Pause Middletown Water Billing Until Accurate Usage Data & Transparency Are Provided

Recent signers:
Ashley Burger and 19 others have signed recently.

The Issue

   Residents of Middletown deserve accurate utility bills, full transparency, and fair treatment. After a cybersecurity incident shut down the city's billing system, residents are being charged estimated bills plus 25% extra, without any explanation of how those numbers were calculated or what our true usage actually is.

   We are calling on the City of Middletown to pause all water billing immediately until real meter data is restored and a transparent explanation is provided.

 

To The City of Middletown Administration, City Manager, and City Council:

 

We, the residents of Middletown, Ohio, respectfully request an immediate pause on all water billing until the city can provide:

 

Full transparency about the cybersecurity incident.

  1. What systems failed?
  2. What data was lost or stolen?
  3. How billing information was impacted?
  4. What recovery actions have been taken?

 

Accurate Meter Data.

  1. Residents should not be billed for estimated usage based on last year.
  2. Residents should not be billed an additional 25% to make up for months the city cannot accurately account for.
  3. Residents should not be billed months of flat fee charges all at once.

These practices create undue financial stress and do not reflect actual usage.

 

An itemized breakdown of charges during the outage. We request a clear explanation of:

  1. How estimates are being calculated?
  2. Why 25% was added?
  3. How back billing amounts will be verified?
  4. How credits or adjustments will be handled once real meter data is restored?

 

A temporary freeze on water shutoffs until the city provides accurate billing, no resident should face shutoff or financial penalties for charges that may not be correct.

 

We are calling on the City of Middletown to:

  1. Pause all water billing until accurate readings are available.
  2. Release a public explanation regarding the cybersecurity incident.
  3. Provide clear, itemized breakdowns of all estimated and back-billed charges.
  4. Temporarily suspend water shutoffs.
  5. Hold a public meeting specifically to address resident concerns.

 

Residents Deserve The Truth

We are signing this petition to ensure that Middletown residents are treated fairly and respectfully. Transparent billing is not optional, it is a fundamental responsibility of any public utility.

We Demand Transparency, Accuracy, and Accountability.

Please join us by signing and sharing this petition! 

 

 

 

 

2,502

Recent signers:
Ashley Burger and 19 others have signed recently.

The Issue

   Residents of Middletown deserve accurate utility bills, full transparency, and fair treatment. After a cybersecurity incident shut down the city's billing system, residents are being charged estimated bills plus 25% extra, without any explanation of how those numbers were calculated or what our true usage actually is.

   We are calling on the City of Middletown to pause all water billing immediately until real meter data is restored and a transparent explanation is provided.

 

To The City of Middletown Administration, City Manager, and City Council:

 

We, the residents of Middletown, Ohio, respectfully request an immediate pause on all water billing until the city can provide:

 

Full transparency about the cybersecurity incident.

  1. What systems failed?
  2. What data was lost or stolen?
  3. How billing information was impacted?
  4. What recovery actions have been taken?

 

Accurate Meter Data.

  1. Residents should not be billed for estimated usage based on last year.
  2. Residents should not be billed an additional 25% to make up for months the city cannot accurately account for.
  3. Residents should not be billed months of flat fee charges all at once.

These practices create undue financial stress and do not reflect actual usage.

 

An itemized breakdown of charges during the outage. We request a clear explanation of:

  1. How estimates are being calculated?
  2. Why 25% was added?
  3. How back billing amounts will be verified?
  4. How credits or adjustments will be handled once real meter data is restored?

 

A temporary freeze on water shutoffs until the city provides accurate billing, no resident should face shutoff or financial penalties for charges that may not be correct.

 

We are calling on the City of Middletown to:

  1. Pause all water billing until accurate readings are available.
  2. Release a public explanation regarding the cybersecurity incident.
  3. Provide clear, itemized breakdowns of all estimated and back-billed charges.
  4. Temporarily suspend water shutoffs.
  5. Hold a public meeting specifically to address resident concerns.

 

Residents Deserve The Truth

We are signing this petition to ensure that Middletown residents are treated fairly and respectfully. Transparent billing is not optional, it is a fundamental responsibility of any public utility.

We Demand Transparency, Accuracy, and Accountability.

Please join us by signing and sharing this petition! 

 

 

 

 

The Decision Makers

Elizabeth Slamka
Middletown City Mayor
Responded
Speaking as Mayor and for myself: First, this has been –to say the least—frustrating for our residents. I thank our residents for their engagement. Good communication is so important and is often so tricky for humans to get right. What I very much appreciate is the willingness of our residents to have calm, focused, and straight-forward conversations with us at the City --whether with employees or elected officials—to move in a positive direction. In addition to this, residents are also suggesting solutions; this is quite helpful as it gives City employees insight as to what residents really need to know and what might work moving forward. I thank Mr. Knauber (who began this petition) for personally keeping me informed of his work, for breaking down the issue, as he sees it, so well, and for providing possible solutions. This is a complicated issue with many moving parts and no one person is responsible for everything. Our residents are working with the City and communicating effectively. Thank you, Middletown. Next, City Staff is working diligently on this issue. It is one of the highest --if not the highest-- priorities at the moment. As things progress, City Manager Ashley Comb’s plan is to stay in routine communication with our residents. She shared that this will be in the form of press releases on the City’s website (cityofmiddletown.org) and on the City’s social media accounts. For the most up-to-date information, please visit these sites. Some things can be communicated quickly; other things take more time. Some things may never be able to be shared, but reasons as to why that is, can be given, and that is something I am encouraging as part of the City’s communications for our residents. The City hears you and is working on a clear and workable way forward for our residents. City Manager Combs has assured that there will be no shut-offs in the month of December. If you have further suggestions, please consider posting them here on change.org so that everyone may have access to the same information. You may certainly also always contact the City directly. Thank you for engaging with us, Middletown; we are listening. Sincerely, Elizabeth Slamka Mayor of Middletown, Ohio
Paul Horn
Paul Horn
Middletown City Council
Ashley Combs
Ashley Combs
Middletown City Manager
Jennifer Carter
Jennifer Carter
Middletown City Council

Supporter Voices

Petition Updates