex is deeply unsettling for many of us. 

The current plan to dismantle this center impacts not just the businesses but the fabric of our community life. These aren't just stores; they are places that offer jobs to locals, provide much-needed services, and foster a sense of belonging. Eliminating them risks eroding our community's culture and economy. Families, including my classmate's, face uncertainty about their livelihood if this project proceeds.

Statistically, increasing residential spaces without equivalent commercial and recreational opportunities can lead to congestion, strain on local services, and loss of community spirit. According to Urban Planning Experts, balanced development is key to preserving the character of neighborhoods and supporting sustainable growth.

Our call to action is clear: let’s urge the local authorities to reconsider this development plan. By signing this petition, we are advocating for a plan that prioritizes the needs of the current community over unnecessary expansion. Let’s support our local businesses and keep the heart of New Milford intact.

Sign this petition to preserve our community’s vibrancy and to support the many families who depend on the River Road shopping center for their livelihood. Together, we can make a difference.

2,856

Recent signers:
Yvette Rolon and 19 others have signed recently.

The Issue

In the bustling heart of New Milford, NJ, there's a vibrant shopping center on River Road that has become an integral part of our community. It's more than just a collection of stores; it's a place where relationships are built, where convenience meets necessity, and where the pulse of our town can be felt. As a student at a local school, I've seen firsthand how this center supports families, including my friend whose family restaurant operates here (save Michael and Rebecca!). The thought of this vital hub being demolished to make way for yet another apartment complex is deeply unsettling for many of us. 

The current plan to dismantle this center impacts not just the businesses but the fabric of our community life. These aren't just stores; they are places that offer jobs to locals, provide much-needed services, and foster a sense of belonging. Eliminating them risks eroding our community's culture and economy. Families, including my classmate's, face uncertainty about their livelihood if this project proceeds.

Statistically, increasing residential spaces without equivalent commercial and recreational opportunities can lead to congestion, strain on local services, and loss of community spirit. According to Urban Planning Experts, balanced development is key to preserving the character of neighborhoods and supporting sustainable growth.

Our call to action is clear: let’s urge the local authorities to reconsider this development plan. By signing this petition, we are advocating for a plan that prioritizes the needs of the current community over unnecessary expansion. Let’s support our local businesses and keep the heart of New Milford intact.

Sign this petition to preserve our community’s vibrancy and to support the many families who depend on the River Road shopping center for their livelihood. Together, we can make a difference.

The Decision Makers

Michael Putrino
New Milford Borough Mayor
Responded
Thank you for reaching out. The petition was initiated by an eighth-grade student at David E. Owens Middle School here in New Milford. She contacted me last evening to ensure I was aware of it and to share her motivation. One of her classmates’ family owns a restaurant in the shopping center, and she was concerned about their livelihood if the property were to be redeveloped. I was genuinely moved by her compassion for her fellow students and civic awareness, and I commended her for her advocacy of our community and willingness to make her voice heard. Due to the Borough’s current and potential involvement in litigation with the Brunetti Organization, I am unable to comment specifically on the proposed redevelopment of the Brookchester Shopping Center currently. However, I can affirm that the governing body, along with our residents, remains opposed to overdevelopment that places undue strain on our infrastructure, school district, and emergency services, while significantly altering the character of our community. The governing body has worked diligently to ensure that New Milford has met its state mandated obligations under Rounds 1 through 3, thereby limiting exposure to “builder’s remedy” lawsuits. Round 4 began in 2025 and will continue through 2035. Today, New Milford’s state-mandated affordable housing obligation is 368 units. This consists of 258 affordable units of unmet need from Round 3 and an additional 110 affordable units allocated for Round 4. While we have complied with the law, we have also consistently voiced our concerns with both the statutory framework and the formulas used to determine these obligations. We have supported legislative efforts, defended our Housing Element and Fair Share Plan (HEFSP), challenged the Affordable Housing Dispute and Resolution Program, the Fair Share Housing Center, and participated in independent and joint legal actions to seek relief. Although those efforts have resulted in setbacks at both the state and federal levels, we will continue to pursue all available avenues to protect the residents of New Milford. For additional information regarding New Milford’s affordable housing obligations please visit: https://www.newmilfordnj.gov/page/affordable-housing Thank you. Michael J. Putrino Mayor Borough of New Milford, NJ
James Tedesco
Bergen County Executive
Ira Grotsky
New Milford Borough Council

Supporter Voices

Petition updates