Protect Cabrillo Beach: Require a Public Safety Review Before Lifeguard Agency Changes

2,331

The Issue

Petition to Councilmember Tim McOsker, Janice Hahn, Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors and Los Angeles City leaders.

We support all lifeguards and respect the difficult work they do every day.  It is about ensuring that any change to lifeguard operations at Cabrillo Beach maintains or improves public safety. Before long-standing rescue operations are changed, the public deserves to see a transparent safety review, response-time analysis, staffing plan, training standards, and rescue capability assessment.

*LA City Parks & Rec lifeguards are set to takeover outer Cabrillo Beach, San Pedro, California starting in September. Currently LA County Lifeguards, who are known as the best in the world, guard our beaches with an impeccable track record. A major shift for our local beach and public safety. 

Cabrillo Beach is unlike many other beaches. It includes both a protected inner beach and an outer beach with open-ocean conditions, surf, currents, rock jetties, fishermen, windsurfers, boat traffic, and a harbor entrance. These unique conditions require specialized rescue capabilities.


We, the undersigned San Pedro families, residents, swimmers, beachgoers, youth program families, and community members, are asking Los Angeles City leaders to pause any proposed change in lifeguard service at Outer Cabrillo Beach until there is a full public safety review, public hearing, and transparent explanation to the community.

We are deeply concerned about any change that could affect ocean-rescue readiness, emergency response, staffing levels, lifeguard training standards, rescue equipment, coordination with fire/EMS, and the level of protection currently expected by the community.

Our concern is with any service change that has not been fully explained, publicly reviewed, and proven to provide equal or better protection for the public.

Before any lifeguard takeover, contract change, staffing change, or operational change occurs at Outer Cabrillo Beach, we are asking city leaders to provide the community with:

-A written public safety review comparing current and proposed lifeguard service.
-A clear explanation of ocean-rescue qualifications and training standards.
-A staffing plan for busy weekends, summer crowds, junior lifeguard activities, holidays, and emergency conditions.
-A response-time and rescue-equipment comparison.
-Written emergency coordination protocols with fire, EMS, harbor, and county resources.
-A public meeting in San Pedro before any final decision.
-A commitment that any change must provide equal or greater public safety protection.
-San Pedro families deserve transparency. Our kids deserve protection. Our community deserves answers before any decision is made that could affect beach safety.

 

We are asking Councilmember Tim McOsker, LA City Recreation and Parks, and all responsible city leaders to stop any lifeguard service change at Outer Cabrillo Beach until the community receives a full public safety review and a public hearing + a full third party formal risk assessment that public safety will be equal or greater than currently provided for our local community.

Public safety must come before politics, budgets, or administrative convenience.

Sign if you agree:
Keep Outer Cabrillo Beach safe.
Protect our kids.
Protect our families.
Protect San Pedro.

avatar of the starter
Nicole MillerPetition StarterJust a local mom in San Pedro, Los Angeles California. Ensuring our community’s safety is #1 on our councilmembers / board of supervisors agenda. Our community. Our neighborhood. Our kids.

The Decision Makers

Timothy McOsker
Los Angeles City Council - District 15
Responded
For nearly fifty years, the City of LA and LA County were partners through a Joint Powers Agreement to provide lifeguard services at City beaches including Cabrillo Beach. That agreement was straightforward: the County provided lifeguard and beach operations, and the City allowed the County to receive revenue generated from parking lots, concessions, and other beach activities. Since 1975, that partnership worked because both parties recognized that these beaches are regional assets serving residents from across LA County. For the past two years, the LA County Fire Department and its Fire Chief Anthony Marrone demanded that the City begin paying millions of dollars more per year for services that have been provided for five decades under the existing agreement. When the City requested detailed financial information to review the demands, the County's figures changed dramatically, growing from an initial request of approximately $8.7 million to verbal indication that it might be three times that. The City did not agree to those increases. Then, rather than working collaboratively toward a fair solution, the County Fire and the LA County Chief Executive Office issued a notice terminating the Agreement. To be clear: the City did not ask for or initiate this termination. The County Fire Department chose to end a fifty-year partnership after attempting to shift the full burden of these regional lifeguard services onto City taxpayers. When it became clear that the County Fire Department would terminate the agreement, the City immediately began evaluating options to protect beach goers to the best of our ability. Because the City already operates lifeguard services on Cabrillo's Inner Beach, our Department of Recreation and Parks determined it can extend those operations to the Outer Beach. At my request, the City is also evaluating an LA City Fire Department developed and staffed lifeguard program. While the County Fire Department's plan is to withdraw services, the City's priority has always been to ensure there is no interruption in lifeguard protection for the public. As this discussion continues, I urge residents to keep these facts in mind when reading the messaging from the Fire Chief and the County's Chief Executive Office. The City did not terminate this agreement. What we have seen is an effort to pressure the City into accepting fully cost recovery for a regional service that the County Fire Department has decided it no longer wishes to bear. That said, I remain hopeful that a resolution can still be reached. I have spoken with Supervisor Janice Hahn, and we will be meeting with LA County Fire and other City and County offices next week to determine whether we can find a path forward that preserves this longstanding partnership. In the meantime, I want to also thank the dedicated staff at the Department of Recreation and Parks for stepping up and preparing to ensure our beaches remain safe, regardless of outcome. At the same time, I know that the dedicated individuals of Los Angeles County Fire lifeguards want to continue serving these beaches, and my hope is that we can reach a mutually agreeable resolution that keeps our beaches safe.
Janice Hahn
Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors - District 4
Mary Galvan Rosas
Mary Galvan Rosas
Member, LA Board of Recreation and Park Commissioners
Tafarai Bayne
Tafarai Bayne
Vice President, LA Board of Recreation and Park Commissioners
Nicole Chase
Nicole Chase
Member, LA Board of Recreation and Park Commissioners

Supporter Voices

Petition Updates