Crisafulli + Minns: Shark nets don't work, replace them and bring us into the 21st century

Recent signers:
Martyn Carr and 19 others have signed recently.

The issue

Queensland (QLD) and New South Wales (NSW) Governments are responsible for the longest-running marine cull in history.

Together via the use of shark nets and baited drumlines (large fishing hooks), over 100,000 sharks other marine animals have been killed. These tactics and methods are cruel, outdated, and have been proved time and again not to protect swimmers and surfers. 

These archaic and ineffective methods pose a huge risk — not only to endangered shark populations — but also to whales, dolphins, turtles, dugongs, and many other wildlife species.

Even the swimmers and surfers these programs are designed to 'protect' are put at risk by them, by not just allowing these beachgoers a false sense of security, but also by attracting large sharks to predate on dead and dying hooked or entangled animals.

We demand decision-makers at all levels stop killing sharks and other marine life, and to modernise shark bite mitigation in Australia. We specifically call for:

  1. The NSW and QLD Governments need to immediately remove shark nets and catch-and-kill drumlines from their waters, and move to deploy modern non-lethal technologies. 
  2. The Australian Government needs to immediately close the 43B loophole in the EPBC Act that allows the culling of protected species at the hands of QLD and NSW Governments, without any formal approvals. 

Shark nets and catch-and-kill drumlines are a beach safety approach from a bygone era. These fishing devices aim to reduce shark incidents by destroying the local shark population.

In 1937 (NSW program commencement) or even 1962 (QLD program commencement), we can forgive how decision makers may have thought this to have been a logical approach. At the time, we had no idea how migratory Great White, Bull, or Tiger sharks were. It was plausible that 'local populations' of these species existed.

We know now, through GPS tracking, genetic sampling, photo ID, and a variety of other scientific methods that this is not the case. They are highly migratory and rarely spend more than a day, maximum two, in any one place. This fact alone, makes the fishing approach of shark nets and drumlines to "fish down local populations" non-sensical and one that must cease.

It is time that the Government stops lying to its citizens and tourists, and instead provides education on how to safely enjoy our oceans, without slaughtering the wildlife that calls it home. 

Petition inspired by Envoy: Shark Cull (2021)

 

 

165,655

Recent signers:
Martyn Carr and 19 others have signed recently.

The issue

Queensland (QLD) and New South Wales (NSW) Governments are responsible for the longest-running marine cull in history.

Together via the use of shark nets and baited drumlines (large fishing hooks), over 100,000 sharks other marine animals have been killed. These tactics and methods are cruel, outdated, and have been proved time and again not to protect swimmers and surfers. 

These archaic and ineffective methods pose a huge risk — not only to endangered shark populations — but also to whales, dolphins, turtles, dugongs, and many other wildlife species.

Even the swimmers and surfers these programs are designed to 'protect' are put at risk by them, by not just allowing these beachgoers a false sense of security, but also by attracting large sharks to predate on dead and dying hooked or entangled animals.

We demand decision-makers at all levels stop killing sharks and other marine life, and to modernise shark bite mitigation in Australia. We specifically call for:

  1. The NSW and QLD Governments need to immediately remove shark nets and catch-and-kill drumlines from their waters, and move to deploy modern non-lethal technologies. 
  2. The Australian Government needs to immediately close the 43B loophole in the EPBC Act that allows the culling of protected species at the hands of QLD and NSW Governments, without any formal approvals. 

Shark nets and catch-and-kill drumlines are a beach safety approach from a bygone era. These fishing devices aim to reduce shark incidents by destroying the local shark population.

In 1937 (NSW program commencement) or even 1962 (QLD program commencement), we can forgive how decision makers may have thought this to have been a logical approach. At the time, we had no idea how migratory Great White, Bull, or Tiger sharks were. It was plausible that 'local populations' of these species existed.

We know now, through GPS tracking, genetic sampling, photo ID, and a variety of other scientific methods that this is not the case. They are highly migratory and rarely spend more than a day, maximum two, in any one place. This fact alone, makes the fishing approach of shark nets and drumlines to "fish down local populations" non-sensical and one that must cease.

It is time that the Government stops lying to its citizens and tourists, and instead provides education on how to safely enjoy our oceans, without slaughtering the wildlife that calls it home. 

Petition inspired by Envoy: Shark Cull (2021)

 

 

Support now

165,655


The Decision Makers

Michael Berkman
Greens MP for Maiwar
Responded
Dear friends, As the Queensland Greens’ spokesperson for fisheries and animal welfare, I want to thank you for standing up against the Government’s baseless and cruel shark control program. Because of you and the almost 150,000 others who’ve signed this petition, it is getting harder and harder for the Labor State Government to justify their program. I know from my experience trying to raise the matter in Parliament and being shut down by the responsible minister, Mark Furner, that it’s an increasingly sensitive topic. I’d be sensitive too if my Government was needlessly killing and maiming sharks, whales and other marine life without any evidence that it’s actually making swimmers safer. But there is one thing politicians are more sensitive about than anything else, and that’s losing their jobs… which gives us an opportunity. This year we are facing two elections in Queensland. And with a new Premier looking to keep his spot, now is the perfect time to up the pressure. Queensland Parliament has so far refused to let me table this petition, so I’m asking you to contact your MPs directly and let them know you want shark nets and catch-and-kill drumlines out of our waters. You can find your local MP and their contact details below. Right now, the Greens are the only ones willing to take this issue on in Queensland Parliament. But if we can show major party politicians that their voters care about this issue, they might just change their minds. And if they don’t, perhaps they’ll have to deal with a bunch more MPs like me in Parliament after the election, pushing for more evidence-based and humane policies! Thanks again for taking action. Don’t take your foot off the pedal now, and we won’t either. Yours in hope, Michael
Peter Whish-Wilson
Senator for lutruwita/Tasmania
Responded
Dear supporters, Thank you for adding your name to the chorus of people now calling for an end to 86 years of shark culling in Australia, and for shark nets and lethal drumlines to be removed from our beaches. It’s been a long time coming but the campaign to end the culture war on sharks and better protect marine wildlife is really gaining traction, and government's are facing more pressure than ever before to act. Only recently did the Federal Government finally respond (albeit six years late!) to an important Senate inquiry I initiated into how best to mitigate the risk of human/shark interactions and get the balance right between protecting BOTH precious human and marine life. Many sharks killed in state-based shark control measures are protected and endangered under federal environment laws, so the Federal Government has an important leadership role in driving national investment in emerging shark risk mitigation measures and technologies to protect ocean goers. Rest assured that I continue to advocate hard in the Senate to protect precious marine wildlife, and push for the urgent implementation of modern-day alternatives to shark nets and lethal drum lines that better protect ocean-users and the environment. Specifically my fellow federal Greens colleagues and I are fighting for: An immediate closure of the 43B loophole in the EPBC Act that allows the culling of protected species at the hands of state governments, without any formal approvals, undermining critical conservation recovery plans. Federal funding of $50 million over ten years to supercharge research and development of non-lethal shark risk mitigation measures that can replace nets and lethal drum lines; The establishment of a National Sharks Working Group across all states that will look at multiple ways to make ocean goers safer; The establishment of a publicly accessible national database of interactions with shark control measures, critical for research and education-awareness programs. Having the ACCC investigate all existing shark mitigation technologies for efficacy and establish national advertising and product promotion standards Instead of embarking on a culture war on sharks and endorsing destructive, unscientific and largely ineffective, shark control measures, I urge governments and media to look at the science and the Senate inquiry report and understand safety in our oceans and the protection of vulnerable species aren’t binary options, both are possible and can be done much more effectively. Thanks again for your support!! In solidarity, Pete
Emma Hurst
NSW MLC, Animal Justice Party
Responded
Last month, at the request of Envoy Foundation, I took this petition and tabled it in NSW Parliament. It was eminently important that Members of Parliament, including the Minister for Environment and Minister for Agriculture, were made aware of the serious community opposition and cruelty caused by the ongoing use of shark nets. Shark nets are cruel, indiscriminate, and ineffective. Unfortunately, on 1 September 2022, these killer nets were once again deployed across NSW beaches, despite the community and many Councils calling on the NSW Government to stop. Shark nets also continue to be deployed on Queensland beaches. This is simply unacceptable. Shark nets kill hundreds of animals including threatened species. From climate change to pollution and fishing, marine animals are already seriously under threat. We should not be adding these cruel killer nets into the mix. The continued use of these nets is even more unjustifiable when you consider the research that shark nets are not effective at protecting beachgoers, instead creating a false sense of security. Furthermore, there are humane, and effective alternatives available. Increased lifeguard patrols, drone and helicopter surveillance and personal shark deterrents are all methods that can keep beach-goers safe without the mass killing of marine animals. The fight is not over – we will continue to campaign to remove the shark nets and protect marine life, both in NSW and QLD. Thank you for supporting this petition, and for being a voice for the animals. The Hon. Emma Hurst MLC – Animal Justice Party
Cate Faehrmann
NSW, MLC, Greens
Responded
Dear supporters, As one of nearly 150,000 people who have taken action calling to stop the slaughter in our water, thank you! This shows just how much support there is in the community for our precious marine life, and yes, including sharks. Shark nets kill turtles, dolphins, whales, penguins, seals and critically endangered grey nurse sharks every year, but don’t actually keep people safe. It’s completely unacceptable that, even with this knowledge, they continue to be rolled out for 8 months of the year here in NSW when there are safer and far more effective methods that will keep people safer at beaches. Thankfully, the community campaign to get shark nets and baited drum lines out of our oceans is growing and the size of this petition shows that. Rest assured, that by raising your voice and taking action for marine animals you are being heard. I know for a fact that the NSW Government is under a lot of pressure to end this cruel practice. So as long as we don’t give up I am certainly hopeful that this could be the last summer that we see nets in NSW waters. Here’s what I’m doing to support the campaign. As a NSW Member of Parliament, I’m working across party lines to build support, and to pressure the responsible Ministers. I’ve also launched an online tool below that you can use to send a quick email to the two Ministers who have the power to get the nets out in NSW with the stroke of a pen - Environment Minister Penny Sharpe and Agriculture Minister Tara Moriarty. I urge you to use the form to take action now. The most powerful thing you can do is keep up the pressure by writing emails, making phone calls, attending protests and making noise on social media until governments act. Keep an eye out for more in the coming months. And thank you again for everything you do to save our turtles, sharks, dolphins, rays and all marine life. Cate Faehrmann NSW Greens MP
Murray Watt
Murray Watt
Federal Environment Minister

Supporter voices

Petition updates