Let's get more signatures for this petition

Lawsuit lawyers Keira M. v. Quin: Overview of the 2025 Tennessee Foster Care Class Action Lawsuit Case Name and Filing Details • Full Title: Keira M. et al. v. Quin (referring to Tennessee Department of Children’s Services Commissioner Margie Quin). • Filed: May 19, 2025, in the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Tennessee (Nashville). • Plaintiffs: 13 named foster children (ages 1–16), represented by nonprofits including A Better Childhood (a New York-based child welfare litigation group), Bass, Berry & Sims, The Barbara McDowell Social Justice Center, Willkie Farr & Gallagher, and Wang Hecker. The suit represents a proposed general class of all ~9,000 children in Tennessee’s foster care system, plus an Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) subclass for those with emotional, psychological, cognitive, or physical disabilities (estimated 25–30% of the class). • Defendants: DCS Commissioner Margie Quin, Deputy Commissioner Carla Aaron, and Deputy Commissioner of Child Programs Karen Jointer Bryant. • Status (as of November 25, 2025): Ongoing; no trial date set. The Tennessee Attorney General’s Office (representing DCS) has declined comment. This is the second major class action against DCS in 2025, following John Doe et al. v. Quin (filed June 2024, focused on facility abuses). Background and Context Tennessee’s foster care system has faced repeated federal scrutiny, most notably in the landmark Brian A. v. Haslam (filed 2000, settled 2001, oversight ended 2019), which exposed severe abuses, over-institutionalization, and inadequate mental health care, leading to reforms that reduced institutional placements by 88% and improved permanency rates (e.g., 50% of children achieving reunification or adoption within 12 months). However, post-oversight gains eroded, with caseloads ballooning (up to 70% above national averages in 2025), foster entries rising 10%+ since 2016 (driven by opioid crises), and placement instability persisting (e.g., 60% of 2022 entrants experiencing 3+ moves). Recent scandals include children sleeping in DCS offices/hotels (hundreds affected in 2022–2024, despite rate hikes) and reliance on private contractors for ~70% of placements, amid shortages of therapeutic beds. The suit argues DCS regressed into “widespread and systematic” violations, especially for disabled children, breaching constitutional due process, the ADA (Title II), and Rehabilitation Act. Key Allegations The 74-page complaint details how DCS “exposes children to significant risk of harm” through systemic failures, prioritizing quantity over quality and echoing pre-Brian A. issues. Core claims include: • Unsafe and Unstable Placements: Frequent moves (e.g., 7+ caseworkers and homes over 8 years for some siblings), sibling separations (e.g., Amara and Zane, apart for 2+ years), and “warehousing” in inadequate settings like offices, hotels, transitional homes, or out-of-state facilities. High-needs children (e.g., with behavioral/medical issues) wait months for beds, exacerbating trauma. • Failure to Protect from Abuse/Neglect: Inadequate vetting of foster parents/institutions, ignored abuse reports (including sexual abuse), and over-reliance on for-profit private facilities (billing $50–$300+/day, higher for “high-needs” labels). • Overburdened Caseworkers: Caseloads exceed caps (despite Quin’s 2023 claims of limits for new hires), leading to poor monitoring and delayed investigations. • Denial of Essential Services: Lack of individualized case plans (within 60 days), mental health/medical care, and education (e.g., no IEPs for disabled children). ADA-specific violations include unnecessary institutionalization over community/kinship placements (breaching Olmstead v. L.C.’s integration mandate), denied therapies (e.g., speech/occupational for physical disabilities), and discrimination via isolation or unmet accommodations. • Named Plaintiffs’ Stories: Examples include Keira (11, re-entered care after prior adoption due to bio-parent abuse, 9 months in limbo); Amara and Zane (sibling pair bounced through institutions, with Zane placed in a teen facility at age 7). These practices allegedly violate federal laws by denying stable childhoods, education, healthcare, and permanency, with disabled children facing heightened risks (e.g., worsened PTSD, developmental delays, or unmanaged conditions like autism or mobility impairments). Relief Sought The suit requests injunctive and declaratory relief, including: • Prohibiting harmful practices (e.g., unsafe placements, abuse cover-ups). • Mandating reforms: Individualized case plans within 60 days; sibling prioritization; caseload reductions; thorough foster/institution vetting; abuse investigations; permanent home facilitation; and full medical/mental health/educational services. • ADA-specific: Disability screenings, training, and policies for community integration (e.g., kinship over institutions). • Broader oversight: Potential federal monitor reinstatement, similar to Brian A., to enforce compliance. Broader Impact and Connections This case highlights Tennessee’s “hybrid” foster care model—state-funded (60% federal Title IV-E, 40% state sales tax) but privatized delivery—as a “worst of both worlds”: bureaucratic shortages (e.g., 13% placement drop in 2023) alongside profit incentives (20–25% higher reimbursements for disabled children, ~$11,000–$21,900/year vs. $9,000–$10,500 for non-disabled). Critics call it “neoliberal child welfare” (left) or “cronyism” (right), fueling kinship placement delays (e.g., via ICPC) and out-of-pocket family costs ($200–$1,000/month). It builds on John Doe v. Quin (abuse in facilities) and echoes Arkansas parallels (e.g., U.S. v. Arkansas, 2009 ADA suit). As of late 2025, DCS’s $1.2B budget includes $182M+ for expansions (e.g., 118+ beds in 2023), but advocates demand kinship-first reforms to cut trauma and costs. For updates, monitor abetterchildhood.org or federal court dockets. Hi all, we've reached 35 signatures on this petition—thank you so much for your support! Would you help us keep the momentum going by sharing? Posting to Facebook groups, Instagram stories, WhatsApp, or sending it directly via text or email all make a big difference. Thanks for being part of this!