Take down the Columbus Statue at the Scotch Plains Municipal Building

The Issue

Scotch Plains is a town that promotes diversity and equality for all of its residents and contains a significant amount of Black people, Indigenous people, and people of color (BIPOC). That being said, many of these Scotch Plains residents have had their cultures, heritages, and ancestries decimated from the racist colonization, genocide, rape, and enslavement of millions of BIPOC at the hands of Christopher Columbus. The effects of the barbaric Trans-Atlantic Slave trade that lasted over 400 years are still felt to this day by Scotch Plains's current community members of Black, Indigenous, Latinx, and Hispanic descent.

 

There is currently a statue of Christopher Columbus's hand that sits in the center of town in front of the Scotch Plains police department and municipal building. We, as taxpayers of a town that is supposed to promote diversity and equality, demand that the statue be removed immediately as it promotes an atmosphere of white supremacy, imperialism, genocide, racism, and rape. Having a statue in front of the most notable building in town only perpetuates these ideas of racism and white supremacy that exist currently within our own town and this country. Columbus is not reflective of the supposed views of our town and he should not be martyred in this town. 

We demand the removal of the Christopher Columbus statue immediately

This petition had 2,690 supporters

The Issue

Scotch Plains is a town that promotes diversity and equality for all of its residents and contains a significant amount of Black people, Indigenous people, and people of color (BIPOC). That being said, many of these Scotch Plains residents have had their cultures, heritages, and ancestries decimated from the racist colonization, genocide, rape, and enslavement of millions of BIPOC at the hands of Christopher Columbus. The effects of the barbaric Trans-Atlantic Slave trade that lasted over 400 years are still felt to this day by Scotch Plains's current community members of Black, Indigenous, Latinx, and Hispanic descent.

 

There is currently a statue of Christopher Columbus's hand that sits in the center of town in front of the Scotch Plains police department and municipal building. We, as taxpayers of a town that is supposed to promote diversity and equality, demand that the statue be removed immediately as it promotes an atmosphere of white supremacy, imperialism, genocide, racism, and rape. Having a statue in front of the most notable building in town only perpetuates these ideas of racism and white supremacy that exist currently within our own town and this country. Columbus is not reflective of the supposed views of our town and he should not be martyred in this town. 

We demand the removal of the Christopher Columbus statue immediately

The Decision Makers

Deputy Mayor Josh Losardo
Deputy Mayor Josh Losardo
Responded
I learned this morning about a petition seeking the removal of the Christopher Columbus monument that rests immediately in front of the Scotch Plains Municipal Building since 1998. I admit having mixed feelings about its removal. I remember being taught that “Columbus discovered America” and have celebrated Columbus Day every year. It cannot be denied, however, that what we once learned in school omits hard truths about human history. In this case, there is compelling evidence that Columbus’ exploration resulted in the deprivation of human rights for many. It is a compelling question whether to honor individuals who lived long ago and may not have acted justly according to the standards of today. Last Columbus Day, I listened as Paul Raphael, president of the Scotch Plains-Fanwood chapter of UNICO, shared “I'm sure Columbus had his faults, as we all do, but he lived in a different time and in a different world… to me, Columbus represents the values of discovery and risk that are at the heart of the American Dream." I expect that many residents feel similarly. It is for these reasons that I have asked that our next Town Council meeting, on July 21, 2020, include a discussion about the Columbus monument. I hope that residents with distinct viewpoints participate.
Philip Murphy
Former New Jersey Governor
Mayor Alexander Smith
Mayor Alexander Smith
Councilwoman Elizabeth Stamler
Councilwoman Elizabeth Stamler
Councilman Roshan White
Councilman Roshan White

Petition Updates