

Don’t Let MLB Expansion Destroy Our Rivalries
The Issue
Baseball is built on rivalries. For over a century, the Yankees and Red Sox have defined East Coast baseball. The Cubs and Cardinals clash has stretched across generations. Dodgers vs. Giants? That’s more than a game—it’s a cultural tradition that started in New York and migrated west.
Now, with Major League Baseball actively planning expansion and considering divisional realignment, many fans fear what could be lost. These iconic matchups—so essential to the soul of the game—may be split across new divisions or reduced to just a few games a year.
MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred and league officials are discussing ways to accommodate new cities, possibly moving to four eight-team divisions or reshuffling teams based on geography. But amid all this, there's been little public commitment to preserving the rivalries that give the sport its identity.
Fans don’t just buy tickets—they buy into history. And when baseball loses its emotional roots, it loses something irreplaceable. We’re not against expansion. New cities deserve teams, and the game should grow. But not at the expense of what has made it great.
We, the undersigned, call on Commissioner Rob Manfred and the MLB Executive Council to publicly commit to protecting historic rivalries as part of any expansion or realignment plan. That means guaranteeing these teams continue to face each other regularly, whether in the same division or through smart scheduling.
This isn’t just about tradition—it’s about what brings fans to the ballpark and keeps generations connected to the game.
Don’t break what makes baseball matter. Keep the rivalries alive.
39
The Issue
Baseball is built on rivalries. For over a century, the Yankees and Red Sox have defined East Coast baseball. The Cubs and Cardinals clash has stretched across generations. Dodgers vs. Giants? That’s more than a game—it’s a cultural tradition that started in New York and migrated west.
Now, with Major League Baseball actively planning expansion and considering divisional realignment, many fans fear what could be lost. These iconic matchups—so essential to the soul of the game—may be split across new divisions or reduced to just a few games a year.
MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred and league officials are discussing ways to accommodate new cities, possibly moving to four eight-team divisions or reshuffling teams based on geography. But amid all this, there's been little public commitment to preserving the rivalries that give the sport its identity.
Fans don’t just buy tickets—they buy into history. And when baseball loses its emotional roots, it loses something irreplaceable. We’re not against expansion. New cities deserve teams, and the game should grow. But not at the expense of what has made it great.
We, the undersigned, call on Commissioner Rob Manfred and the MLB Executive Council to publicly commit to protecting historic rivalries as part of any expansion or realignment plan. That means guaranteeing these teams continue to face each other regularly, whether in the same division or through smart scheduling.
This isn’t just about tradition—it’s about what brings fans to the ballpark and keeps generations connected to the game.
Don’t break what makes baseball matter. Keep the rivalries alive.
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on August 26, 2025