Change social care decisions to be evidence and fact-based not probability

Recent signers:
Debra Green and 19 others have signed recently.

The Issue

Losing my children to social services was a traumatic experience, one that unfortunately stemmed from decisions based solely on "probabilities" rather than concrete evidence. After a lengthy and emotionally draining battle, I finally regained custody, but the scars from the experience remain. Despite presenting undeniable proof of my fitness as a parent, the system I encountered seemed preoccupied with statistics and projections. Our children deserve to be seen as individuals, not mere numbers. The current approach within the social care system too often relies on generalized probabilities instead of factual evidence, leading to misjudgments and harm to families. The principle of making decisions based on evidence is crucial in ensuring that families are treated fairly and are given the support they need without unjustified separationsnAccording to a 2022 report by the Family Rights Group, many cases handled by social services involve decisions made on assumptions that are not backed by solid evidence. For example, during that year, over 60% of the cases reviewed involved decisions where tangible evidence was either weak or circumstantial. Such an approach not only misleads outcomes but undermines the trust of those who seek help. A overhaul is necessary to ensure all social care professionals operate with a mandate that prioritizes evidence and facts over probabilities. This change would require mandatory training for social workers on the importance of evidence-based decision-making and setting up an independent oversight body to review contentious cases. By doing so, we can foster a system that truly supports families, making sure decisions are beneficial and transparent. It’s time to shift the system within social services to one that values each individual's circumstances based on verifiable facts. This petition calls for a legislative change to mandate that social care decisions be rooted in solid, evidence-based practices. Please join me in advocating for this crucial reform. Sign this petition to help promote a fairer and more just social care system for all families.

92

Recent signers:
Debra Green and 19 others have signed recently.

The Issue

Losing my children to social services was a traumatic experience, one that unfortunately stemmed from decisions based solely on "probabilities" rather than concrete evidence. After a lengthy and emotionally draining battle, I finally regained custody, but the scars from the experience remain. Despite presenting undeniable proof of my fitness as a parent, the system I encountered seemed preoccupied with statistics and projections. Our children deserve to be seen as individuals, not mere numbers. The current approach within the social care system too often relies on generalized probabilities instead of factual evidence, leading to misjudgments and harm to families. The principle of making decisions based on evidence is crucial in ensuring that families are treated fairly and are given the support they need without unjustified separationsnAccording to a 2022 report by the Family Rights Group, many cases handled by social services involve decisions made on assumptions that are not backed by solid evidence. For example, during that year, over 60% of the cases reviewed involved decisions where tangible evidence was either weak or circumstantial. Such an approach not only misleads outcomes but undermines the trust of those who seek help. A overhaul is necessary to ensure all social care professionals operate with a mandate that prioritizes evidence and facts over probabilities. This change would require mandatory training for social workers on the importance of evidence-based decision-making and setting up an independent oversight body to review contentious cases. By doing so, we can foster a system that truly supports families, making sure decisions are beneficial and transparent. It’s time to shift the system within social services to one that values each individual's circumstances based on verifiable facts. This petition calls for a legislative change to mandate that social care decisions be rooted in solid, evidence-based practices. Please join me in advocating for this crucial reform. Sign this petition to help promote a fairer and more just social care system for all families.

The Decision Makers

Family Rights Group
Family Rights Group

Supporter Voices

Petition Updates