
Eliminate backup defense and kicker spots in fantasy football
The Issue
Fantasy football is an intense and strategic game, yet sometimes our joy is overshadowed by unnecessary complexities. One such complexity is the inclusion of backup defense and kicker slots in several leagues. Personally, it's been a source of frustration that detracts from the excitement of managerial strategy and drafting the perfect team each week.
In countless leagues, managers are forced to allocate valuable roster spots to backup defenses and kickers, limiting their ability to stash breakout players or gamble on high-upside talent. This detracts from the original spirit of fantasy football where the emphasis should be on strategic decision-making and player analysis, rather than on maintaining redundant positions.
Moreover, statistically, the difference in points among top-tier defenses and kickers and their backups is marginal. According to Fantasy Football Analytics, during the 2022 NFL season, the top 10 performing kickers had an average point variance of just 2.3 points per game compared to the next tier. Similarly, defenses showed minimal range in week-to-week performance against lower-ranked teams.
Many fantasy players share the sentiment that focusing on skill positions offers a more engaging experience. By eliminating backup defense and kicker slots, leagues can become more competitive and fun. There's a growing consensus among fantasy players that the current model stifles creativity and active roster management.
Therefore, we urge fantasy football league commissioners and platform providers to consider revising league rules to exclude these positions. Let’s shift the focus back to impactful player choices and strategic game-play.
Join us in calling for a change in league policies to better reflect the interests and enjoyment of all players. Signing this petition helps advocate for an improved fantasy football system that prioritizes player engagement and fosters a dynamic gaming experience. Please sign and share to support a more vibrant and proactive fantasy football league.

10
The Issue
Fantasy football is an intense and strategic game, yet sometimes our joy is overshadowed by unnecessary complexities. One such complexity is the inclusion of backup defense and kicker slots in several leagues. Personally, it's been a source of frustration that detracts from the excitement of managerial strategy and drafting the perfect team each week.
In countless leagues, managers are forced to allocate valuable roster spots to backup defenses and kickers, limiting their ability to stash breakout players or gamble on high-upside talent. This detracts from the original spirit of fantasy football where the emphasis should be on strategic decision-making and player analysis, rather than on maintaining redundant positions.
Moreover, statistically, the difference in points among top-tier defenses and kickers and their backups is marginal. According to Fantasy Football Analytics, during the 2022 NFL season, the top 10 performing kickers had an average point variance of just 2.3 points per game compared to the next tier. Similarly, defenses showed minimal range in week-to-week performance against lower-ranked teams.
Many fantasy players share the sentiment that focusing on skill positions offers a more engaging experience. By eliminating backup defense and kicker slots, leagues can become more competitive and fun. There's a growing consensus among fantasy players that the current model stifles creativity and active roster management.
Therefore, we urge fantasy football league commissioners and platform providers to consider revising league rules to exclude these positions. Let’s shift the focus back to impactful player choices and strategic game-play.
Join us in calling for a change in league policies to better reflect the interests and enjoyment of all players. Signing this petition helps advocate for an improved fantasy football system that prioritizes player engagement and fosters a dynamic gaming experience. Please sign and share to support a more vibrant and proactive fantasy football league.

Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on September 15, 2026