Protect Free Speech and Religious Equality in New Jersey-Oppose Assembly Bill A1146

187

Let’s get to 200 signatures!
Petitions with 1,000+ supporters are 5x more likely to win!

The Issue

Protect Free Speech and Religious Equality in New Jersey – Oppose Assembly Bill A1146
No religion should receive preferential treatment from government, and no belief system should be beyond criticism.

We urge New Jersey lawmakers to reject Assembly Bill A1146, which proposes establishing a state definition of Islamophobia for use in certain civil and criminal matters.

Although the bill contains language preserving First Amendment rights, we are concerned about the breadth of its definition and the requirement that public officials and law enforcement consider it when evaluating whether an alleged violation of existing law was motivated by anti-Muslim bias.

Freedom of religion must mean freedom for everyone, equally.

The government should not elevate one religion above another by establishing special definitions or standards that could create the perception that one faith deserves greater protection from criticism than others. Christianity, Judaism, Islam, Hinduism, and every other religion should receive equal treatment under the law.

There must also be a clear distinction between discrimination against people and criticism of their religious beliefs. People should be free to question, criticize, challenge, and debate religious doctrines, institutions, practices, and political ideologies without fear that their opinions will be interpreted as evidence of prejudice or discriminatory intent.

We are also concerned about the unintended social consequences of legislation like A1146. When government appears to single out one religion for special protections, it risks creating resentment and division rather than understanding and tolerance. It can foster the perception that certain beliefs are protected from scrutiny while others remain open to criticism. Rather than reducing prejudice, this perception could actually deepen negative attitudes toward the very communities the legislation is intended to protect.

We believe that hate and intolerance are best confronted through education, open dialogue, and the freedom to challenge offensive ideas with better ideas. The answer to speech we find hateful should be more speech, not broader government involvement in defining which opinions are acceptable.

Threats, violence, harassment, and unlawful discrimination should be addressed under existing laws, regardless of the religion or background of the individuals involved. But criticism, disagreement, and the expression of unpopular opinions should not be confused with unlawful conduct.

New Jersey's Constitution expressly states that no religious sect shall be established in preference to another and protects the freedom to speak and publish one's sentiments on all subjects.

We should uphold those principles consistently.

Our requests to New Jersey lawmakers are:

Reject Assembly Bill A1146.
Ensure that no religion or religious group receives preferential treatment in government policy.
Protect the right of all New Jersey residents to criticize, question, and debate every religion and ideology.
Address genuine discrimination and violence through laws that apply equally to everyone, without discouraging constitutionally protected expression.
Religious tolerance cannot be achieved by limiting open discussion. True tolerance means allowing people to disagree, question, challenge, and debate without government interference.

Protect free speech. Protect religious equality. Protect the right to disagree.

We ask New Jersey lawmakers to reject A1146.

PDFView bill here

The Decision Makers

New Jersey General Assembly
8 Members
Lisa Swain
New Jersey General Assembly - District 38
Erik K. Simonsen
New Jersey General Assembly - District 1
New Jersey General Assembly - District 4
Former State House of Representatives
3 Members
Former State House of Representatives - New Jersey-17B
Former State House of Representatives - New Jersey-18B
Former State House of Representatives - New Jersey-38B
Garwood Borough Council

Petition Updates