We, the undersigned, respectfully request that the National Football League and its Office of Officiating conduct a transparent review of the interception call made by referee Carl Cheffers during the Buffalo Bills and Denver Broncos game on January 17, 2026 during the AFC Divisional. The call had a material impact on the game and raised questions about the application of the rule in that situation. The controversy centered on a crucial overtime play in the Bills–Broncos 2026 AFC Divisional playoff game, when referee Carl Cheffers and his crew ruled that a deep pass to Brandin Cooks was not a catch, but instead an interception by Denver’s Ja’Quan McMillian. That ruling flipped possession and helped set up Denver’s game‑winning drive. 

Josh Allen threw a deep ball to Brandin Cooks. Cooks appeared to secure the ball in the air, came down with it, and then hit the ground while McMillian was also making a play on it. As they went to the turf, McMillian ripped the ball away.

Cooks had clear possession first, and the defender only took it away after Cooks hit the ground. ask for the following:

1. A public explanation of the rule(s) applied and the rationale for the call, including any relevant replay review footage or official statement.
2. A formal review to determine whether the call was consistent with NFL rules and officiating protocols.
3. Clearer guidance for officials and fans on how similar plays will be interpreted going forward.
4. If errors are found, appropriate corrective measures such as updated training, clarification of replay procedures, or other steps to reduce recurrence.

We make this request in the spirit of fair play and transparency. Our goal is not to attack any individual but to ensure consistent, well‑explained officiating that preserves the integrity of the game.