Revoke Mary Kay Cabot and Tony Grossi's access to cover the Cleveland Browns
The Issue
For many ardent Cleveland Browns fans, the local sports media plays an integral role in shaping our perceptions and understanding of the team we love. Yet the coverage by Mary Kay Cabot and Tony Grossi has repeatedly left fans feeling frustrated, misrepresented, and exhausted by a pattern of inaccuracies, bias, and sensationalism. This reporting does a disservice to Cleveland’s dedicated fan base and harms the reputation of our Browns. It is time for it to stop.
Cabot and Grossi have, for years, delivered coverage that many in the community find dismissively negative and cynically inclined. Reports too often lack depth, overlook genuine team efforts, and elevate gossip or drama over substantive sporting news. The focus appears fixed on creating conflict rather than fairly examining the team’s performance, achievements, and potential.
This pattern extends beyond general negativity into clear instances of unfair bias directed at specific players—targeted jabs and narratives that persist even when available evidence, on-field results, and team statements refute them. Everyone can see it. These two reporters appear determined to remain in their own land of delusion, and that privilege must end.
Consider the treatment of Shedeur Sanders. Cabot publicly reported that Deshaun Watson had taken the lead and possessed the “inside track” to the starting job, then argued the Browns should declare Watson QB1 immediately so the first-team offense could “start to cook.” This framing drew direct pushback from Sanders’ brother Shilo, who accused Cabot of a consistent “hateful agenda,” of offering opinions that always ran negative toward Shedeur rather than sticking to facts, and of prioritizing emotion over accurate reporting. Tony Grossi faced a similar confrontation from Shedeur himself after a preseason game, with the young quarterback calling out the reporter for only saying negative things about him and noting he had “never seen you say anything positive.” Grossi’s prior radio commentary and framing of the quarterback competition had already drawn accusations of condescension and predetermined narratives that downplayed Sanders’ progress.
The selective praise is equally revealing. Cabot repeatedly highlighted Dillon Gabriel’s “computer-like brain” and “computer-like processing speed,” describing it as his superpower, extraordinary cognitive ability, and high football aptitude that supposedly set him apart. The Browns organization was said to be captivated by it. In reality, Gabriel’s 2025 performance as a third-round pick who received significant opportunities was underwhelming at best: six starts, a 1-5 record, 937 passing yards, seven touchdowns, two interceptions, and a dismal 5.1 yards per attempt. He did nothing on the field that warranted such elevated, almost hyperbolic praise. The “computer” narrative did not translate into production or wins, yet the glowing characterization stood in stark contrast to the more skeptical or limited framing often applied to other young quarterbacks.
Meanwhile, even as Watson has delivered terrible throws, struggled in practices, and missed substantial portions of multiple seasons due to serious injuries (shoulder issues, Achilles tears, and extended absences), the coverage has continued to emphasize his work ethic, physical condition, sharpness, and potential. Praise for Watson persists despite the evidence of limited availability and inconsistent results, while Shedeur Sanders—who closed strong in limited opportunities and has shown the traits of a clear front-runner in the eyes of many fans and observers—receives comparatively restrained or critical treatment. The double standard is obvious to those watching the same practices, games, and results.
These are not isolated moments. Grossi’s history includes a well-documented, frosty relationship with Baker Mayfield—including incorrect comparisons to Johnny Manziel before the 2018 draft and a hot-mic incident in which he referred to Mayfield with a derogatory slur, resulting in suspension. Fans have long noted a tendency to press certain players with loaded questions or sustain critical storylines long after results or context have shifted. When evidence of improvement, competitive performances, or organizational statements contradicts the preferred narrative of perpetual shortcomings—or when over-the-top praise is heaped on players who fail to deliver—the pattern continues. The result is coverage that feels personal and selective rather than professional, eroding trust among the fan base that sees the same practices and the same evidence.
Statistics and common sense both show that persistent negative or uneven media portrayal can damage a team’s public image and affect morale. The Browns are working toward positive change, visible in recent performances and organizational direction. They deserve fair representation that mirrors their efforts and successes—not coverage locked into outdated cynicism, evidence-resistant praise, or targeted skepticism. Fans deserve reporting that is balanced, accurate, and willing to update when the facts on the field demand it.
We believe it is time for a fresh perspective from reporters committed to journalistic integrity, fair analysis, and enriching the fan experience. By removing Mary Kay Cabot and Tony Grossi’s privileges to cover the team, we open the door to new voices capable of constructive insight rather than sustained, evidence-resistant bias. The pattern of targeted criticism against certain players, inflated praise for others that the results completely refute, and refusal to acknowledge the clear front-runner status of Shedeur Sanders has gone on long enough. Living in that delusion while shaping the narrative for an entire market cannot continue.
Join us in urging the news outlets and press organizations responsible for covering the Cleveland Browns to revoke the access of Mary Kay Cabot and Tony Grossi. Seek journalists who respect the legacy and aspirations of the team and who report what is actually happening rather than what fits a preconceived storyline. Sign this petition to demand change and ensure Browns fans receive media coverage that truly reflects the spirit, resilience, and reality of Cleveland’s football community.
85
The Issue
For many ardent Cleveland Browns fans, the local sports media plays an integral role in shaping our perceptions and understanding of the team we love. Yet the coverage by Mary Kay Cabot and Tony Grossi has repeatedly left fans feeling frustrated, misrepresented, and exhausted by a pattern of inaccuracies, bias, and sensationalism. This reporting does a disservice to Cleveland’s dedicated fan base and harms the reputation of our Browns. It is time for it to stop.
Cabot and Grossi have, for years, delivered coverage that many in the community find dismissively negative and cynically inclined. Reports too often lack depth, overlook genuine team efforts, and elevate gossip or drama over substantive sporting news. The focus appears fixed on creating conflict rather than fairly examining the team’s performance, achievements, and potential.
This pattern extends beyond general negativity into clear instances of unfair bias directed at specific players—targeted jabs and narratives that persist even when available evidence, on-field results, and team statements refute them. Everyone can see it. These two reporters appear determined to remain in their own land of delusion, and that privilege must end.
Consider the treatment of Shedeur Sanders. Cabot publicly reported that Deshaun Watson had taken the lead and possessed the “inside track” to the starting job, then argued the Browns should declare Watson QB1 immediately so the first-team offense could “start to cook.” This framing drew direct pushback from Sanders’ brother Shilo, who accused Cabot of a consistent “hateful agenda,” of offering opinions that always ran negative toward Shedeur rather than sticking to facts, and of prioritizing emotion over accurate reporting. Tony Grossi faced a similar confrontation from Shedeur himself after a preseason game, with the young quarterback calling out the reporter for only saying negative things about him and noting he had “never seen you say anything positive.” Grossi’s prior radio commentary and framing of the quarterback competition had already drawn accusations of condescension and predetermined narratives that downplayed Sanders’ progress.
The selective praise is equally revealing. Cabot repeatedly highlighted Dillon Gabriel’s “computer-like brain” and “computer-like processing speed,” describing it as his superpower, extraordinary cognitive ability, and high football aptitude that supposedly set him apart. The Browns organization was said to be captivated by it. In reality, Gabriel’s 2025 performance as a third-round pick who received significant opportunities was underwhelming at best: six starts, a 1-5 record, 937 passing yards, seven touchdowns, two interceptions, and a dismal 5.1 yards per attempt. He did nothing on the field that warranted such elevated, almost hyperbolic praise. The “computer” narrative did not translate into production or wins, yet the glowing characterization stood in stark contrast to the more skeptical or limited framing often applied to other young quarterbacks.
Meanwhile, even as Watson has delivered terrible throws, struggled in practices, and missed substantial portions of multiple seasons due to serious injuries (shoulder issues, Achilles tears, and extended absences), the coverage has continued to emphasize his work ethic, physical condition, sharpness, and potential. Praise for Watson persists despite the evidence of limited availability and inconsistent results, while Shedeur Sanders—who closed strong in limited opportunities and has shown the traits of a clear front-runner in the eyes of many fans and observers—receives comparatively restrained or critical treatment. The double standard is obvious to those watching the same practices, games, and results.
These are not isolated moments. Grossi’s history includes a well-documented, frosty relationship with Baker Mayfield—including incorrect comparisons to Johnny Manziel before the 2018 draft and a hot-mic incident in which he referred to Mayfield with a derogatory slur, resulting in suspension. Fans have long noted a tendency to press certain players with loaded questions or sustain critical storylines long after results or context have shifted. When evidence of improvement, competitive performances, or organizational statements contradicts the preferred narrative of perpetual shortcomings—or when over-the-top praise is heaped on players who fail to deliver—the pattern continues. The result is coverage that feels personal and selective rather than professional, eroding trust among the fan base that sees the same practices and the same evidence.
Statistics and common sense both show that persistent negative or uneven media portrayal can damage a team’s public image and affect morale. The Browns are working toward positive change, visible in recent performances and organizational direction. They deserve fair representation that mirrors their efforts and successes—not coverage locked into outdated cynicism, evidence-resistant praise, or targeted skepticism. Fans deserve reporting that is balanced, accurate, and willing to update when the facts on the field demand it.
We believe it is time for a fresh perspective from reporters committed to journalistic integrity, fair analysis, and enriching the fan experience. By removing Mary Kay Cabot and Tony Grossi’s privileges to cover the team, we open the door to new voices capable of constructive insight rather than sustained, evidence-resistant bias. The pattern of targeted criticism against certain players, inflated praise for others that the results completely refute, and refusal to acknowledge the clear front-runner status of Shedeur Sanders has gone on long enough. Living in that delusion while shaping the narrative for an entire market cannot continue.
Join us in urging the news outlets and press organizations responsible for covering the Cleveland Browns to revoke the access of Mary Kay Cabot and Tony Grossi. Seek journalists who respect the legacy and aspirations of the team and who report what is actually happening rather than what fits a preconceived storyline. Sign this petition to demand change and ensure Browns fans receive media coverage that truly reflects the spirit, resilience, and reality of Cleveland’s football community.
Supporter Voices
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on August 3, 2026