Having spent decades in law enforcement, I understand how critical public trust is to the justice system. Justice must not only be done, it must be seen to be done. When a senior judicial figure such as Richard Wagner makes public comments on matters that may later come before the court, it raises legitimate concerns about impartiality.

This is not about attacking an individual. It is about protecting the integrity of the system.

In public remarks regarding the convoy protests connected to the Emergencies Act debate, the Chief Justice described the situation as a “small beginning of anarchy” and said residents were effectively “taken hostage.”

These are strong characterizations. When such views are expressed in advance of legal proceedings, they risk creating a perception that a position has already been formed.

The foundation of our justice system is impartial decision-making, free from preconceived opinions. Where there is a reasonable concern that impartiality could be questioned, recusal is not a weakness, it is a safeguard.

This petition respectfully calls for Chief Justice Wagner to recuse himself from any cases directly connected to matters on which he has made prior public comments.

Taking this step would reinforce, not diminish, public confidence in Canada’s highest court and demonstrate a clear commitment to fairness, neutrality, and the rule of law.

If you believe in preserving the integrity of our justice system, add your name.